2019 Player of the Year Leaderboard

Remove this Banner Ad

ZoBlitz

The Ghost Who Walks
Sep 20, 2004
8,224
12,467
Brisbane/Melbourne
AFL Club
Brisbane Lions
Round 15 Results:

BL 15.17.107 - MEL 11.8.74 at the Gabba

5 Votes - Dayne Zorko (180 votes)
4 Votes - Eric Hipwood (179 votes)
3 Votes - Lachie Neale (166 votes)
2 Votes - Jarryd Lyons (123 votes)
1 Vote - Stefan Martin (111 votes)

Leaderboard after Round 15:

42 - Lachie Neale
33 - Daniel Rich
26 - Hugh McCluggage
19 - Dayne Zorko
18 - Harris Andrews
14 - Mitch Robinson
9 - Charlie Cameron
9 - Eric Hipwood
8 - Jarryd Lyons
6 - Oscar McInerney
5 - Lincoln McCarthy
5 - Jarrod Berry
5 - Josh Walker
3 - Lewis Taylor
3 - Darcy Gardiner
3 - Stefan Martin
2 - Noah Answerth [best rookie]
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

ZoBlitz

The Ghost Who Walks
Sep 20, 2004
8,224
12,467
Brisbane/Melbourne
AFL Club
Brisbane Lions
Round 16 Results:

GWS 11.8.74 - BL 14.10.94 at Giants Stadium

5 Votes - Lincoln McCarthy (208 votes)
4 Votes - Harris Andrews (192 votes)
3 Votes - Lachie Neale (187 votes)
2 Votes - Hugh McCluggage (172 votes)
1 Vote - Noah Answerth (53 votes)

Leaderboard after Round 16:

45 - Lachie Neale
33 - Daniel Rich
28 - Hugh McCluggage
22 - Harris Andrews
19 - Dayne Zorko
14 - Mitch Robinson
10 - Lincoln McCarthy
9 - Charlie Cameron
9 - Eric Hipwood
8 - Jarryd Lyons
6 - Oscar McInerney
5 - Jarrod Berry
5 - Josh Walker
3 - Lewis Taylor
3 - Noah Answerth [best rookie]
3 - Darcy Gardiner
3 - Stefan Martin
 

ZoBlitz

The Ghost Who Walks
Sep 20, 2004
8,224
12,467
Brisbane/Melbourne
AFL Club
Brisbane Lions
Round 17 Results:

PTA 6.13.49 - BL 14.13.97 at Adelaide Oval

5 Votes - Jarryd Lyons (168 votes)
4 Votes - Dayne Zorko (165 votes)
3 Votes - Mitch Robinson (127 votes)
2 Votes - Charlie Cameron (120 votes)
1 Vote - Lincoln McCarthy (84 votes)

Leaderboard after Round 17:

45 - Lachie Neale
33 - Daniel Rich
28 - Hugh McCluggage
23 - Dayne Zorko
22 - Harris Andrews
17 - Mitch Robinson
13 - Jarryd Lyons
11 - Lincoln McCarthy
11 - Charlie Cameron
9 - Eric Hipwood
6 - Oscar McInerney
5 - Jarrod Berry
5 - Josh Walker
3 - Lewis Taylor
3 - Noah Answerth [best rookie]
3 - Darcy Gardiner
3 - Stefan Martin
 

DERRINALPHIL

Club Legend
Sep 16, 2001
1,073
1,419
Behind the goals at the BSO
AFL Club
Brisbane Lions
Other Teams
Fitzroy, Detroit Lions Mercantile C
I umpire cricket games where we have to award votes. We have six votes to give and can give a maximum of three to any one player. You can give any combination that adds up to six. Very useful in one day games where any one, only allowed nine overs, bowlers find it hard to dominate.

On our BF I often only give four players votes and the Gold Coast game was an example where I thought that four players (they received far more votes than the rest) were considerably better than the rest. I didn't worry abut a one vote as you could raffle it between lots of players.

Against Collingwood ( IIRC)I only gave three players votes.

What do others do?
 

