2019 Draft

[Marcel Proust]

Most of the better defenders in the competition were drafted as defenders and played junior football as defenders.

were they?

i think astbury was a forward ...

 

[richoatthedisco]

were they?

i think astbury was a forward ...

Astbury was a swingman as a junior, as was Darcy Moore. Rance, Hurley, Lever, Talia, Weitering were all backmen. I think McGovern and Andrews were too. May was a forward.

 

[Toadvine]

It'll be strange next week because we have the last two picks of the second round and the first pick of the 3rd.

The first two rounds are done on day one and then we'll have to wait until the next day for the 3rd round to start.

Last year west coast held the first pick of the 2nd day of the draft and on the radio they said WC had heaps of offers overnight from clubs wanting to jump and to not miss out on the player they wanted. I wonder if the same will happen this year and we can get a good deal?

 

[Marcel Proust]

Astbury was a swingman as a junior, as was Darcy Moore. Rance, Hurley, Lever, Talia, Weitering were all backmen. I think McGovern and Andrews were too. May was a forward.

well thats pretty convincing list

maybe the turning key forwards into defenders mentality is outdated

Grimes was a defender too

 

[Marcel Proust]

It'll be strange next week because we have the last two picks of the second round and the first pick of the 3rd.

The first two rounds are done on day one and then we'll have to wait until the next day for the 3rd round to start.

Last year west coast held the first pick of the 2nd day of the draft and on the radio they said WC had heaps of offers overnight from clubs wanting to jump and to not miss out on the player they wanted. I wonder if the same will happen this year and we can get a good deal?

I think its just round 1 done on the first day, so Richmonds first pick is the last?

National draft	First round: 27 November Second and subsequent rounds: 28 November

suns will be in a good position with pick 20, the first pick post the first round.


Will have all night to negotiate with other teams the best deal if they want to trade.

Assuming the gold coast pick 20 is classified as the start of round 2, not end of round 1 (?)

 

[Toadvine]

I think its just round 1 done on the first day, so Richmonds first pick is the last?

National draft	First round: 27 November Second and subsequent rounds: 28 November

suns will be in a good position with pick 20, the first pick post the first round.


Will have all night to negotiate with other teams the best deal if they want to trade.

Assuming the gold coast pick 20 is classified as the start of round 2, not end of round 1 (?)

Woops my bad. I thought they changed it this year.

 

[Toadvine]

 

[Toadvine]

Kemp into the teens you say?

 

[Jozzy]

View attachment 783830

I’d be stoked win Rantall, I’m happy to admit he really doesn’t fit an immediate hole or need. I just think he has one of the highest ceilings of all the prospects in the draft.

 

[Infamy]

Hawks-42 & 1st(2020).(How well will the Hawks go next year is the ?,while 42 would gives us picks 38,39,40,41.(gws lose 40)
Ess-31 & 33.( 56 back to them.won't need).
Coll-35 & 1st(2020)

Not sure I like any of those deals as we cut ourselves out of the best part of this years draft
The 1st round pick next year could have a decent return, but we'd want to rate the non-academy players in the pool next year higher than what we'd get now

 

[Wrenny]

Interesting that Rantall is rated elite for goals and score involvements for a midfielder in those champion data stats.
That sort of goes against the general held view that his kicking is schizen

Not necessarily, he has great ha

Kemp into the teens you say?

Shame we'll be early 20's

 

[Grockadoc]

Kemp into the teens you say?

We are dead keen on Kemp, especially losing Menadue.

 

[Wrenny]

We are dead keen on Kemp, especially losing Menadue.

Very different players there Grock

 

[theflea]

were they?

i think astbury was a forward ...

Nearly all used to be forwards not many dedicated backs but that was a while ago so it probably has shifted.

On CPH1920 using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[THE_GUN]

Imagine if we had drafted Sam Taylor at 25 instead of Balta .
KB sorted gor the next 10 years .

On SM-A520F using BigFooty.com mobile app

Lets just get him in 2 years time when he comes out of contract

Kemp into the teens you say?

How do we upgrade to the cats pick #17 if Kemp is still available ............. Unfortunately Kemp will be gone before we get a shot

 

[Grockadoc]

Very different players there Grock

More for the versatility and athleticism side of things. Menadue could play HB, HF or on a wing. Kemp provides that as well and he can go through the middle as well.

 

[Wrenny]

More for the versatility and athleticism side of things. Menadue could play HB, HF or on a wing. Kemp provides that as well and he can go through the middle as well.

Agree regarding versatility but Kemp played KPF as a junior and has play key defence aswell at 192cm. Menadue is/was more speedy/agile with versatility whilst kemp has the contested marking, strength and ability to play on ball. Both versatile but for different reasons and different positions.

