Discussion 2019 Rookies

Tyruddanaut

Team Captain
Joined
Jul 6, 2018
Posts
550
Likes
251
AFL Club
Carlton
Thread starter #1
It's worth mentioning there are some over-rated first round picks (AFL Fantasy Scores):
Tarryn Thomas, Senior avg. 31. 175k.
Nick Blakey, U18 Champs avg. 67. 167k
Jye Caldwell, U18 Champs avg. 33 (I know, injury), State Junior League U18s (2018), 76 avg. 162k
Connor Rozee, SANFL avg. 70 (Decreases significantly at AFL), 189k
Isaac Quaynor, U18s avg. 74, 153,300

Meanwhile, the most underrated is Bailey Smith, 125 avg. U18 Champs, 176 avg. TAC 2018, 118 avg. TAC 2017. 180,300. Big body translates well into AFL scoring
Walsh and Ely Smith should be looked at, too.
Walsh, U18s 142 avg. TAC 151 avg. TAC (2017) 121 avg. 207k
Ely Smith, U18s 122 avg. State Junior 114 avg 117k (Worth mentioning a senior avg. of 73)

Bewley should be a lock (104 senior avg.)
Foley high (115 U18s, 139 TAC, 99 TAC 2017)
Valente high (118 U18s, 159 SANFL U18s)
Hayes (98 senior avg.)
Fort (125 VFL)

TL;DR: What's in bold
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Seymour Skinner

Norm Smith Medallist
Joined
Aug 5, 2014
Posts
5,003
Likes
11,628
Location
Springfield
AFL Club
Richmond
Other Teams
Springfield Isotopes
#2
Noticed we didn't have a rookies thread and HS dropped their "rookie bible" today, I've just copy pasted all this using outline.com so hopefully the formatting isn't too horrendous.

Text walls incoming, enjoy :rainbow:

In those early days of the Gold Coast Suns and GWS Giants we stuffed our squads with cheap kids we knew would get game time, and mature-age recruits ready to make the most of a shot at the big time.

With the Suns embarking on an ambitious list overhaul and an apparent competition-wide search for the next Tim Kelly, 2019 playing lists present potential rookie riches not seen since those glory days.

FORGOTTEN MEN: NINE BIG SUPERCOACH STEALS FOR 2019

SUPERCOACH: TRADED PLAYERS WORTH CONSIDERING FOR YOUR TEAM

Cheapies — players priced at under $200,000 — are the key to a successful SuperCoach team.

Not only do they help you put a squad together under the $10 million salary cap, they help your SuperCoach team grow in overall price during the season, allowing you to upgrade starting players with low prices into premium players who pump out big scores every week.


Tim Kelly was the gun SuperCoach rookie of 2018. Picture: Mike Dugdale
The key is to find players who will get games early in the season, so role and opportunity play a big role in the search for a successful rookie SuperCoach pick.

Pre-season matches will provide an insight into how teams might look when the season kicks off, but if you can’t wait until then here is an early take on the cheapies who should be part of our SuperCoach plans.

Check back for regular updates of this article as we get more insights over the pre-season.

REVEALED: AL PATON’S FIRST DRAFT SUPERCOACH TEAM

RETURNING DOG: LIBBA FIGHTING FIT IN COMEBACK FROM ACL

REVEALED: THE PHANTOM’S FIRST DRAFT SUPERCOACH TEAM

DEFENDERS

Tom Williamson (Carlton) $189,500
Williamson’s 2018 season was ruined by injury, a major blow given he is very highly rated at the Blues. He’s a smooth-moving halfback and with Sam Docherty suffering another ACL tear, some believe Williamson will be the man to fill the void. He played 15 senior games in 2017 and averaged only 49.9 SuperCoach points but will another pre-season under his belt and time in the gym, he should be better equipped for senior footy. The Blues play a high-possession style, which could mean very good things. Watch him over the pre-season.

Connor Rozee (Port Adelaide) $189,300 def/fwd
The No.5 draft pick is lightly-framed but the Power are looking to inject more speed into the midfield following the loss of Jared Polec and Chad Wingard, and Rozee brings just that. He’s had experience playing against senior bodies in the SANFL, which will hold him in good stead as he pushes for a Round 1 debut. He’s also known for his tackling and aggression, two characteristics that should see him in the selection mix. Has played both midfield (157 SuperCoach-point average in 2016 under-16 championships and 104 points in 2017) and forward (74-point SuperCoach average at under-18 carnival), so watch his role over pre-season before making a decision. Still, if he can average 74 points at AFL level you’d take that as a nice cash cow injection.


