2019 Draft

Tiger_Of_Old · Nov 27, 2019

_DBF_ said:
If Carlton are trying to pip us for Stephens, I hope that Geelong get him instead lol

Luv your work _DBF_

Tiger_Of_Old · Nov 27, 2019

Grockadoc said:
And Kemp gone.

Tiger_Of_Old · Nov 27, 2019

tigers12 said:
Carlton are the laughing stock of the AFL they should relocate to Tasmania

What you got against Tassie?

69vintage · Nov 27, 2019

Mr Magic said:
Stack is a defender at best, why waste Stack in the guts and get him injured??

Stack is an Elite forward and above average defender .

On SM-A520F using BigFooty.com mobile app

Mr Magic · Nov 27, 2019

69vintage said:
Stack is an Elite forward and above average defender .

On SM-A520F using BigFooty.com mobile app

lol, Stack is the best defender we have apart from maybe Grimes and Rance.

Stack might be able to kick goals better than some others but he is a better defender for me, in fact as a defender he is elite

You are highlighting our forward line is far from complete!!

mad_tiggy911 · Nov 27, 2019

Would like Rivers at our next pick tbh.

Tiger_Of_Old · Nov 28, 2019

nick1408 said:
Seems a very Reece Conca pick

No that was Port.

4tune8 · Nov 28, 2019

Mr Magic said:
lol, Stack is the best defender we have apart from maybe Grimes and Rance.

Stack might be able to kick goals better than some others but he is a better defender for me, in fact as a defender he is elite

You are highlighting our forward line is far from complete!!

Geez bucko, you talk some shit sometimes. No love for Vlastuin or Houli?

To say he's the best defender we have apart from MAYBE Grimes and Rance tells me that you have a screw loose.

Ok, I know I shouldn't respond to your comments....but sheesh!!

docko911 · Nov 28, 2019

Mr Magic said:
I would take a punt on Williams and Taheny but do not anticipate them to reach our picks. Fraser Phillips for a late stab otherwise 2021 focus.

I had a look at Dow.

He runs a 3.06 20 metre sprint which is considered average. He is 183 cm 4 cm less than his brother he is still on the light side at 76 cm. The trouble is he is inconsistent to per Afldraft central profile. He will need to get better enduro and improve size and strength. Will this affect his speed and consistency?

Can he play back in a role before improving consistency??

The thing is the lack of a real competitive strength like size or speed could be why he is inconsistent apart from injury. I think atm he is a project player but I wish him the best in his development and I hope he really accelerates his development

3rd in agility.

db26 · Nov 28, 2019

Guys back our footy department recruitment team have did well in recruiting. 2 flags in 3 years and talent in our vfl got my full backing.Alot of whingeing here.

Mr Magic · Nov 28, 2019

docko911 said:
3rd in agility.

If you are talking about Dow agility is not everything. It is not unimportant but speed, endurance for overall impact is probably more relevant especially in contested scenarios.

Agility is inconsequential if you cannot get to the contest or do not have the power to break a contest or speed to break away.

Cyril and Daniel are probably high on agility but they also had speed to break away. Dow does not have the don't argue Dusty has. Is Dusty quicker than Dow?

See someone like Philp has the speed and the extra height reach at 186cm which affects his consistency and effectiveness in contests with a bit more weight and strength. You can see it in his vision when he greats a ball from height coming down and bursts through

Mr Magic · Nov 28, 2019

4tune8 said:
Geez bucko, you talk some shit sometimes. No love for Vlastuin or Houli?

To say he's the best defender we have apart from MAYBE Grimes and Rance tells me that you have a screw loose.

Ok, I know I shouldn't respond to your comments....but sheesh!!

Stack is better than Vlastuin, and Houli as defenders. Said it earlier in the year. I rate Vlastuin and Houli, I just rate Stack higher

db26 · Nov 28, 2019

Mr Magic said:
Its a bit speculative for me at that pick. Hope not but he could be a dud.