Dylan12

Brownlow Medallist
Sep 7, 2007
20,203
20,254
Melbourne
AFL Club
Brisbane Lions
Other Teams
Chelsea, Boston Red Sox
I umpire cricket games where we have to award votes. We have six votes to give and can give a maximum of three to any one player. You can give any combination that adds up to six. Very useful in one day games where any one, only allowed nine overs, bowlers find it hard to dominate.

On our BF I often only give four players votes and the Gold Coast game was an example where I thought that four players (they received far more votes than the rest) were considerably better than the rest. I didn't worry abut a one vote as you could raffle it between lots of players.

Against Collingwood ( IIRC)I only gave three players votes.

What do others do?
You have to give 5 players votes. That’s what the comp asks for. Personally, I think the poll shouldn’t accept votes unless 5 players are given votes.
 

Dlions

Norm Smith Medallist
Aug 12, 2016
8,064
9,574
AFL Club
Brisbane Lions
You have to give 5 players votes. That’s what the comp asks for. Personally, I think the poll shouldn’t accept votes unless 5 players are given votes.
If I don’t think players deserve votes, I won’t give them a vote just for the sake of it!
There has been a couple of times where I have really struggled to find five.
Probably back to back games in round 4 and 5 this year comes to mind, where I may have only voted for three or 4 players!
 

ZoBlitz

The Ghost Who Walks
Sep 20, 2004
8,224
12,467
Brisbane/Melbourne
AFL Club
Brisbane Lions
Round 18 Results:

BL 12.15.87 - NM 12.3.75 at the Gabba

5 Votes - Jarryd Lyons (184 votes)
4 Votes - Allen Christensen (107 votes)
3 Votes - Daniel Rich (92 votes)
2 Votes - Dayne Zorko (70 votes)
1 Vote - Darcy Gardiner (64 votes)
1 Vote - Oscar McInerney (64 votes)

Leaderboard after Round 18:

45 - Lachie Neale
36 - Daniel Rich
28 - Hugh McCluggage
25 - Dayne Zorko
22 - Harris Andrews
18 - Jarryd Lyons
17 - Mitch Robinson
11 - Lincoln McCarthy
11 - Charlie Cameron
9 - Eric Hipwood
7 - Oscar McInerney
5 - Jarrod Berry
5 - Josh Walker
4 - Allen Christensen
4 - Darcy Gardiner
3 - Lewis Taylor
3 - Noah Answerth [best rookie]
3 - Stefan Martin
 

ZoBlitz

The Ghost Who Walks
Sep 20, 2004
8,224
12,467
Brisbane/Melbourne
AFL Club
Brisbane Lions
Round 19 Results:

HAW 7.18.60 - BL 13.9.87 at University of Tasmania Stadium

5 Votes - Mitch Robinson (128 votes)
5 Votes - Lachie Neale (128 votes)
3 Votes - Dayne Zorko (116 votes)
2 Votes - Hugh McCluggage (115 votes)
1 Vote - Noah Answerth (68 votes)

Leaderboard after Round 19:

50 - Lachie Neale
36 - Daniel Rich
30 - Hugh McCluggage
28 - Dayne Zorko
22 - Harris Andrews
22 - Mitch Robinson
18 - Jarryd Lyons
11 - Lincoln McCarthy
11 - Charlie Cameron
9 - Eric Hipwood
7 - Oscar McInerney
5 - Jarrod Berry
5 - Josh Walker
4 - Allen Christensen
4 - Noah Answerth [best rookie]
4 - Darcy Gardiner
3 - Lewis Taylor
3 - Stefan Martin
 

ZoBlitz

The Ghost Who Walks
Sep 20, 2004
8,224
12,467
Brisbane/Melbourne
AFL Club
Brisbane Lions
Round 20 Results:

BL 14.14.98 - WB 11.14.80 at the Gabba

5 Votes - Mitch Robinson (145 votes)
4 Votes - Charlie Cameron (135 votes)
3 Votes - Jarrod Berry (107 votes)
2 Votes - Stefan Martin (68 votes)
1 Vote - Noah Answerth (58 votes)

