You still think this? Go watch him.He's an 18 yr old vs huge guys who have been in the system for years.
Any1 could pop his shoulder, remember murph in his first year.
I think he will be okay, but not AFL standards. Sounds harsh but it's probably the truth.
If the midfield was cripps Kennedy SPS Dow Curnow Setterfield and fisher i would be over the moon.