MRP / Trib. 2019 MRP Chook Lotto - Carlton Tribunal News & Reports

[KohPhi]

Just as an aside, on Sam McClure's "Time On" show tonight, he said the AFL have sent a "Please Explain" to Carlton for the Cheer Squad calling the umpires "w***ers" in the Collingwood game in Round 8 two weeks ago. Gees, the AFL are really after us for some reason. This is the game where Collingwood had 24 free kicks to our 8 for the game.

I saw the response..

Dear AFL

We are sorry. The Cheer Squad is made up of two types of supporters.. Kids who should know better than using unsavory language towards an Official of the game and deserve some leeway due to their age, and adults who should have the book thrown at them for still being in a cheer squad.

Thanks

Carlton

 

[teagueyubeauty]

Agree it’s unbelievable the troll Mumford gets off without any reprimand and or fine minimum.
What’s more pathetic is our footy ops mngr , Llyod applauding and condoning the behavior as desirable. So Krooz should have rammed his knee into any GWS midfielders kidneys in a falling action eyes on the ball of course and squared the ledger?

Yep, it’s clearly legal otherwise he’d have got suspended.
It’s not a game of soccer, this is a brutal sport that is significantly less brutal than it used to be but it’s still a game that when you get the opportunity to legally give a hit you take it.

It’s about time our players found a touch of that white line fever and did whatever it takes to get a win. It’s completely mindset

 

[Dadda Dave]

Just as an aside, on Sam McClure's "Time On" show tonight, he said the AFL have sent a "Please Explain" to Carlton for the Cheer Squad calling the umpires "w***ers" in the Collingwood game in Round 8 two weeks ago. Gees, the AFL are really after us for some reason. This is the game where Collingwood had 24 free kicks to our 8 for the game.

And what about the 50k blues supporters ..ban them from games ??they were calling them w***ers too ..I know I was from my lounge ..

 

[Blue and Blue]

Yep, it’s clearly legal otherwise he’d have got suspended.
It’s not a game of soccer, this is a brutal sport that is significantly less brutal than it used to be but it’s still a game that when you get the opportunity to legally give a hit you take it.

It’s about time our players found a touch of that white line fever and did whatever it takes to get a win. It’s completely mindset

Now your talking mongrel.... JustaBattler will be buying you a beer.....

 

[Keyza]

Ummm, 28-8

It was 24 to 8.

 

[Keyza]

Just as an aside, on Sam McClure's "Time On" show tonight, he said the AFL have sent a "Please Explain" to Carlton for the Cheer Squad calling the umpires "w***ers" in the Collingwood game in Round 8 two weeks ago. Gees, the AFL are really after us for some reason. This is the game where Collingwood had 24 free kicks to our 8 for the game.

Supporters and cheer squads have doing this for as long as I can remember.
My goodness, the AFL are showing that they do in fact have an agenda against us.

 

[MrsEddieBetts]

Don’t believe everything on Twitter you guys. The cheer squad said it’s the first they’ve heard of it.

 

[HBF]

Pretty fair outcome really for Daisy.

 

[brixyblue]

Yep, it’s clearly legal otherwise he’d have got suspended.
It’s not a game of soccer, this is a brutal sport that is significantly less brutal than it used to be but it’s still a game that when you get the opportunity to legally give a hit you take it.

It’s about time our players found a touch of that white line fever and did whatever it takes to get a win. It’s completely mindset

Would have thought durdins shepherd was completely legal still got a week

 

[Burgers45]

It’s about time our players found a touch of that white line fever and did whatever it takes to get a win. It’s completely mindset.

Who would you consider in our team is aggressive or hard enough to do this?

 

[Jabba73]

It’s about time our players found a touch of that white line fever and did whatever it takes to get a win. It’s completely mindset.

Who would you consider in our team is aggressive or hard enough to do this?

There is a whole thread on this, seems even though we don’t really have enough, there is a bit to work with.

 

[manang magoos]

It was 24 to 8.

Pretty fair outcome really for Daisy.

Yer fair fine umps went to AFL and said $7500 would be enough for end of year piss up for
agreeing to screw us over

 

[Osc1]

Don’t believe everything on Twitter you guys. The cheer squad said it’s the first they’ve heard of it.

I heard them saying it. I was sitting in the box above them, it was crystal clear and hilarious !!

 

[Dramoth]

It’s in the heat of the moment, adrenaline and emotions running through the veins. I know I did and said things on the footy field I would never say off it. I’ve heard way worse (directed at umps on the field) that has been simply shrugged off due to ‘the moment’.
I agree with you outside of this though.

I sung out, on the field in primary school, "You're a ******* idiot!"... those exact words... aimed at the umpire... who unfortunately was also a teacher at my school. Fortunately, one of my team mates had done something stupid further up the ground passed the umpire/teacher, so I was able to blag my way out of it by saying I had aimed it at my team mate who made the mistake!

 

[thylacine60]

Yer fair fine umps went to AFL and said $7500 would be enough for end of year piss up for
agreeing to screw us over

this poster actually believes this

 

[rezzi]

My rage is indescribable.

I understand the umpires grant 1 warning before penalising the 6-6-6 rule but to be charged with umpire dissent is ******* insane.

Next year you’ll be fine for forgetting to say “thank you” after getting a free kick.

 

[JustaBattler]

I disagree, that was a calculated response from the club.

Start hardening the **** up, grow some balls and be much harder at the football and the man

I so hope you are right - all I've seen from Carlton FOR 20 YEARS is a bunch of soft underbellied puppies - with precious few exceptions.

 

[Jabba73]

My rage is indescribable.

I understand the umpires grant 1 warning before penalising the 6-6-6 rule but to be charged with umpire dissent is ******* insane.

Next year you’ll be fine for forgetting to say “thank you” after getting a free kick.

Finally, a rule change that won’t effect us

 

[thylacine60]

My rage is indescribable.

I understand the umpires grant 1 warning before penalising the 6-6-6 rule but to be charged with umpire dissent is ******* insane.

Next year you’ll be fine for forgetting to say “thank you” after getting a free kick.

and rightly so - game doesn't need rudeness or poor manners.........

 

[Kruezing]

and rightly so - game doesn't need rudeness or poor manners.........

You’re right ... I think it’s very bad manners they don’t hand out lube to Carlton supporters on the way into the ground ... I’m sure many would be politely thankful ...

 

[Wickzki]

Don’t believe everything on Twitter you guys. The cheer squad said it’s the first they’ve heard of it.

https://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/...t/news-story/e0d3c83f974cd4cc28fb5fa797585a77

Honestly, given how awful the free kick differential was in that game I'm genuinely surprised that's all they did.

It's still, I believe, the only game of that round not released in the umpire's report -- I wonder why.

 

[FlowersByIrene]

https://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/...t/news-story/e0d3c83f974cd4cc28fb5fa797585a77

Honestly, given how awful the free kick differential was in that game I'm genuinely surprised that's all they did.

It's still, I believe, the only game of that round not released in the umpire's report -- I wonder why.

They release umpire reports?

 

[Bamboo Harvester]

Dear Gill
I have spoken to the leaders of our Cheer Squad, and they have requested me to solemnly express to you, "get ****** Boofhead."
Yours sincerely,
Mark LoGiudice

 

[Wickzki]

They release umpire reports?

They regularly say whether or not a game gets an "all clear."

 

[rezzi]

and rightly so - game doesn't need rudeness or poor manners.........

hey...they started it