2019 Planning Thread

[markm106]

Definitely a watch and see. Averaged 79 last year so will need to average in 90s yo make it worth while.

 

[Hai_Newman]

Yeah I’d be staying away from Hogan next year.

Agreed, that fwd line will take year or 2 to click into gear.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Definitely a watch and see. Averaged 79 last year so will need to average in 90s yo make it worth while.

At his price, I'm thinking a 90 is not enough for a midfielder ......give me Brad Crouch who'll go 105-110 and probably at a cheaper price

 

[stevebbb]

he's a gun of a player, love watching him play. He's St Kilda's best player already

I might take a punt

 

[stevebbb]

At his price, I'm thinking a 90 is not enough for a midfielder ......give me Brad Crouch who'll go 105-110 and probably at a cheaper price

he's a forward in SC though. 90-95 would be acceptable for F4-F6

Any chance he gets Mid/Fwd DPP?

 

[WaynesWorld19]

he's a gun of a player, love watching him play. He's St Kilda's best player already

I might take a punt

Welcome back ....We know SuperCoach is at hand, when Steve wakes up from his post season slumber

 

[Hai_Newman]

Definitely a watch and see. Averaged 79 last year so will need to average in 90s yo make it worth while.

Watch list for me, jump on at the right time at the right price. After the China game maybe a good time to bring him ala The Chad last few years.
Can't see him being a top 6 fwd but may be a handy bench player.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

he's a forward in SC though. 90-95 would be acceptable for F4-F6

Any chance he gets Mid/Fwd DPP?

Why not ...everyone else is .....so many forward options this year, means he may still not sneak into our forwards, whilst playing midfield minutes

FFS .....start SuperCoach Gold Picker !!!!

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Watch list for me, jump on at the right time at the right price. After the China game maybe a good time to bring him ala The Chad last few years.
Can't see him being a top 6 fwd but may be a handy bench player.

What price do you expect him to be ?

 

[pincrusher]

What price do you expect him to be ?

$435k using last years multiplier. Probably a little more than that though as it goes up slightly each year.

 

[Hai_Newman]

What price do you expect him to be ?

I may take a risk on him after his bye at 400kish maybe, really depends on the Saints form I guess.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

$435k using last years multiplier. Probably a little more than that though as it goes up slightly each year.

That's an awkward price

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

That's an awkward price

Would be worth it for every St Kilda player maybe

 

[pincrusher]

Would be worth it for every St Kilda player maybe

With a $100k discount if you include Billings.

 

[SavDog23]

Inb4 all the "hEy guyS sHOulD I sTart DAngErField aS a FoRWard?" posts

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Would be worth it for every St Kilda player maybe

In a side that may struggle this year & with Gresham having to learn midfield ....it seems a big leap of faith to me

I didn't have any St Kilda players last year ....apart from starting with the man, who's name shall not be mentioned ......avoided Clark, avoided Coffield

Might look very closely at Acres and Jimmy Webster, whose price should fall somewhat ....given his injury ridden last 3rd of the season

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Inb4 all the "hEy guyS sHOulD I sTart DAngErField aS a FoRWard?" posts

No, your late ....all those Dangerfield posts have already been done

 

[SavDog23]

No, your late ....all those Dangerfield posts have already been done

 

[Andrew Birch]

At his price, I'm thinking a 90 is not enough for a midfielder ......give me Brad Crouch who'll go 105-110 and probably at a cheaper price

I like BCrouch, but can't see him having a breakout season after missing the whole season. The last time he missed a year he went backwards. A 90-92 average would be a realistic return for Brad in 2019 for mine.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

I like BCrouch, but can't see him having a breakout season after missing the whole season. The last time he missed a year he went backwards. A 90-92 average would be a realistic return for Brad in 2019 for mine.

View attachment 592034

Yes I agree .... but he’s never had an uninterrupted season, never had a full PS

He’s been back training a couple of months now after the groin operation .... my only proviso is he gets a full PS in .... if he does I think the 105-110 is realistic

 

[Hai_Newman]

Inb4 all the "hEy guyS sHOulD I sTart DAngErField aS a FoRWard?" posts

No, Dangerstud is all mine!!!

 

[Andrew Birch]

Yes I agree .... but he’s never had an uninterrupted season, never had a full PS

He’s been back training a couple of months now after the groin operation .... my only proviso is he gets a full PS in .... if he does I think the 105-110 is realistic

He'd be a bit more tempting with a 30% price discount. Good signs with his fitness though.

 

[Andrew Birch]

In a side that may struggle this year & with Gresham having to learn midfield ....it seems a big leap of faith to me

I didn't have any St Kilda players last year ....apart from starting with the man, who's name shall not be mentioned ......avoided Clark, avoided Coffield

Might look very closely at Acres and Jimmy Webster, whose price should fall somewhat ....given his injury ridden last 3rd of the season

Anyone know how big Dylan Roberton is recovering from his heart scare? 68 average from 4 games, might also get a 20%? discount? Averaged 93 the previous year...

 

[BuddysBuddy23]

https://supercoachtalk.com/2019-rookie-bible/
Bit of light reading on some of the up and coming rookies for 2019. Apologies if link has already been posted

 

[WaynesWorld19]

He'd be a bit more tempting with a 30% price discount. Good signs with his fitness though.

Andrew ....Brad Crouch's last 4 games (2017) ......3 Finals a R23

And he still had an interrupted PS .....but with continuity & in the big games, he produces

Sloane will be tagged ....that'll release Brad early in the season