Unlike robertson does not have the consistency, nor the size of others nor the skill by foot of Bianco.

The other thing is I do not see how he gets past Bolton, Edwards, Graham etc..

He is more versatile then those players you mentioned tho can play forward to and we like our players to be like that.

69vintage · Nov 28, 2019

Mr Magic said:
lol, Stack is the best defender we have apart from maybe Grimes and Rance.

Stack might be able to kick goals better than some others but he is a better defender for me, in fact as a defender he is elite

You are highlighting our forward line is far from complete!!

Mate he rates Elite in 3 of 4 categories forward and above average or average in 3of 4 for a defender .
AFL ratings .

On SM-A520F using BigFooty.com mobile app

Mr Magic · Nov 28, 2019

db26 said:
He is more versatile then those players you mentioned tho can play forward to and we like our players to be like that.

Edwards, Graham and Bolton can play forward?? Which players are you referring to?

4tune8 · Nov 28, 2019

Mr Magic said:
Stack is better than Vlastuin, and Houli as defenders. Said it earlier in the year. I rate Vlastuin and Houli, I just rate Stack higher

Oh Boy!!!!

juss · Nov 28, 2019

Could we package our 3 picks together to get 2 around 28-30?
It's only a small difference but might help us nab one or two of the highly rated sliders still on the board.

Mr Magic · Nov 28, 2019

4tune8 said:
Oh Boy!!!!

I will be honest, if Stack was fit he would be playing in the GF last years for RFC for me

juss · Nov 28, 2019

Mr Magic said:
I will be honest, if Stack was fit he would be playing in the GF last years for RFC for me

No one disagrees with that. But Vlastuin and Houli are established stars, while Stack has the potential and ability to be our best player in a few years, he isn't close to those guys yet.

Roksman · Nov 28, 2019

juss said:
Could we package our 3 picks together to get 2 around 28-30?
It's only a small difference but might help us nab one or two of the highly rated sliders still on the board.

Don't think so.

I reckon we'll want to keep those 3 together given how the Draft is shaping up. I think our only trading activity - if any - will be offering our future first for the next few selections up until about pick 26 then we'll shelve trading.

Just my gut feel.

I think we'll try the above to try snare a Bianco, Rivers, Rantall or H Jones, and then we're out.

Hoping Brock Smith makes it to our triple selection.

4tune8 · Nov 28, 2019

Mr Magic said:
I will be honest, if Stack was fit he would be playing in the GF last years for RFC for me

And according to you....in place of Vlastuin or Houli

69vintage · Nov 28, 2019

With 7 clubs having multiple picks in front of us we should get some good kids with our next picks .

On SM-A520F using BigFooty.com mobile app

db26 · Nov 28, 2019

Mr Magic said:
Edwards, Graham and Bolton can play forward?? Which players are you referring to?

The ones being drafted you mentioned. His a pick expected to develop for 1 to 2 seasons in vfl.

Tiger_Of_Old · Nov 28, 2019

crackertiger said:
There are some very ill inform people on this board tonight ..

Agree.

roacheee · Nov 28, 2019

crackertiger said:
There are some very ill, infirm, people on this board tonight ..

Log In or Create New Account

2019 Draft

THE_GUN:"Why don't you use your reg acc"7/9/24

THE_GUN:"Why don't you use your reg acc"7/9/24

THE_GUN:"Why don't you use your reg acc"7/9/24

Premiership Player

Brownlow Medallist

🏆 🏆 🏆

THE_GUN:"Why don't you use your reg acc"7/9/24

Norm Smith Medallist

Brownlow Medallist

Norm Smith Medallist

Brownlow Medallist

Brownlow Medallist

Norm Smith Medallist

Premiership Player

Brownlow Medallist

Norm Smith Medallist

Hall of Famer

Brownlow Medallist

Hall of Famer

Premiership Player

Norm Smith Medallist

Premiership Player

Norm Smith Medallist

THE_GUN:"Why don't you use your reg acc"7/9/24

🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆

Similar threads