2019 Planning Thread

[WaynesWorld19]

Gotta feel sorry for Docherty, after 12 months out everything was looking up... Co Captaincy etc!

It's going to leave CARL short on experience in DEF .....at 34, I can see Simpson falling away quickly, and can Carlton afford to depend on Simmo again ?

 

[faible]

It's going to leave CARL short on experience in DEF .....at 34, I can see Simpson falling away quickly, and can Carlton afford to depend on Simmo again ?

Is Nic Newman a DEF or MID this year?

 

[Fourthorn!]

It's going to leave CARL short on experience in DEF .....at 34, I can see Simpson falling away quickly, and can Carlton afford to depend on Simmo again ?

Doesn’t miss many games Simpson... but you’re right, even a soft tissue injury at 34 will keep him out for a bit. Carlton supporters would be devastated.

 

[NSWCROW]

 

[gutsroy]

So Doch would have been 511k, by looks.
Naismith / Z Clarke of interest.
Hanners enticing the Chol if uncooked, Setterfield confirmed cheap.
Brouch 418k, Greene 354k.Brodie Smith 332k, but card-carrying member of the Burnman club.
https://outline.com/wW8kCX

 

[gcsunsfc]

Feel horrible for him.
Would just be crying.

 

[gutsroy]

I think Clarke only plays if Bellchambers is injured (or rested). So likely to get intermittent games but unless there's an LTI he won't make enough cash to bother with if he's RUC only.

Fort seems likely to get games, or a floating RUC / FWD donut with Westhoff adds value.



Goldy / Westhoff a sneaky chance?

Gawn / Grundy are pretty well priced as high as they're going to get, swing Westhoff FWD and trade in whichever one is the better option in if Goldstein can hold up his end of the bargain?

Also on option, absolutely

 

[SavDog23]

Docherty looking to be at 350k in 2020 SuperCoach

 

[faible]

So Doch would have been 511k, by looks.
Naismith / Z Clarke of interest.
Hanners enticing the Chol if uncooked, Setterfield confirmed cheap.
Brouch 418k, Greene 354k.Brodie Smith 332k, but card-carrying member of the Burnman club.
https://outline.com/wW8kCX

Brutal.

 

[JT_the_Man]

Say it again JT!

BigFooty really wanted the word to get out on this one it seems.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Brutal.

Timing of the post on his SC results couldn't have been worse

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

Nick Riewoldt to make a comeback in Docherty’s place Here2tellyouwhy

Would have and or bang

 

[gutsroy]

Pretty sure he's DEF.

 

[gutsroy]

Is Nic Newman a DEF or MID this year?

Sorry, forgot to reply, but see above post, looks like DEF.

 

[gutsroy]

Would have and or bang

'Or' completely superfluous there.

 

[Jiska]

Now official.

Docherty an absolute un-lock. Bad luck to all you pricks that just jinxed him.

https://www.news.com.au/sport/afl/c...y/news-story/7dc606af05fcc356fc9fe0f711e07dab

 

[faible]

Pretty sure he's DEF.

Newman a sneaky chance with Docherty out then? Similar-ish kind of role off half-back and Newman can certainly score.

 

[Dark Sharks]

Couldn't have scripted a more savage start. Biggest lock for the season has been removed from the chess board



Times like these make me want to roll the dice on Billdick

 

[gutsroy]

Newman a sneaky chance with Docherty out then? Similar-ish kind of role off half-back and Newman can certainly score.

Reckon he's a chance, maybe Williamson, too(?), not as across the Carlton DEFs.

 

[faible]

Couldn't have scripted a more savage start. Biggest lock for the season has been removed from the chess board



Times like these make me want to roll the dice on Billdick

Do it.

 

[Jcpdragonx]

Thinking Milera to take docs spot. Whitfield and Williams locks.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Thinking Milera to take docs spot. Whitfield and Williams locks.

You sure ? ......I'm not sure he'll get enough of the ball, with Smith back at HB ......depends on where he plays thru the JLT series though

 

[Me Myself and I]

Reckon he's a chance, maybe Williamson, too(?), not as across the Carlton DEFs.

Williamson - $189,500
Coming back from LTI though.

 

[Jcpdragonx]

You sure ? ......I'm not sure he'll get enough of the ball, with Smith back at HB ......depends on where he plays thru the JLT series though

Truly believe Milera is a special talent. 1st in time trial and looks in top shape. If he's at ~420k I'll probably pick him, pending on a few pre season reports.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Truly believe Milera is a special talent. 1st in time trial and looks in top shape. If he's at ~420k I'll probably pick him, pending on a few pre season reports.

You may not have seen my signature that's been un-changed for 2 years !