Analysis 2019 List Management Discussion

[Mr_Plow]

Who is this, Mr P?

Papley.

 

[Mr_Plow]

Forgot about that.
From the games I’ve seen from Papley, he seems to be an improving midfielder who gets a lot clearances.

Can play midfield as well as forward, only 22, averages over a goal per game. Would be a great get.

 

[Coona Blues]

Can play midfield as well as forward, only 22, averages over a goal per game. Would be a great get.

Had discounted any Papley references, due to his family connections, but if he truly wants to be in Victoria, would be almost our number one realistic target. Would make a serious difference to our forward line with his pressure. Would be interesting to know if his midfield move was his idea or more necessity at the Swans.

 

[The Bighouse]

Can play midfield as well as forward, only 22, averages over a goal per game. Would be a great get.

Certainly not against him, is improving as well. Hard at it too but midfielder role beckons off this year’s output. Strange level for a trade though.

 

[Blue and Blue]

Can play midfield as well as forward, only 22, averages over a goal per game. Would be a great get.

The day we played them I thought thats the one I want. And was the difference on the day.

 

[DangerousD]

If North have a shit year, I don't see why we should be holding our breath waiting to pick up one of their discards. For mine that's too close to the year we picked up Mullet.

Or when the Crows snared Betts, the Swans with Laidler, the Lions with Robinson and Garlett at the Dees.

A club under pressure can make poor decisions.

 

[DangerousD]

Found the posts on Max Lynch really interesting reading this week caught up with a mate of mine who's a Pies supporter and mentioned what I'd read on this thread and what his opinion of him was, first he mentioned the big fella has a massive tank on him, he finished in the top 3/4 in their 2km time trial over the preseason behind Tom Phillips also mentioned his mobility and having great hands both in the ruck and around the ground, apparently club has a high opinion of him...

They may have a high opinion of him but I just can’t see how they convince a young ruck he has a future there, when you have Grundy.

Grundy will be number 1 ruck for 5-7 more years, so what would the player be thinking?

 

[Red Bull]

Had discounted any Papley references, due to his family connections, but if he truly wants to be in Victoria, would be almost our number one realistic target. Would make a serious difference to our forward line with his pressure. Would be interesting to know if his midfield move was his idea or more necessity at the Swans.

I like him a lot but also factored in his family history.
He loves a goal and applies great pressure.
Agresta’s Sydney connection should be valuable in discussions should this be a possibility.

 

[Christou2Kouta]

Had discounted any Papley references, due to his family connections, but if he truly wants to be in Victoria, would be almost our number one realistic target. Would make a serious difference to our forward line with his pressure. Would be interesting to know if his midfield move was his idea or more necessity at the Swans.

I would 100% be on board with chasing Papley. He’s a perfect fit for our side/list. Much like Setterfield, I’m sure he would see the opportunity to play for 10 years in a successful side with a large group of people around his age. We’ve also got the capacity to pay him far more than Sydney would.


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Blue and Blue]

I would 100% be on board with chasing Papley. He’s a perfect fit for our side/list. Much like Setterfield, I’m sure he would see the opportunity to play for 10 years in a successful side with a large group of people around his age. We’ve also got the capacity to pay him far more than Sydney would.


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

And much less than Kelly etc.

 

[The Dominator7]

Papley would be the perfect addition to our side as that pressure forward who can do stints in the middle....just reeks of a SOS target this year...hard worker and a bit of pig in him, high on the Mongrelometer

 

[The Bighouse]

Ok, perfect trade period Coniglio (FA), Billings (1st rounder prob + some), Papley (next year’s 2nd) + a ruck (we’ll take M.Lynch off recent reports).

FB: Marchbank - Jones - Plowman
HB: Docherty - Weitering - Williamson
R: Kreuzer - Stocker - Coniglio
C: Walsh - Cripps - SPS
HF: Cuningham - Charlie - Billings
FF: Papley - McKay - McGovern
INT: Fisher - Setterfield - Dow - JSOS + Gibbons - Pickett - LOB - Lang - Schumacher - Macreadie - Kennedy - TDK - Kerr - Newman - Polson - Phillips - M. Lynch
Murphy, Simmo, Daisy, Ed + development players.

 

[Mr_Plow]

Ok, perfect trade period Coniglio (FA), Billings (1st rounder prob + some), Papley (next year’s 2nd) + a ruck (we’ll take M.Lynch off recent reports).

