Teams 2019 Rate My Team (Pre JLT)

Status
Not open for further replies.

Metapod

Club Legend
Joined
Sep 30, 2015
Posts
1,143
Likes
2,397
AFL Club
Richmond
3rd iteration. With Roberton apparently looking fit during intraclub I've shuffled to fit him in at D4. Would be happy with an 80 avg whilst I upgrade all other rookies, leaving him til last/D7. In light of his surgery, I've flipped Fyfe to the healthier Macrae... just too concerned about him missing games early. Ditto flipped Oliver to Kelly due to pre season surgeries. Oliver will be first upgrade target. Gawn > Goldstein was the sacrifice to fund rookie > Roberton... hope it's the right move. Gray still holding on to F3, but may be flipped to Smith or TKelly pending JLT.

1551234377352.png
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Joined
Nov 20, 2013
Posts
2,234
Likes
2,096
AFL Club
Carlton
Did Some tinkering to bring miles into m6 than m5 I feel that’s a good position to put him at with Neale coming in who I have feel is gonna start the yr well. First time picking Neale . Waiting for jlt and rookies to named rnd 1 etc

E17DDC31-469A-4906-999B-8BFBAA7BB6DF.jpeg
 

Quazza

Norm Smith Medallist
Joined
Sep 11, 2006
Posts
6,700
Likes
7,482
Location
Adelaide
AFL Club
Carlton
Other Teams
Golden State Warriors
3rd iteration. With Roberton apparently looking fit during intraclub I've shuffled to fit him in at D4. Would be happy with an 80 avg whilst I upgrade all other rookies, leaving him til last/D7. In light of his surgery, I've flipped Fyfe to the healthier Macrae... just too concerned about him missing games early. Ditto flipped Oliver to Kelly due to pre season surgeries. Oliver will be first upgrade target. Gawn > Goldstein was the sacrifice to fund rookie > Roberton... hope it's the right move. Gray still holding on to F3, but may be flipped to Smith or TKelly pending JLT.

View attachment 626485

*Googles "Clayton Oliver Surgery" *

oh.... well ****
 
Joined
Feb 3, 2019
Posts
13
Likes
10
Location
Wallan
AFL Club
Essendon
Other Teams
Rabbitohs & Melbourne Renegades
3rd iteration. With Roberton apparently looking fit during intraclub I've shuffled to fit him in at D4. Would be happy with an 80 avg whilst I upgrade all other rookies, leaving him til last/D7. In light of his surgery, I've flipped Fyfe to the healthier Macrae... just too concerned about him missing games early. Ditto flipped Oliver to Kelly due to pre season surgeries. Oliver will be first upgrade target. Gawn > Goldstein was the sacrifice to fund rookie > Roberton... hope it's the right move. Gray still holding on to F3, but may be flipped to Smith or TKelly pending JLT.

View attachment 626485
LOL
 

LegendLewis

All Australian
Joined
May 6, 2012
Posts
980
Likes
1,408
Location
on the dance floor
AFL Club
Hawthorn
3rd iteration. With Roberton apparently looking fit during intraclub I've shuffled to fit him in at D4. Would be happy with an 80 avg whilst I upgrade all other rookies, leaving him til last/D7. In light of his surgery, I've flipped Fyfe to the healthier Macrae... just too concerned about him missing games early. Ditto flipped Oliver to Kelly due to pre season surgeries. Oliver will be first upgrade target. Gawn > Goldstein was the sacrifice to fund rookie > Roberton... hope it's the right move. Gray still holding on to F3, but may be flipped to Smith or TKelly pending JLT.

View attachment 626485
Solid Team!
Personally not going the top backs this year but would not discredit anyone that does.
Whitfield and Roberton must haves and I think your rooks are pretty spot on with current info.
McCrae is awesome but I think its better to look at a value pick to gain coin as I doubt he will rise, but again that is personal preference.
Your other premo mids are all good gets and should continue their scoring, I for some reason have doubts on Kelly which tbh I cannot exactly put into words but it has something to do with tagging.
Constable from an inside word is supposedly not the new coming unfortunately as supposedly was not as contested as was hoped for.
Grundy injured but will be fine and I've got Goldy too but starting to wonder if I should actually pick Campbell for Nth instead??
Solid forward line but I reckon McAdam won't be playing first up, think it will be Stengle or Murphy for the spot opposite Eddie. . Cavarra and Parker will be great SC rooks this year but possibly young an unpgrade in the middle of the year.
But who the **** knows at this stage hey :)
 

Metapod

Club Legend
Joined
Sep 30, 2015
Posts
1,143
Likes
2,397
AFL Club
Richmond
Solid Team!
Personally not going the top backs this year but would not discredit anyone that does.
Whitfield and Roberton must haves and I think your rooks are pretty spot on with current info.
McCrae is awesome but I think its better to look at a value pick to gain coin as I doubt he will rise, but again that is personal preference.
Your other premo mids are all good gets and should continue their scoring, I for some reason have doubts on Kelly which tbh I cannot exactly put into words but it has something to do with tagging.
Constable from an inside word is supposedly not the new coming unfortunately as supposedly was not as contested as was hoped for.
Grundy injured but will be fine and I've got Goldy too but starting to wonder if I should actually pick Campbell for Nth instead??
Solid forward line but I reckon McAdam won't be playing first up, think it will be Stengle or Murphy for the spot opposite Eddie. . Cavarra and Parker will be great SC rooks this year but possibly young an unpgrade in the middle of the year.
But who the **** knows at this stage hey :)
Cheers for the feedback mate! Whitfield & Lloyd has been in the team for some time, they’re locks for mine. Sicily was Laird but concerned the new rule changes may impact him a bit (ie Smith kicking long from kick-ins).
Macrae I’m not 100% on. He may be flipped to Oliver if he has a huge JLT game with Viney in team, Zerrett or even Libba and bank the cash ($300k may sound a lot, but I play for cash leagues only). Grundy locked, Goldy watching closely in JLT.
Rookies are placeholders, but looking good. Walsh may suck everyone in (including me) during JLT. Collins the only popular rookie I’m not sold on, reckon he will be a very slow burner
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom