2019 Player X v Y v Z

[Judd_Magic]

Yep...guess who I started with
What was I thinking?

 

[King_Steele]

L. Parker + Darling
vs
Fyfe + Worpal.

Fyfe & Worpel

 

[Andrewy]

Yeah..went off a bit early

 

[King_Steele]

Hickey

+1.

 

[SELFCONFESDAFLNERD]

Should I field Duursma or Setterfield? (via Moore)

Field Constable or Cousins?

Right now I'm leaning towards Setters and Cousins but I'm generally horrible at making these decisions so I always 2nd/3rd/...50th guess myself

 

[Benno_900]

Should I field Duursma or Setterfield? (via Moore)

Field Constable or Cousins?

Right now I'm leaning towards Setters and Cousins but I'm generally horrible at making these decisions so I always 2nd/3rd/...50th guess myself

Setterfield and Cousins

 

[Changa10]

Should I field Duursma or Setterfield? (via Moore)

Field Constable or Cousins?

Right now I'm leaning towards Setters and Cousins but I'm generally horrible at making these decisions so I always 2nd/3rd/...50th guess myself

If you fielding Constable will make Cousins play well and score well, I say field Constable!

I'm with you though, I usually get these all wrong. Blind luck had me field Scott and Drew last week though. About the only thing in my team that went well.

Constable & Duursma.

 

[Mitchell54]

Trade Gawn or Grundy?

Also who do i field in minds and forward.

Mids: Walsh, Constable, Scott

Fwds: Setterfield, Drew, Parker

need two of each.

 

[Squiba]

Opinions on choosing a rookie option of Scott/Atkins/Constable to field?

Apologies but I was away last weekend and didn't see any of them play, not even Scott's sexy sexy tonne

 

[Hava Alle]

Start 2. Constable-Scott-Walsh.

 

[Judd_Magic]

Start 2. Constable-Scott-Walsh.

Walsh and Scott

Based on last week they had more ground time than Constable.

 

[ROOINYOU]

L. Parker + Darling
vs
Fyfe + Worpal.

Not even close mate...you know the answer already!
Parker+ Darling of course

 

[ROOINYOU]

Should I field Duursma or Setterfield? (via Moore)

Field Constable or Cousins?

Right now I'm leaning towards Setters and Cousins but I'm generally horrible at making these decisions so I always 2nd/3rd/...50th guess myself

i'm with you..Setters/Cuz

 

[ROOINYOU]

Trade Gawn or Grundy?

Also who do i field in minds and forward.

Mids: Walsh, Constable, Scott

Fwds: Setterfield, Drew, Parker

need two of each.

not even gonna answer the ruck question.
Bench Constable and Paaaarker!

 

[ROOINYOU]

Opinions on choosing a rookie option of Scott/Atkins/Constable to field?

Apologies but I was away last weekend and didn't see any of them play, not even Scott's sexy sexy tonne

bench Atkins/Constable.
gotta give Scott another go after a tonne mate..

 

[ROOINYOU]

Start 2. Constable-Scott-Walsh.

Scott/Walsh

 

[Dundalis]

Sheed v Hopper v Rockliff in order

 

[samFFC]

Can go Billings -> Rocky (via DPP) or Gus Brayshaw -> Fyfe

So basically:
Billings + Fyfe + 15k
or
Rocky + Brayshaw + 135k

I feel both pairs give a similar seasonal average.
Rocky pair has more cash, but Billings pair uses a forward position which could be handy (and Fyfe is a frequent captain option).

 

[samFFC]

Sheed v Hopper v Rockliff in order

Not sure on Hopper once Jelly back

Rocky average 100
Sheed average 95-100
Hopper average 95

 

[toxic]

Salem v Witherden v Newman

I'm in over think mode

 

[SterlingArcher]

Salem v Witherden v Newman

I'm in over think mode

For this week? Why? Watch round 2, analyse role?

I think Witherden has the best chance of averaging in the top 10-11 of defenders. Newman and Salem may have just had spike games.

 

[samFFC]

For this week? Why? Watch round 2, analyse role?

I think Witherden has the best chance of averaging in the top 10-11 of defenders. Newman and Salem may have just had spike games.

Agree

I have Witho but would wait a week on roles

 

[Hai_Newman]

Salem v Witherden v Newman

I'm in over think mode

 

[toxic]

For this week? Why? Watch round 2, analyse role?

I think Witherden has the best chance of averaging in the top 10-11 of defenders. Newman and Salem may have just had spike games.

Got at least 1 rookie correction to do next week
And I've slapped myself and c realised Toby and Ridley were a mistake

Trade will happen this afternoon

Greene to Parker

Ridley to......

 

[SterlingArcher]

Got at least 1 rookie correction to do next week
And I've slapped myself and c realised Toby and Ridley were a mistake

Trade will happen this afternoon

Greene to Parker

Ridley to......

I think the points gained by going early are negated by the lack of evidence in choosing the right player, but I`d go Witherden in that case still.

2017 87 2018 87 until an injury in round 22.

Should be able to boost up to 92 minimum without much trouble I think.

Plus if they all averaged the same for the year you still end up better with Witherden as already missed out on what is likely to be a top or top 2 score for Newman and Salem.