List Mgmt. 2019 Draft Thread

[Max the great]

Don't care what it takes. Just get me a Xavier Duursma clone... preferably with a cool name and a bow and arrow as well. Love that kid

 

[bird_man]

I seriously doubt we have player we can afford to lose who gets us a top 20 pick though. Might get back into the late second round or something unless Stuv or Carlisle want out.

Well Carlisle is yet to sign and Steven looks gone.

 

[RWB4life]

What's the go with kemp?

Saw he did his ACL but that he's played all over including the midfield? Don't know much about the start aside from the top 2.

Is he a chance to last until end of the first road if we downgraded with gws.

 

[Mikka84]

What's the go with kemp?

Saw he did his ACL but that he's played all over including the midfield? Don't know much about the start aside from the top 2.

Is he a chance to last until end of the first road if we downgraded with gws.

I'd suggest after the injury he will nearly fall outside the top 20. Clubs are all about the now.

There are no real mids at our pick, likely 5-7. I'm not against trading it in the slightest. If we can secure a true mid through the trade of this pick, that would be my preference.

 

[Ducky Tie]

I'd suggest after the injury he will nearly fall outside the top 20. Clubs are all about the now.

There are no real mids at our pick, likely 5-7. I'm not against trading it in the slightest. If we can secure a true mid through the trade of this pick, that would be my preference.

If Rowell, Anderson, Young and Ash go top 4, Serong and Flanders would be around at that 5-7 mark. Flanders I'd be very happy with. Serong - don't rate his kicking so not keen.

 

[bird_man]

What's the go with kemp?

Saw he did his ACL but that he's played all over including the midfield? Don't know much about the start aside from the top 2.

Is he a chance to last until end of the first road if we downgraded with gws.

He'll definitely slide now. Could make it to Giants first (Essendon pick)

I think it's going to be hard to trade down unless we finish bottom 4 though which looks unlikely.

 

[Mikka84]

If Rowell, Anderson, Young and Ash go top 4, Serong and Flanders would be around at that 5-7 mark. Flanders I'd be very happy with. Serong - don't rate his kicking so not keen.

IMO - we have enough young kids at this stage of our list. We have King and Bytel to come on, who are basically brand new recruits.

I'd like us to get some mature players that compliment our list with this pick.

I know people don't like it, but Jones and Papley to me are worth more than pick 5 at this stage.

If possible, pick 5 and next years first for Whitfield. Or take the risk on the above and hope he comes over as a RFA next year.

Coniglio still not resigned is very interesting. More to play out on that one you sense.

 

[Mighty_sainter]

Have a feeling serong shaping as our pick if we have pick 5. That our we trade it imo

 

[Sarcoidevo]

Probably should be in the trade thread but f Steven wants out (say to Geelong) what draft picks could we realistically expect to get for him

This year's first / next year's first / 2nd rounder / a swap of this year's first picks plus their 1st next year?

After the weekends win I am not sure we really need him going forward given his age and the issues he faced this year

 

[bird_man]

Probably should be in the trade thread but f Steven wants out (say to Geelong) what draft picks could we realistically expect to get for him

This year's first / next year's first / 2nd rounder / a swap of this year's first picks plus their 1st next year?

After the weekends win I am not sure we really need him going forward given his age and the issues he faced this year

Probably a late second unfortunately

 

[RWB4life]

Probably should be in the trade thread but f Steven wants out (say to Geelong) what draft picks could we realistically expect to get for him

This year's first / next year's first / 2nd rounder / a swap of this year's first picks plus their 1st next year?

After the weekends win I am not sure we really need him going forward given his age and the issues he faced this year

Honestly I think the priority pick will be shut down and it might be wishful thinking but I'm think the AFL might lean on Geelong to overpay as a bit of a priority like Ablett. I can see a late first or a second and someone like constable.

 

[BrutThough]

Probably a late second unfortunately

Geelong's second will be around pick 40 once you add in academy selections etc, which feels like we are being extremely ripped off.

 

[ScrappyDo]

I'd suggest after the injury he will nearly fall outside the top 20. Clubs are all about the now.