FB: Marchbank - Jones - Plowman
HB: Docherty - Weitering - Williamson
R: Kreuzer - Stocker - Coniglio
C: Walsh - Cripps - SPS
HF: Cuningham - Charlie - Billings
FF: Papley - McKay - McGovern
INT: Fisher - Setterfield - Dow - JSOS + Gibbons - Pickett - LOB - Lang - Schumacher - Macreadie - Kennedy - TDK - Kerr - Newman - Polson - Phillips - M. Lynch
Murphy, Simmo, Daisy, Ed + development players.

Billings will likely sign and I think Papley demands a late first round selection, particularly contracted.

 

[CFC18]

Billings will likely sign and I think Papley demands a late first round selection, particularly contracted.

You'd also expect Coniglio will go to Hawks alongside O'Meara if he does request a trade. Papley alone though would be a big addition to the team.

 

[Mr_Plow]

You'd also expect Coniglio will go to Hawks alongside O'Meara if he does request a trade. Papley alone though would be a big addition to the team.

Yes, I would be quite content with adding Papley as well as another young talented player.

If Adelaide's pick ends up 5-7, we should be able to get a 2nd round pick back from the Swans to use in another trade.

Although I suspect SOS will still work hard on Gresham and the likes, but I see Papley as really gettable based on what barass70 said.

 

[HARKER]

R: Kreuzer - Stocker - Coniglio
HF: Cuningham - Charlie - Billings
FF: Papley - McKay - McGovern

If it looks to be too good to be true.........it probably will be.

That would make for a wonderful trade period, whilst possibly still holding onto the 2020 1st

 

[The Bighouse]

If it looks to be too good to be true.........it probably will be.

That would make for a wonderful trade period, whilst possibly still holding onto the 2020 1st

Dream/perfect = same/same
1993, 1995, 1996 are the right age brackets too.

 

[Robertio]

Papley.

He's definitely one that can ride on Cripps shoulders.

 

[The Bighouse]

I like him a lot but also factored in his family history.
He loves a goal and applies great pressure.
Agresta’s Sydney connection should be valuable in discussions should this be a possibility.

Contracted until 2020 and upon last signing was more than happy for SYD but winds of change...
https://www.dailytelegraph.com.au/s...t/news-story/cb3f449b217d56040407b224a63e4c42 “I never thought about signing on with another club,” Papley told the Daily Telegraph.
“As soon as the Swans made an offer I didn’t think twice I was straight to it. I’m close with the other younger players, we’ve got Millsy, George and players like Ollie Florent and Will Hayward coming up. It’s looking exciting for the future and I can’t wait.”

 

[Robertio]

They may have a high opinion of him but I just can’t see how they convince a young ruck he has a future there, when you have Grundy.

Grundy will be number 1 ruck for 5-7 more years, so what would the player be thinking?

Grundy could also end up being no 1 ruck for Adelaide.

 

[Iamcarlton]

Garlett played Hff for 10+ games last year. He can't find the ball or stick a tackle

Do you remember what our side was like last year ?
Now imagine trying to get a kick as a small forward in that side think he's definitely worth a try again as a forward considering how weak we still are in this area .
Also think he was carrying a shoulder injury last year for awhile having said that he isn't exactly lighting it up in the reserves at this early stage of their season .

 

[THE_GUN]

They may have a high opinion of him but I just can’t see how they convince a young ruck he has a future there, when you have Grundy.

Grundy will be number 1 ruck for 5-7 more years, so what would the player be thinking?[/QUOTE]

If Lynch dd come to Carlton to take #1 Ruck , The same question could be asked about TDK with McKay,Curnow,McGovern,Kerr in the foward line will TDK be happy in 2 years time sitting in the reserves

 

[Juddernaut08]

If Lynch dd come to Carlton to take #1 Ruck , The same question could be asked about TDK with McKay,Curnow,McGovern,Kerr in the foward line will TDK be happy in 2 years time sitting in the reserves

They can all play forward. We are looking to pickup 2 more gun KPFs this offseason so we can buck the trend and play 8 tall forwards at once. Slow and steady.

 

[MITSUHIRATO]

If the Adelaide Pick did end up being 6/7: I’d love to somehow turn that into Papley and Langdon.

 

[Mr_Plow]

If the Adelaide Pick did end up being 6/7: I’d love to somehow turn that into Papley and Langdon.

Would be an elite result for us.

Small forward and rebounding defender issues potentially solved very quickly.