Port Adelaide young gun Connor Rozee in action at training. Picture: Sarah Reed
Sam Collins (Gold Coast) $188,900
During his first stint in the AFL Collins put up some good scores for Fremantle in 2016-17 (including a 126 against Collingwood) before being delisted by the Dockers after just 14 matches. The 24-year-old gets another chance, this time at the Suns, after an outstanding season in the VFL where he led the league for total marks and contested marks. Should see plenty of action down back for Gold Coast.

JON RALPH: HOW I PLAN TO BEAT ROBBO IN SUPERCOACH

ELIZA SEWELL: BILLINGS DESERVES ANOTHER CHANCE

THE PHANTOM: RUCK ALTERNATIVES TO GRUNDY, GAWN

Isaac Cumming (GWS Giants) $173,700
Cumming was on the radar at this time last year but managed just two AFL games in 2018 for modest SuperCoach returns. With another pre-season under his belt and senior players including Dylan Shiel, Tom Scully and Ryan Griffen departing, there are spots available in the Giants’ best 22. He averaged just over 20 disposals per game in the NEAFL, including one 33-disposal and two-goal game. Could he be 2019’s Jeremy Finlayson?


Can Oleg Markov became a senior regular for the Tigers? Picture: Michael Klein
Oleg Markov (Richmond) $158,000
The Tigers have big raps on Markov but 2019 is surely a make or break year for him. It will be his fourth season at Richmond and given he’s still yet to cement his spot in the team, he needs a big pre-season to get himself in the mix. With the departures of depth players Sam Lloyd, Reece Conca, Corey Ellis and Anthony Miles, there is opportunity for Markov to put himself under coach Damien Hardwick’s nose. Bachar Houli has been a great servant but will the Tigers look to transition Markov into that role? Watch this space. Provides great dash from defence or on the wing and ignored interest from rivals at the end of the year to re-sign with Richmond. Track watchers have told us he’s put on some serious size.

Isaac Quaynor (Collingwood) $153,300
Collingwood’s first-round draft pick has been likened to Bulldog Jason Johannisen for his speed and ability to take the game on, and many believe he’s ready to step into the senior team should an opportunity arise. With an ASADA drug test hanging over Sam Murray, the Pies do need a small rebounding defender and Quaynor definitely fits the bill. He averaged 419m gained in the under-18 championships, ranked No.2 in the competition and was rated elite for contested possessions. Watch his pre-season form.


Can Isaac Quaynor make an immediate impact at Collingwood? Picture: Getty
Jack Scrimshaw (Hawthorn) $149,800
A former No.7 draft pick, Scrimshaw was traded to Hawthorn from Gold Coast during the trade period after never really getting settled in Queensland. The Hawks have a history of turning players from rival clubs into stars and talent doesn’t disappear overnight, so Scrimshaw could be a diamond in the rough. We know coach Alastair Clarkson has given big roles to younger players in the past two years as he regenerates his list for another tilt at a premiership. Look out for him in the JLT Series to gauge whether he’s in the senior selection mix early.

Callum Wilkie (St Kilda) $124,900
Picked up by the Saints in the rookie draft from SANFL club North Adelaide, where he won the best-and-fairest this year as a playmaking defender. The 22-year-old averaged 26 disposals and nine marks a game and could have an immediate impact.

PRICES: SUPERCOACH GUNS WHO’LL BREAK THE BANK

PREMIUMS: THE PLAYERS YOU NEED TO LAUNCH YOUR SEASON

Jordan Clark (Geelong) $144,300
The Cats haven’t been afraid to throw their draftees into the AFL furnace early and Clark could be one to come in and have an immediate impact. The No.15 draft pick has a lot of upside still, after only recently focusing on footy, but has played against senior bodies in the WAFL already which holds him in good stead for a potential debut. He’s a very creative player who could come in and play across halfback to free up Zach Tuohy.

Chris Burgess (Gold Coast) $123,900 def/fwd
One of the Suns’ three priority mature-age access recruits, along with Sam Collins and forward Josh Corbett. The 22-year-old played as a swingman for West Adelaide this year and has been given dual-position status in SuperCoach. It also doubles his chances of selection after the departure of bookends Tom Lynch and Steven May.


Chris Burgess in action at Gold Coast Suns training. Picture: Supplied

Marty Hore is known for his intercept marking. Picture: Michael Klein
Marty Hore (Melbourne) $117,300
Took the second-most marks in the VFL this year (behind Collins) and gets a chance at the Demons at age 22. He is likely to be a back-up for first-choice backmen Steven May and Jake Lever but the Dees chopped and changed their defence a fair bit last season and Lever has had some hiccups in his return from a knee injury. Ready if called upon.

