Analysis 2019 List Management Discussion II

[Soapy V]

Surprised you think Deluca is borderline Soap?
We had 1st pick of all mature players only a few months ago. Seems strange to take him for half a season, then cut him to replace with another rookie pick?

Some will be borderline depending upon what we recruit. I think he will stay but not guaranteed

 

[Bamboo Harvester]

Final call

Definite Outs: Lobbe LeBois Lang Thomas Fasolo

Borderline: Garlett Kerr Phillips Polson Schumacher DeLuca

Not a bad call Soap....I did a back of the envelope list a while back and came up with pretty much the same, remembering Pickett already gone.

If we assume 4-5 FA's/trades and an additional three picks in the ND, we'd have to be looking at 7-8 moving on from the senior list.

Wouldn't be surprised if we ended up rookie listing maybe Schu and/or Kerr (if he doesn't get picked up by another club).

 

[Juddernaut08]

Not a bad call Soap....I did a back of the envelope list a while back and came up with pretty much the same, remembering Pickett already gone.

If we assume 4-5 FA's/trades and an additional three picks in the ND, we'd have to be looking at 7-8 moving on from the senior list.

Wouldn't be surprised if we ended up rookie listing maybe Schu and/or Kerr (if he doesn't get picked up by another club).

Kerr to dogs or melbourne for a 3rd would be ideal.

 

[Benaly28]

Kerr to Cats.

 

[Elmer_Judd]

I am all onboard the trying to draft a young ruck with our 3rd or 4th rnd (doesn't seem to be any ones for sale/trade at other clubs)

Also from now on, it seems trading for contracted players is going to be a lot harder and costly than it once was.

Hoping we can send a future pick to Gold Coast for Jack Martin (if the rumour is true he is keen to join us)

 

[Bamboo Harvester]

I am all onboard the trying to draft a young ruck with our 3rd or 4th rnd (doesn't seem to be any ones for sale/trade at other clubs)

Ben Kelly (over-age ruckman, Murray Bushrangers)....apparently injured at the moment, but having a great year.
Possibly unlucky not to be drafted mid-year.

 

[Opine]

Kerr to Cats.

Please no. I can’t stand the Cat’s. Selfishly, I prefer he goes to GC.
As much as I’d love to see him do well I couldn’t take it if he came really really good while playing under a Scott.

 

[Curnivore]

Please no. I can’t stand the Cat’s. Selfishly, I prefer he goes to GC.
As much as I’d love to see him do well I couldn’t take it if he came really really good while playing under a Scott.

They have been asking about him for 6 months. Good on him

 

[Opine]

They have been asking about him for 6 months. Good on him

Is it bad if I prefer that he just play Sate League if he is dropped; rather than join the Cats?

 

[FlowersByIrene]

With the bluemour thread locked I flock here.

Jack Martin in Navy. I love it

 

[BrisbaneCFC]

With the bluemour thread locked I flock here.

Jack Martin in Navy. I love it

Yep. Agreed. Would be a good signing to go with Cogs.

 

[BrisbaneCFC]

Please no. I can’t stand the Cat’s. Selfishly, I prefer he goes to GC.
As much as I’d love to see him do well I couldn’t take it if he came really really good while playing under a Scott.

TBF, if he isn't at Carlton, it doesn't really bother me at all where he goes or who coaches him or what he becomes.

 

[Canyouhearthedrums]

I feel like Daisy being forced out so far out from trade period means a few deals have already been agreed.

 

[Accidental genius]

I feel like Daisy being forced out so far out from trade period means a few deals have already been agreed.

most likely jack martin who can play half back/forward.

also this will be his last game at mcg so should be a more memorable send off rather than next week in geelong.

 

[Benaly28]

God no Mason Wood.Soaps May Have alluded to.And God no to Rory Atkins,very conditional player.

 

[RoyalParade]

Not s

They have been asking about him for 6 months. Good on him

Not sure how he fits into the cats? Maybe Hawkins retiring in a year or 2?

 

[zeggie]

I am all onboard the trying to draft a young ruck with our 3rd or 4th rnd (doesn't seem to be any ones for sale/trade at other clubs)

Cameron says hello.

 

[C4[2]Yo`DooR]

We are one of the clubs that have approached Ollie Wines. He's open to moving, but as a co-captain and the fact that he's contracted - he knows its in the hands of the club.

 

[Coona Blues]

Cameron says hello.

I have been "tracking" him since his (non)draft year. Highly rated big boy who has progressed much slower than one would imagine. First couple of seasons in WA state league played more forward than ruck. Super slow burn at Swans, missing huge chunks through injury and continuing to have ruck minutes "managed".

I don't believe he is the ruck we are looking for. Injury levels rivalling our own (pre 2019) Andrew Phillips. If we are trading in a ruck to cover MK and young TDK, surely we need a solid citizen who will be there when required and can hold his own if required. Phillips has managed to play games more consistently this season, we can surmise Mr. Russell may have been a contributing factor.

Perhaps even a group of Kreuzer, DeKoning and Phillips would suffice for 2020. I must admit the rumoured departure of Levi Casboult may force our hand to adding some insurance.

The other end of the scale is, of course, Grundy. I have learned never say never with SOS, however it is fair to say that any work going in to this end would be preliminary with an eye to free agency (next year if I remember correctly).

There are three, seemingly, quality ruck prospects in this year's draft Jackson, Bryan and Comben to consider. This poster, however, has his eyes firmly on Henry Walsh and/or Josh Cripps in the 2020 renewal of the draft.

 

[HavUEvaSeenTheRain]

We are one of the clubs that have approached Ollie Wines. He's open to moving, but as a co-captain and the fact that he's contracted - he knows its in the hands of the club.

Yeh I see on the port board they seem more than happy to let him go if they get a good offer. As good as he is I think he makes us too slow

 

[StandByyourMan]

Can I urge people not to get too excited about cogs. I may be being put off the scent but i am reliably informed (by a v reliable source) Hawks. I don't know whether its a good idea to put him in our best 22 next year just yet.

 

[C4[2]Yo`DooR]

I can't decide if I'd rather B. Crouch or Ollie if it came down to trading for one of the two.

Both bolster our inside game, both approx the same age, both can accumulate, both are slow.

 

[Jeremias]

I can't decide if I'd rather B. Crouch or Ollie if it came down to trading for one of the two.

Both bolster our inside game, both approx the same age, both can accumulate, both are slow.

Crouch is the better footballer IMO.

But his body is and always will be a concern.

 

[mochacinolatte]

I can't decide if I'd rather B. Crouch or Ollie if it came down to trading for one of the two.

Both bolster our inside game, both approx the same age, both can accumulate, both are slow.

Really really liked his second year, another bull to help Cripps which will allow him to drift forward.

Would cost a fortune of picks since he is contracted....

Brad Crouch seems more gettable but injury prone, believe in Andrew Russel?

Tough one.

 

[C4[2]Yo`DooR]

Not Carlton related but Port Adelaide are pushing very hard for Cedric Cox from the Lions.

Given we have SPS - I wonder if there would be any appeal there to have him join us. Would love his run and carry.