 

[_RT_]

Based on the latest information regarding the possible first round picks, I've updated my rankings and I think people would be much happier

2019 Phantom Draft
Pick	Club	Name	Position	Height	Weight	Matched Bids
1	Gold Coast	Matt Rowell	Inside Midfielder	180	78
2	Gold Coast	Noah Anderson	Inside Midfielder	191	87
3	Melbourne	Luke Jackson	Ruck	199	94
4	GWS	Lachlan Ash	Medium Defender	187	83
5	GWS	Tom Green	Inside Midfielder	190	89	Match using 40 59 & 60
6	Sydney	Sam Flanders	Inside Midfielder	182	83
7	Adelaide	Fisher McAsey	KPD	197	91
8	Fremantle	Hayden Young	Medium Defender	188	83
9	Fremantle	Deven Robertson	Inside Midfielder	184	81
10	Fremantle	Liam Henry	Midfielder/Forward	180	68	Match using 49 57 & 67
11	Carlton	Caleb Serong	Inside Midfielder	178	83
12	Melbourne	Kysaiah Pickett	Small Forward/Mid	188	83
13	Hawthorn	Brodie Kemp	Utility	192	89
14	Port Adelaide	Dylan Stephens	Medium Defender	183	74
15	Bulldogs	Cody Weightman	Small Forward/Mid	178	75
16	Geelong	Josh Worrell	KPP	195	83
17	Gold Coast	Will Day	Defender/Midfielder	189	76
18	Port Adelaide	Trent Bianco	Small Forward/Mid	178	73
19	Hawthorn	Finn Maginness	Inside Midfielder	189	82	Match using 41 48 & 52 get pick 60 back
20	Geelong	Miles Bergman	Medium Forward	188	83
21	Port Adelaide	Trent Rivers	Medium Defender	188	83
22	Richmond	Cooper Stephens	Inside Midfielder	188	83
23	Gold Coast	Elijah Taylor	Medium Forward	188	77
24	Brisbane	Jay Rantall	Balanced Midfielder	185	83
25	Adelaide	Cameron Tanehy	Medium Forward	185	80
26	Adelaide	Harry Schoenberg	Inside Midfielder	182	83
27	Geelong	Sam De Koning	KPP	201	86
28	Sydney	Thomson Dow	Inside Midfielder	184	76
29	North	Harrison Jones	KPP	196	78
30	North	Sam Philp	Inside Midfielder	184	82
31	Melbourne	Jeremy Sharp	Outside Midfielder	189	81
32	Brisbane	Will Gould	KPD	192	106
33	North	Nick Bryan	Ruck	202	87
34	Port Adelaide	Jackson Mead	Balanced Midfielder	183	83	Match using 50 & 52 get 62 back
35	Essendon	Charlie Comben	Ruck	199	84
36	Sydney	Dylan Williams	Medium Forward	186	81
37	Essendon	Darcy Chirgwin	Inside Midfielder	191	80
38	Brisbane	Darcy Cassar	Utility	184	82
39	Collingwood	Mitch Georgiades	KPF	192	87
40	Geelong	Karl Finlay	KPD	192	88
41	Adelaide	Dyson Hilder	KPD	195	93
42	Richmond	Hugo Ralphsmith	Forward/Midfielder	188	75
43	Richmond	Brock Smith	Defender	189	82
44	Richmond	Cooper Sharman	KPF	192	79
45	Carlton	Ned Cahill	Small Forward/Mid	179	78
46	Sydney	Josh Honey	Balanced Midfielder	185	82
47	Adelaide	Emerson Jeka	KPF	198	91
48	West Coast	Fraser Phillips	Medium Forward	187	72
49	North	Daniel Mott	Balanced Midfielder	183	80
50	Collingwood	Ryan Byrnes	Balanced Midfielder	182	84
51	Saints	Louis Butler	Medium Defender	185	75
52	Bulldogs	Callum Jamieson	Ruck	199	84
53	Richmond	Chad Warner	Inside Midfielder	183	83
54	Carlton	Josh Shute	Outside Midfielder	187	74
55	Fremantle	Jaxon Prior	Medium Defender	189	82

 

[smurfin]

I like it.
Except for th

Based on the latest information regarding the possible first round picks, I've updated my rankings and I think people would be much happier