Jez McLennan (Gold Coast) $117,300
The Suns are expected to give their kids plenty of game time next season and McLennan is one who could be given an opportunity. At 185cm and 81kg, he’s got a pretty solid body already and plays across halfback — a perfect position for a young player finding his way in the game. He reads the ball very well in flight and is known for his intercept marking, an area Gold Coast is lacking down back.

DUAL POSITION: WHY DANGER IS AVAILABLE AS A FORWARD IN 2019

STAR EAGLE: YEO’S MIDFIELD MOVE A BLOW FOR SUPERCOACH

Harrison Wigg (Gold Coast) $102,400
Wigg was on plenty of SuperCoach radars 12 months ago after being traded to the Suns from Adelaide following a big season in the SANFL when he averaged 25 disposals, five tackles and 98 SuperCoach points a game. He never got a chance to show what he can do at AFL level in 2018 after breaking his ankle in an early pre-season training session, but if he’s fit for Round 1 he could be a great bottom-priced bench option.

MIDFIELDERS
Sam Walsh (Carlton) $207,300
Normally the No.1 draft pick is overlooked as a cash cow option because their price is steep for an untried AFL player, but Walsh is different. Champion Data described him as one of the most “reliable ball-winners ever seen” after averaging 29 disposals across 41 matches and at least 23 disposals in all 25 of his TAC Cup matches as both an under-age and top-age player. He will join Patrick Cripps in the Blues midfield and be given plenty of opportunities. Watch his scores in the JLT Series before locking him into your team but signs out of Carlton are good if you’re willing to invest over $200,000 of your cap in him.


No.1 pick Sam Walsh should slot straight into Carlton’s midfield. Picture: Alex Coppel
Luke Davies-Uniacke (North Melbourne) $197,500
He was one of the must-have cash cows last season but things didn’t quite go to plan for the No.4 draft pick. Davies-Uniacke was in and out of the North Melbourne side and averaged only 40.4 SuperCoach points per game. With the addition of Jared Polec, Aaron Hall and Dom Tyson, it’s hard to see him playing a big role. Pass.

Bailey Smith (Western Bulldogs) $180,300
At 185cm and 83kg, Smith is ready for senior footy and he’s exactly the type of player the Bulldogs love — he’s a hard runner who is quick, wins plenty of the ball, uses it well and is clean with his hands in contested situations. He has battled a sore Achilles but is expected to be OK by January, which puts him in the frame to impress during the JLT Series. Was ranked behind only Sam Walsh for disposals in the under-18 carnival. Watch this space.


Western Bulldogs draftee Bailey Smith at the club’s pre-season training camp. Picture: Getty
Tarryn Thomas (North Melbourne) $175,800
The talented Tasmanian is exactly the type of X-factor player the Kangaroos are looking for but will he slot straight into their team for Round 1? He can play forward, midfield or down back but with his natural goal sense, he’ll surely get his opportunity inside forward 50, while also pushing up the ground. Unlikely to be a popular choice but that could change with a solid JLT Series campaign.

Harley Bennell (Fremantle) $167,700
We know he’s not a rookie but Benell is rookie priced, so that gets him on this list. If he can get his body right, the Docker would be the cash cow of the year given he has the potential to be an elite player. The only questions are — can he stay fit, and how much does he want it? If he plays in the JLT Series and he’s picked for Round 1, at just $167,700 he is absolutely worth the risk for such a low investment with seriously high scoring potential.

Jye Caldwell (GWS Giants) $162,300
After losing Dylan Shiel, Tom Scully and Ryan Griffen from the midfield, the Giants bolstered their onball brigade with Caldwell at pick No.11 in the draft. He has had some injury troubles but he’s got a strong body already and with good pre-season training and match form, could push himself into the mix for senior selection given there are spots available. He averaged 22 disposals, four clearances and five tackles in his two full TAC Cup games (before injury), which is a great sign.


GWS draftee Jye Caldwell in action during a TAC Cup game. Picture: Getty
Jackson Hately (GWS Giants) $148,800
Like Caldwell, Hately will see opportunities for a senior debut early in 2019 and has the added benefit of already having experience against bigger bodies in the SANFL. He averaged 91 SuperCoach points in the SANFL in 2017 and is an elite stoppage player who tackles hard. He can play almost anywhere because of his size, at 189cm and 80kg, and has been compared to West Coast star Elliot Yeo. He’s on the watch list.

