2019 Draft

[tigs2010]

Tiges super keen on Prince Philp at pick 38 SOS

 

[Calcium Man]

In all seriousness Carlton seem to go into the draft with zero plan and make these live pick trading decisions on a whim. The decisions reek of desperation.

 

[Calcium Man]

View attachment 785963
Tiges super keen on Prince Philp at pick 38 SOS

will drive Walsh to training.

 

[tigs2010]

will drive Walsh to training.

Nearly ran Walsh over last year on his way to his first training session. True story.

 

[dustysnecktattoo]

Dont like the draft going more than one day , unnecessary

 

[Grrr]

I would take a punt on Williams and Taheny but do not anticipate them to reach our picks. Fraser Phillips for a late stab otherwise 2021 focus.

I had a look at Dow.

He runs a 3.06 20 metre sprint which is considered average. He is 183 cm 4 cm less than his brother he is still on the light side at 76 cm. The trouble is he is inconsistent to per Afldraft central profile. He will need to get better enduro and improve size and strength. Will this affect his speed and consistency?

Can he play back in a role before improving consistency??

The thing is the lack of a real competitive strength like size or speed could be why he is inconsistent apart from injury. I think atm he is a project player but I wish him the best in his development and I hope he really accelerates his development

I don't think speed is an issue, looked very quick in his video and is noted by all pre drafts that he is quick. Don't read to much into those 20m times, my son did those and was slower than many of his team mates, but on a footy field they were miles behind him. I like his quick movement while standing up (as opposed to the sprinters starting position), he looks to have a serious step and great agility.

 

[Grrr]

Nearly ran Walsh over last year on his way to his first training session. True story.

Nearly is not good enough.

 

[tigs2010]

Nearly is not good enough.

I'm a bad driver.

 

[GoTigers2015]

Tried to run Walsh over last year on his way to his first training session. True story.

EFA

 

[A Banderas]

Dont like the draft going more than one day , unnecessary

need chris newman hosting

 

[Calcium Man]

need chris newman hosting

Sugar Kane should host, would have told Robertson he wasn’t getting drafted last night.

 

[dustysnecktattoo]

need chris newman hosting

Brilliant idea and he can present the Cup in 2020 too

 

[JAKLAUGHING]

It was reported at the time that Stocker was told by our recruiters that he had flaws and he did not take it well. We were never going to take him after that. Not the type we want at our club. If you look back a few pages you will see the articles about his interview with us.

Ahhh sos baby!!!

 

[Grrr]

Thats fine but what role is he going to play?

Eg, get Williams, Thayen and or Fraser Phillip.

Over time replace Castagna or Lambert or others as they age or help out on the wing for lefties as part of rotations. In the forward line complimentary support Dusty, JR and or his replacement, Lynch and the smalls with left footed shots and leads etc..


With Dow who does he replace? To short for Cotch replacement, can't see him replacing Prestia, does not have the size of Graham, Edwards could go on for another 4 years or so. Plus there are others like Rioli and Bolton, that are quicker with more forward line tricks. So what is Dows role??

If we get Cooper Stephens goes in the guts, Dusty goes forward and stays there till needed, helps Cotch. Same with Philps might rotate with Cotch, rotations with Ross and Pickett

Georgardis replaces JR if good enough when JR retires generally. What role is for Dow?? It is not clear for me and he might be jack of a few trades master of none because role wise he is pretty incomplete so far and speculative. Too high a pick for speculation for me when a he has to develop yet and if he does that b there has to be an effective role or him!!

How is Dow to short to play Cotchin's role, 2cm. Rowell therefore would also be too short. Dow could easily play Castagna's role down the track. Good in the air and on the deck, and could go through the midfield. He was also not a speculative pick, Chris Doerre had him at 15. Our scouts have obvious spent a lot of time watching him, and given that he played mostly in the schools system not may NAB watchers would have seen much of his best work.

 

[Ocker]

Spoke to a guy at the club and no one even knew who Philp was until Carlton read his name out.

Gold

 

[A Banderas]

from Kain Little to sos the whole blooze footy club is severely obsessed with Richmond

 

[A Banderas]

knightmare has said he is a poor mans Paddy dow

 

[A Banderas]

Brilliant idea and he can present the Cup in 2020 too

lids

 

[Drofder]

knightmare has said he is a poor mans Paddy dow

Phew. That's a relief. Must be decent.

 

[Calcium Man]

knightmare has said he is a poor mans Paddy dow

he also said you’re a poor mans Shazza

 

[A Banderas]

just dropped a truth bomb on the sos thread

Nostradamus Lives - Stephen SOS Silvagni sacked from Carlton. Tom Browne upgraded to CCC- Junk Bond rating

LOL. The bar you set for a ‘great’ game is extremely low. There should be an expectation that that SOS recruited group would have contributed more than 7.5 games on average per player before leaving the club. But then again, you think that’s perfectly acceptable. Because they were ‘free’...

www.bigfooty.com

 

[JAKLAUGHING]

from Kain Little to sos the whole blooze footy club is severely obsessed with Richmond

And so they ought to be...we are currently the standard of quality...

 

[Roksman]

Evidently these phantom drafts aren't a great indication of what real recruiters value but here's the Day 2 mock...

AFL phantom draft: How the remaining picks should play out — and there are some hidden gems

Phantom Draft: How remaining picks will play out — and there are some hidden gems

www.foxsports.com.au

 

[Jozzy]

I would take a punt on Williams and Taheny but do not anticipate them to reach our picks. Fraser Phillips for a late stab otherwise 2021 focus.

I had a look at Dow.

He runs a 3.06 20 metre sprint which is considered average. He is 183 cm 4 cm less than his brother he is still on the light side at 76 cm. The trouble is he is inconsistent to per Afldraft central profile. He will need to get better enduro and improve size and strength. Will this affect his speed and consistency?

Can he play back in a role before improving consistency??

The thing is the lack of a real competitive strength like size or speed could be why he is inconsistent apart from injury. I think atm he is a project player but I wish him the best in his development and I hope he really accelerates his development

Where did you read he runs a 3.06 second 20m sprint??

 

[A Banderas]