2019 Phantom Draft
Pick	Club	Name	Position	Height	Weight	Matched Bids
1	Gold Coast	Matt Rowell	Inside Midfielder	180	78
2	Gold Coast	Noah Anderson	Inside Midfielder	191	87
3	Melbourne	Luke Jackson	Ruck	199	94
4	GWS	Lachlan Ash	Medium Defender	187	83
5	GWS	Tom Green	Inside Midfielder	190	89	Match using 40 59 & 60
6	Sydney	Sam Flanders	Inside Midfielder	182	83
7	Adelaide	Fisher McAsey	KPD	197	91
8	Fremantle	Hayden Young	Medium Defender	188	83
9	Fremantle	Deven Robertson	Inside Midfielder	184	81
10	Fremantle	Liam Henry	Midfielder/Forward	180	68	Match using 49 57 & 67
11	Carlton	Caleb Serong	Inside Midfielder	178	83
12	Melbourne	Kysaiah Pickett	Small Forward/Mid	188	83
13	Hawthorn	Brodie Kemp	Utility	192	89
14	Port Adelaide	Dylan Stephens	Medium Defender	183	74
15	Bulldogs	Cody Weightman	Small Forward/Mid	178	75
16	Geelong	Josh Worrell	KPP	195	83
17	Gold Coast	Will Day	Defender/Midfielder	189	76
18	Port Adelaide	Trent Bianco	Small Forward/Mid	178	73
19	Hawthorn	Finn Maginness	Inside Midfielder	189	82	Match using 41 48 & 52 get pick 60 back
20	Geelong	Miles Bergman	Medium Forward	188	83
21	Port Adelaide	Trent Rivers	Medium Defender	188	83
22	Richmond	Cooper Stephens	Inside Midfielder	188	83
23	Gold Coast	Elijah Taylor	Medium Forward	188	77
24	Brisbane	Jay Rantall	Balanced Midfielder	185	83
25	Adelaide	Cameron Tanehy	Medium Forward	185	80
26	Adelaide	Harry Schoenberg	Inside Midfielder	182	83
27	Geelong	Sam De Koning	KPP	201	86
28	Sydney	Thomson Dow	Inside Midfielder	184	76
29	North	Harrison Jones	KPP	196	78
30	North	Sam Philp	Inside Midfielder	184	82
31	Melbourne	Jeremy Sharp	Outside Midfielder	189	81
32	Brisbane	Will Gould	KPD	192	106
33	North	Nick Bryan	Ruck	202	87
34	Port Adelaide	Jackson Mead	Balanced Midfielder	183	83	Match using 50 & 52 get 62 back
35	Essendon	Charlie Comben	Ruck	199	84
36	Sydney	Dylan Williams	Medium Forward	186	81
37	Essendon	Darcy Chirgwin	Inside Midfielder	191	80
38	Brisbane	Darcy Cassar	Utility	184	82
39	Collingwood	Mitch Georgiades	KPF	192	87
40	Geelong	Karl Finlay	KPD	192	88
41	Adelaide	Dyson Hilder	KPD	195	93
42	Richmond	Hugo Ralphsmith	Forward/Midfielder	188	75
43	Richmond	Brock Smith	Defender	189	82
44	Richmond	Cooper Sharman	KPF	192	79
45	Carlton	Ned Cahill	Small Forward/Mid	179	78
46	Sydney	Josh Honey	Balanced Midfielder	185	82
47	Adelaide	Emerson Jeka	KPF	198	91
48	West Coast	Fraser Phillips	Medium Forward	187	72
49	North	Daniel Mott	Balanced Midfielder	183	80
50	Collingwood	Ryan Byrnes	Balanced Midfielder	182	84
51	Saints	Louis Butler	Medium Defender	185	75
52	Bulldogs	Callum Jamieson	Ruck	199	84
53	Richmond	Chad Warner	Inside Midfielder	183	83
54	Carlton	Josh Shute	Outside Midfielder	187	74
55	Fremantle	Jaxon Prior	Medium Defender	189	82

I like it.
Except for the ruckmen, do you also think we'd be looking at any sliders that you have projected above us?
Would we go Finlay, Hilder or Georgiades instead of Sharman if they are available?

 

[Marcel Proust]

Based on the latest information regarding the possible first round picks, I've updated my rankings and I think people would be much happier