There are no real mids at our pick, likely 5-7. I'm not against trading it in the slightest. If we can secure a true mid through the trade of this pick, that would be my preference.

Surely without a pp we're zero chance of landing Anderson.
Time to get Calders off GWS and grab Kemp with pick 12-18 that we get from them too.. Value is value at the end of the day..

 

[bird_man]

Geelong's second will be around pick 40 once you add in academy selections etc, which feels like we are being extremely ripped off.

This is why I'd be chasing one of their young players.

 

[Mikka84]

Surely without a pp we're zero chance of landing Anderson.
Time to get Calders off GWS and grab Kemp with pick 12-18 that we get from them too.. Value is value at the end of the day..

I go round and round with Caldwell. But three games back from injury and he's straight into the best every game.

If his body holds up, genuine star of the future. Worth the risk for sure. Especially if we get a late first back.

 

[ScrappyDo]

I go round and round with Caldwell. But two games back from injury and he's straight into the best both games.

If his body holds up, genuine star of the future. Worth the risk for sure. Especially if we get a late first back.

I'm the same, and I'd not want another injured draftee. But "if" we can reap Jye, Kemp and Bytel from picks 6 and 41 then we only need one of them to come good to get our value from it. Jye looks a star, Jack looks a giant version of Sam Mitchell, Kemp l haven't seen but I'll back gringo!

 

[majortinkle]

IMO - we have enough young kids at this stage of our list. We have King and Bytel to come on, who are basically brand new recruits.

I'd like us to get some mature players that compliment our list with this pick.

I know people don't like it, but Jones and Papley to me are worth more than pick 5 at this stage.

If possible, pick 5 and next years first for Whitfield. Or take the risk on the above and hope he comes over as a RFA next year.

Coniglio still not resigned is very interesting. More to play out on that one you sense.

Are you talking Jones and Papley as a pair for 5 - I'd definitely do it

 

[Mikka84]

Are you talking Jones and Papley as a pair for 5 - I'd definitely do it

Yep. Sydney are on the rebuild, Longmire gets a free shot for a year or two with his new contract.

Both have said they would like/consider a club change.

Pick 5 gets it done imo. Gives Sydney pick 4 and 5 in the draft and they can go hard rebuilding.

 

[Gosaints12]

If Rowell, Anderson, Young and Ash go top 4, Serong and Flanders would be around at that 5-7 mark. Flanders I'd be very happy with. Serong - don't rate his kicking so not keen.

That’s the top 5.
1. Rowell
2. Anderson
3. Young
4. Ash
5. Serong



On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Gosaints12]

He'll definitely slide now. Could make it to Giants first (Essendon pick)

I think it's going to be hard to trade down unless we finish bottom 4 though which looks unlikely.

Unless we trade down to Melbourne to trade up to GWS gets us Caldwell, worth it.


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Gosaints12]

IMO - we have enough young kids at this stage of our list. We have King and Bytel to come on, who are basically brand new recruits.

I'd like us to get some mature players that compliment our list with this pick.

I know people don't like it, but Jones and Papley to me are worth more than pick 5 at this stage.

If possible, pick 5 and next years first for Whitfield. Or take the risk on the above and hope he comes over as a RFA next year.

Coniglio still not resigned is very interesting. More to play out on that one you sense.

Whitfield if Cogs says no Everyday and twice on sundays.


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Gosaints12]

Surely without a pp we're zero chance of landing Anderson.
Time to get Calders off GWS and grab Kemp with pick 12-18 that we get from them too.. Value is value at the end of the day..

That’s a great trade, I only rate Caldwell as a early second Pick 19-23 ish.


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Gosaints12]

This is why I'd be chasing one of their young players.

Constable. Chuck Ross in their as well and get a first and a second.


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Gosaints12]

Yep. Sydney are on the rebuild, Longmire gets a free shot for a year or two with his new contract.

Both have said they would like/consider a club change.

Pick 5 gets it done imo. Gives Sydney pick 4 and 5 in the draft and they can go hard rebuilding.

Papley wants to wear the blue and white if North Melbourne. Jones for Carsile.

 

[MOLTEN GANGLANDS]

Papley wants to wear the blue and white if North Melbourne. Jones for Carsile.

explosive vomit