Prediction 2019 "Hypothetical Trade, FA, random player you wish we could get" thread..

[mickmaster]

gonna b tall with 2m Peter, Patton and Mitch Lew.

 

[HawksILove]

2 meter peter to the hawks almost done

Peter has signed a new three-year deal in May 2019 , how can we make this work

On SM-G955F using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[badboybobba]

2 meter peter to the hawks almost done

Surely not, Lewis, Patton and Wright would leave us way too tall and slow up forward.

 

[Mrzohs]

Peter has signed a new three-year deal in May 2019 , how can we make this work

On SM-G955F using BigFooty.com mobile app

Trade, watch this space

 

[Mrzohs]

Surely not, Lewis, Patton and Wright would leave us way too tall and slow up forward.

It Wouldn't hurt having 3 guys over 195cm with ability...he might play as the ruck.
We currently have m.lewis thats it relying on patton with no back up on the list is insane, has played a handful of games over 3yrs

 

[badboybobba]

Wouldn't hurt having 3 guys over 195cm with ability...he might play 2nd ruck.
We currently have m.lewis thats it

I understand what your saying but really you’d think that the only way all 3 play in the same side is if that one of them is the number one ruck. Can’t see it happening when we have Big Boy

 

[Leather Poisoning]

Surely not, Lewis, Patton and Wright would leave us way too tall and slow up forward.

Patton and Wright?
Op shop forward line.

 

[sven_inc]

2 meter peter to the hawks almost done

What would he be worth?

Would fall somewhere between our 1st and 2nd at this stage IMO.

Would love him at the Hawks. Elite talent despite being at GC.

 

[MasterSamurai]

Ceglar, Mcevoy, Lewis , O’Brien- if peter is coming than one or more are going considering also Patton!!
Or, it reeks of dees going after Preuss without putting much thought into it.

 

[Cyzzametimbres]

Ceglar, Mcevoy, Lewis , O’Brien- if peter is coming than one or more are going considering also Patton!!
Or, it reeks of dees going after Preuss without putting much thought into it.

Why would the suns be looking to let him go considering the haven’t signed up king long term yet and have an injury prone day as their no 1 forward target they’d need to have another kpf in line for a trade in or they’ve lost the plot.

 

[Brant]

People keep talking up Gunston-to-Dogs rumours lately (potentially making way for multiple Hawks trade ins, don't believe it but whatever) but had this thought for a hypothetical 3-way trade

Pick 9 + Pick 41 + Pick 43
<-->
Gunston + Pick 25

This gives the Hawks extra draft points to help match Maginness (assuming 25 is swallowed by a bid, it's basically just upgrading it's worth in points) while also leaving them two firsts to play with. This could mean they can trade with Melbourne:

Pick 7 + Pick 9 + Pick 41 <--> Pick 2 + Pick 20

This means Melbourne gets currency to trade for Brad Hill (if that happens) plus still remain in the top 10 of the draft. Hawks get to bring in Cogs + whoever else, draft Anderson while having more than enough points to match an early bird on Maginness. This ultimately values Gunston at Pick ~8

I don't like it, but it's well thought out

 

[TallyHawk]

Nice audition from Ceglar last night, could be Giants bound.


On iPad using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[TylerDurden]

Trade, watch this space

Is this the Burgoyne rumour?

 

[dermott]

2 meter peter to the hawks almost done

I note this is in the Hypothetical thread, yet you sound confident.
Are you confident?

 

[Brant]

2 meter peter to the hawks almost done

He'd wanna learn to play 1st Ruck or KPD pretty quickly then.



And, he needs to be a gun in the snow - we don't carry bad snow players at Hawthorn...

 

[PhatHQ]

Trade, watch this space

I don’t mind this at all.

If this is actually happening I would be inclined to think we are moving on from Cegs & preparing for the end of McEvoy.

If 2mP comes to Hawthorn as the primary ruck that can rotate with Patton & Lewis up forward he would be a fantastic inclusion. Farley mobile marking ruck that can roll up the ground as a dangerous forward.