2019 Phantom Draft
Pick	Club	Name	Position	Height	Weight	Matched Bids
1	Gold Coast	Matt Rowell	Inside Midfielder	180	78
2	Gold Coast	Noah Anderson	Inside Midfielder	191	87
3	Melbourne	Luke Jackson	Ruck	199	94
4	GWS	Lachlan Ash	Medium Defender	187	83
5	GWS	Tom Green	Inside Midfielder	190	89	Match using 40 59 & 60
6	Sydney	Sam Flanders	Inside Midfielder	182	83
7	Adelaide	Fisher McAsey	KPD	197	91
8	Fremantle	Hayden Young	Medium Defender	188	83
9	Fremantle	Deven Robertson	Inside Midfielder	184	81
10	Fremantle	Liam Henry	Midfielder/Forward	180	68	Match using 49 57 & 67
11	Carlton	Caleb Serong	Inside Midfielder	178	83
12	Melbourne	Kysaiah Pickett	Small Forward/Mid	188	83
13	Hawthorn	Brodie Kemp	Utility	192	89
14	Port Adelaide	Dylan Stephens	Medium Defender	183	74
15	Bulldogs	Cody Weightman	Small Forward/Mid	178	75
16	Geelong	Josh Worrell	KPP	195	83
17	Gold Coast	Will Day	Defender/Midfielder	189	76
18	Port Adelaide	Trent Bianco	Small Forward/Mid	178	73
19	Hawthorn	Finn Maginness	Inside Midfielder	189	82	Match using 41 48 & 52 get pick 60 back
20	Geelong	Miles Bergman	Medium Forward	188	83
21	Port Adelaide	Trent Rivers	Medium Defender	188	83
22	Richmond	Cooper Stephens	Inside Midfielder	188	83
23	Gold Coast	Elijah Taylor	Medium Forward	188	77
24	Brisbane	Jay Rantall	Balanced Midfielder	185	83
25	Adelaide	Cameron Tanehy	Medium Forward	185	80
26	Adelaide	Harry Schoenberg	Inside Midfielder	182	83
27	Geelong	Sam De Koning	KPP	201	86
28	Sydney	Thomson Dow	Inside Midfielder	184	76
29	North	Harrison Jones	KPP	196	78
30	North	Sam Philp	Inside Midfielder	184	82
31	Melbourne	Jeremy Sharp	Outside Midfielder	189	81
32	Brisbane	Will Gould	KPD	192	106
33	North	Nick Bryan	Ruck	202	87
34	Port Adelaide	Jackson Mead	Balanced Midfielder	183	83	Match using 50 & 52 get 62 back
35	Essendon	Charlie Comben	Ruck	199	84
36	Sydney	Dylan Williams	Medium Forward	186	81
37	Essendon	Darcy Chirgwin	Inside Midfielder	191	80
38	Brisbane	Darcy Cassar	Utility	184	82
39	Collingwood	Mitch Georgiades	KPF	192	87
40	Geelong	Karl Finlay	KPD	192	88
41	Adelaide	Dyson Hilder	KPD	195	93
42	Richmond	Hugo Ralphsmith	Forward/Midfielder	188	75
43	Richmond	Brock Smith	Defender	189	82
44	Richmond	Cooper Sharman	KPF	192	79
45	Carlton	Ned Cahill	Small Forward/Mid	179	78
46	Sydney	Josh Honey	Balanced Midfielder	185	82
47	Adelaide	Emerson Jeka	KPF	198	91
48	West Coast	Fraser Phillips	Medium Forward	187	72
49	North	Daniel Mott	Balanced Midfielder	183	80
50	Collingwood	Ryan Byrnes	Balanced Midfielder	182	84
51	Saints	Louis Butler	Medium Defender	185	75
52	Bulldogs	Callum Jamieson	Ruck	199	84
53	Richmond	Chad Warner	Inside Midfielder	183	83
54	Carlton	Josh Shute	Outside Midfielder	187	74
55	Fremantle	Jaxon Prior	Medium Defender	189	82

nice work.

i am on the Gould bandwagon if he is still on the board at Richmond first pick, assuming the Tigers keep it.

no chance he gets past the crows twice in the mid20s otherwise im guessing

 

[Cotchy9]

Media linking us heavily to Stephens, Rivers Rantall, with mentions to Bianco and Day. Sounds like it’ll probably come from those 5 with our first

My preference

1. Rivers
2. Rantall
3. Stephens
4. Bianco
5. Day

Wouldn’t be too unhappy with any of them though

 

[Marcel Proust]

Media linking us heavily to Stephens, Rivers Rantall, with mentions to Bianco and Day. Sounds like it’ll probably come from those 5 with our first

My preference

1. Rivers
2. Rantall
3. Stephens
4. Bianco
5. Day

Wouldn’t be too unhappy with any of them though

Gould going before Richmonds first pick in these phantom drafts i assume?

 

[Cotchy9]

Gould going before Richmonds first pick in these phantom drafts i assume?

Not in all of them. But even so, no one is linking him with us. Not to say we’re not interested though

 

[Roksman]

AFL draft 2019, AFL mock draft, AFL phantom draft, Matt Balmer, draft prospects, profiles, rankings | FOX SPORTS

Blink and you would’ve missed it.

coupler.foxsports.com.au

Has us taking Cooper Stephens even with Trent Rivers available.

 

[HumanMeatball]

Who knows what could happen. Don’t think anyone thought we would have Higgins or Dawkins the last two years