Leaderboard after Round 20:

50 - Lachie Neale
36 - Daniel Rich
30 - Hugh McCluggage
28 - Dayne Zorko
27 - Mitch Robinson
22 - Harris Andrews
18 - Jarryd Lyons
15 - Charlie Cameron
11 - Lincoln McCarthy
9 - Eric Hipwood
8 - Jarrod Berry
7 - Oscar McInerney
5 - Stefan Martin
5 - Noah Answerth [best rookie]
5 - Josh Walker
4 - Allen Christensen
4 - Darcy Gardiner
3 - Lewis Taylor
 

ZoBlitz

The Ghost Who Walks
Sep 20, 2004
8,224
12,467
Brisbane/Melbourne
AFL Club
Brisbane Lions
Round 21 Results:

BL 22.12.144 - GC 8.5.53 at the Gabba

5 Votes - Charlie Cameron (142 votes)
4 Votes - Jarryd Lyons (127 votes)
3 Votes - Dayne Zorko (124 votes)
2 Votes - Mitch Robinson (99 votes)
1 Vote - Jarrod Berry (59 votes)

Leaderboard after Round 21:

50 - Lachie Neale
36 - Daniel Rich
31 - Dayne Zorko
30 - Hugh McCluggage
29 - Mitch Robinson
22 - Jarryd Lyons
22 - Harris Andrews
20 - Charlie Cameron
11 - Lincoln McCarthy
9 - Eric Hipwood
9 - Jarrod Berry
7 - Oscar McInerney
5 - Stefan Martin
5 - Noah Answerth [best rookie]
5 - Josh Walker
4 - Allen Christensen
4 - Darcy Gardiner
3 - Lewis Taylor
 

Gadzorks

Premium Gold
Oct 23, 2015
4,697
6,445
AFL Club
Brisbane Lions
You have to give 5 players votes. That’s what the comp asks for. Personally, I think the poll shouldn’t accept votes unless 5 players are given votes.
I don’t vote for that reason - can always get top three in my mind but then it all gets to close for me to make a call. Maybe I’m just a wuss
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

ZoBlitz

The Ghost Who Walks
Sep 20, 2004
8,224
12,467
Brisbane/Melbourne
AFL Club
Brisbane Lions
Round 22 Results:

BL 10.15.75 - GEE 10.14.74 at the Gabba

5 Votes - Charlie Cameron (179 votes)
4 Votes - Marcus Adams (174 votes) [first Player of the Year votes awarded]
3 Votes - Jarryd Lyons (143 votes)
2 Votes - Hugh McCluggage (130 votes)
1 Vote - Stefan Martin (102 votes)

Leaderboard after Round 22:

50 - Lachie Neale
36 - Daniel Rich
32 - Hugh McCluggage
31 - Dayne Zorko
29 - Mitch Robinson
25 - Charlie Cameron
25 - Jarryd Lyons
22 - Harris Andrews
11 - Lincoln McCarthy
9 - Eric Hipwood
9 - Jarrod Berry
7 - Oscar McInerney
6 - Stefan Martin
5 - Noah Answerth [best rookie]
5 - Josh Walker
4 - Allen Christensen
4 - Marcus Adams
4 - Darcy Gardiner
3 - Lewis Taylor
 

ZoBlitz

The Ghost Who Walks
Sep 20, 2004
8,224
12,467
Brisbane/Melbourne
AFL Club
Brisbane Lions
Round 23 Results:

RICH 12.10.82 - BL 8.7.55 at the MCG

5 Votes - Lachie Neale (135 votes)
4 Votes - Dayne Zorko (128 votes)
3 Votes - Hugh McCluggage (122 votes)
2 Votes - Mitch Robinson (73 votes)
1 Vote - Daniel Rich (51 votes)

Leaderboard after Round 23:

55 - Lachie Neale
37 - Daniel Rich
35 - Hugh McCluggage
35 - Dayne Zorko
31 - Mitch Robinson
25 - Charlie Cameron
25 - Jarryd Lyons
22 - Harris Andrews
11 - Lincoln McCarthy
9 - Eric Hipwood
9 - Jarrod Berry
7 - Oscar McInerney
6 - Stefan Martin
5 - Noah Answerth [best rookie]
5 - Josh Walker
4 - Allen Christensen
4 - Marcus Adams
4 - Darcy Gardiner
3 - Lewis Taylor
 

ZoBlitz

The Ghost Who Walks
Sep 20, 2004
8,224
12,467
Brisbane/Melbourne
AFL Club
Brisbane Lions
So are we announcing the winner of the home and away?

Could you post your break down of the season? My OC personality wants to break down the raw scores.
I was going to do it as per how the club has handled best and fairest's in years where we've made the finals in that voting will just continue on from the home and away rounds. It's just I'll also keep a record of the best finals player as well.

I'll put up my voting spreadsheets at the end of our season, whenever it finally finishes.
 

ZoBlitz

The Ghost Who Walks
Sep 20, 2004
8,224
12,467
Brisbane/Melbourne
AFL Club
Brisbane Lions
Second Qualifying Final Results:

BL 8.17.65 - RICH 18.4.112 at the Gabba

5 Votes - Luke Hodge (118 votes)
4 Votes - Lachie Neale (106 votes)
3 Votes - Cam Rayner (70 votes)
2 Votes - Hugh McCluggage (54 votes)
1 Vote - Dayne Zorko (52 votes)

Leaderboard after Second Qualifying Final:

59 - Lachie Neale
37 - Hugh McCluggage
37 - Daniel Rich
36 - Dayne Zorko
31 - Mitch Robinson
25 - Charlie Cameron
25 - Jarryd Lyons
22 - Harris Andrews
11 - Lincoln McCarthy
9 - Eric Hipwood
9 - Jarrod Berry
7 - Oscar McInerney
6 - Stefan Martin
5 - Luke Hodge [best finals player]
5 - Noah Answerth [best rookie]
5 - Josh Walker
4 - Allen Christensen
4 - Marcus Adams
4 - Darcy Gardiner
3 - Lewis Taylor
3 - Cam Rayner
 

ZoBlitz

The Ghost Who Walks
Sep 20, 2004
8,224
12,467
Brisbane/Melbourne
AFL Club
Brisbane Lions
Second Semi Final Results:

BL 11.14.80 - GWS 12.11.83 at the Gabba

5 Votes - Stefan Martin (119 votes)
4 Votes - Dayne Zorko (109 votes)
3 Votes - Daniel Rich (93 votes)
2 Votes - Luke Hodge (91 votes)
1 Vote - Hugh McCluggage (49 votes)

Final Leaderboard:

Winner - 59 votes - Lachie Neale! (Most votes recorded in a season)
Equal Runner Up - 40 votes - Dayne Zorko
Equal Runner Up - 40 votes - Daniel Rich
Third Place - 38 votes - Hugh McCluggage
Best Rookie - 5 votes - Noah Answerth
Best Finals Player - 7 votes - Luke Hodge

31 - Mitch Robinson
25 - Charlie Cameron
25 - Jarryd Lyons
22 - Harris Andrews
11 - Lincoln McCarthy
11 - Stefan Martin
9 - Eric Hipwood
9 - Jarrod Berry
7 - Luke Hodge [best finals player]
7 - Oscar McInerney
5 - Noah Answerth [best rookie]
5 - Josh Walker
4 - Allen Christensen
4 - Marcus Adams
4 - Darcy Gardiner
3 - Lewis Taylor
3 - Cam Rayner

Random Notes:

- Lachie Neale's tally of seven best on grounds equals Dayne Beams' effort in 2015.
- Lachie Neale polled the most amount of votes with 59, beating Stefan Martin's 53 votes in 2015.
- This season had the largest margin between first and second, 19 votes margin compared with the previous largest, a 6 vote margin between Dayne Beams and Harris Andrews in 2018.
- Daniel McStay is the first player, since I've been looking after the player of the year voting from 2015, that has played every game in the season and not recorded a vote.

I've attached the raw data spreadsheet for the year. Any mistakes are my own.
 

Attachments


Top Bottom