I can’t honestly comment on his ruck work but given Monkey is a ruck whisper, 2mP would only need to break even rucking & then expose his opponent around the ground, it looks like a Clarko play.

On the trade front...

Gunston To GC with 2mP & pick 16(Brisbane pick)... sold.
It would certainly give us some added trade currency for another 25 year old or hit the draft.

So..

Cogs
Patton
2mP
Draft pick at 6
*insert player (pick 16 or trade)

That is a rather significant off season when you still have the supposed Smith trade, possible Cegs trade, a second & third rd draft selection.

 

[beta_condition]

I would love if GWS would trade their 12*+14* for our 7*+25*. If we traded 45 for Patton I think that trade works for both parties, over paying for Patton to get the two first round draft picks.

Trade out Ceglar/Smith and get the picks for Finn and that 45 ish draft pick to get our yearly Hardwick/Worpel.

 

[beta_condition]

I don’t mind this at all.

If this is actually happening I would be inclined to think we are moving on from Cegs & preparing for the end of McEvoy.

If 2mP comes to Hawthorn as the primary ruck that can rotate with Patton & Lewis up forward he would be a fantastic inclusion. Farley mobile marking ruck that can roll up the ground as a dangerous forward.

I can’t honestly comment on his ruck work but given Monkey is a ruck whisper, 2mP would only need to break even rucking & then expose his opponent around the ground, it looks like a Clarko play.

On the trade front...

Gunston To GC with 2mP & pick 16(Brisbane pick)... sold.
It would certainly give us some added trade currency for another 25 year old or hit the draft.

So..

Cogs
Patton
2mP
Draft pick at 6
*insert player (pick 16 or trade)

That is a rather significant off season when you still have the supposed Smith trade, possible Cegs trade, a second & third rd draft selection.

I rather not go for the ginger verison of Vickery. Wright is utter s**t no thanks.

 

[VandoHawk]

I rather not go for the ginger verison of Vickery. Wright is utter s**t no thanks.

2MP was one of the best marks I’ve seen in his draft year. It’s such a shame GC have stunted his development and he’s become a shell of the player he could have been.

Sometimes that can be fixed with a change of environment. He’ll only be 23 at the end of this year. But I don’t think it’ll be cheap to get a contracted KPF so I don’t like the suggestion.

 

[WWSD]

Anyone figure out who is the mystery key position player?

 

[Pessimistic]

Not neccesarily for us, but scott thompson has a bit of lake about him maybe a bit old now

 

[Falco131415]

All this talk of trading out Ceglar, is very speculative.
He's are only decent back up ruck as proved Friday night- he was huge. Had he pulled in the the 6+ marks he just missed he may of been Bog.
reeves is too young & Pittonet is not AFL standard.
Seen Pitts at Box Hill, he's a very good VFL Ruck but can't cut it with the big boys!
So if we do trade out Cegs, we need to top up with a player of similar standard.
Is peter wright that player maybe?

 

[Pessimistic]

If ceglars happy to stay, its a no brainer

 

[Bugs1977]

Is this the Burgoyne rumour?

I assume your thinking we resign Silk and they resign Wright and then we trade them for each other. Interesting if true and it would be one final assist from the great man... Shauny Burgoyne. FWIW I don’t think the rumour is true

 

[Bugs1977]

All this talk of trading out Ceglar, is very speculative.
He's are only decent back up ruck as proved Friday night- he was huge. Had he pulled in the the 6+ marks he just missed he may of been Bog.
reeves is too young & Pittonet is not AFL standard.
Seen Pitts at Box Hill, he's a very good VFL Ruck but can't cut it with the big boys!
So if we do trade out Cegs, we need to top up with a player of similar standard.
Is peter wright that player maybe?

To be a starting caliber ruck at AFL level you gotta be able to rest up forward and clunk marks and kick goals. This is why Pitto is a t Box Hill and why Cegs is in and out of the team.