Will Setterfield (Carlton) $144,900 mid/fwd
Former No.5 draft pick is a discount price after playing only two senior games due to injuries, but arrives at Carlton from GWS ready to step straight into the starting midfield at age 20. Showed what he is capable of when he averaged 25 disposals, five clearances and almost eight tackles a game in the NEAFL in 2017 before rupturing his ACL in a practice match early this year. Dual-position status makes him close to a must-have.


Will Setterfield is a must-have. Picture: Michael Klein
Liam Stocker (Carlton) $126,300
The Blues pulled off that risky trade with the Crows to secure Stocker, meaning they must see serious potential in him. He’s already strongly built, with a body that appears ready for AFL footy. He’s been touted as a potential replacement for co-captain Sam Docherty across halfback, while he’s also viewed as a long-term partner for Cripps and Walsh in the midfield. Stocker won the Morrish Medal as the best under-18 player in the TAC Cup, which ticks another box. Can see him being given opportunities to ply his trade early for Carlton. He’s definitely one to closely monitor.

Charlie Constable (Geelong) $123,900
Constable pushed hard for a senior debut in 2018 but despite his impressive VFL form didn’t get his opportunity. He finished top-10 in the Cats’ VFL best and fairest after averaging 24 disposals in his 15 matches, with his best a 34-disposal and one-goal game against eventual premiers Box Hill in Round 21. The tall midfielder will definitely be in the mix to play a role for the Cats in 2019 as they look for more midfield and half-forward options. He’s a must-watch during the JLT Series.


Charlie Constable finished top-10 in Geelong VFL’s best and fairest. Picture: Arj Giese
Joe Atley (Port Adelaide) $123,900
Another of the 2017 draftees to consider, Atley was close to senior selection for the Power in 2018 but didn’t break through for his debut, meaning he’s still a nice price for us. He did have an injury-interrupted season but proved his ball-winning ability by winning 20 or more disposals in most of his SANFL games, finishing with an average of 21.5 in his 10 games. Definitely one have on your list.

Matthew Ling (Sydney Swans) $123,900 mid/fwd
The second-year Swan has pace to burn and could be ready to add some excitement to a regenerating Sydney team. With Gary Rohan, Dan Hannebery and Nic Newman all departing during the trade period, John Longmire will need his younger players to step up and fill the void and Ling could be one of those. He was restricted to just six NEAFL games in 2018 but with a big pre-season can push himself into the frame for a debut. Sydney’s head of development, John Blakey told the club’s website: “We drafted him for a purpose — for his run and his talent he showed through his under-18s year. We get him back next year probably looking like a first-year player again because he hasn’t played much football at all. We’ll be really pleased to get him on the park.” Good signs.

Corey Wagner (Melbourne) $123,900
The ex-Kangaroo was signed by Melbourne under the new rookie rules — does that mean coach Simon Goodwin has a specific role in mind? The Demons have a history of plucking mature-age players (Bayley Fritsch, Mitch Hannan) and turning them into significant role players. Is Wagner the next cab off the rank?

Brett Bewley (Fremantle) $117,300
Recruited from Williamstown, where he averaged 25 disposals a game in 2018 and led the league for effective long kicks. Has been likened to Tom Scully for his running ability. Ross Lyon had success with mature-age recruit Bailey Banfield last year and seems to have taken a liking to the concept.

Luke Valente (Fremantle) $117,300
The classic draft slider, Valente was tipped as a likely first-round selection on draft night but slipped to pick 32, where he was happily snapped up by the Dockers. The South Australian under-18 captain already has an AFL-ready body was ranked the 10th-best player in the draft by Champion Data and rated elite for intercept possessions and score involvements. Think Tiger Jack Graham.

Rhylee West (Western Bulldogs) $117,300
Calder Cannons coach Ross Smith says the son of Bulldogs champion Scott West is ready to play in his first season. “He’s a very mature 18-year-old,” Smith said of West, who averaged 19 disposals, six tackles and a goal in the TAC Cup this year. Smith likened tough onballer West to another hard nut Jack Viney — it’s worth noting he scored 117 SuperCoach points in his AFL debut.


Will you pick Bulldogs father-son recruit Rhylee West? Picture: Getty
Will Hayes (Western Bulldogs) $117,300
The Dogs have a long list of new faces so it’s hard to know what their starting 22 will look like but Hayes is ready to play if needed upon after winning Footscray’s best-and-fairest in the VFL this year. The 23-year-old midfielder averaged 26 disposals and 10 contested possessions a game and finished third in the comp for inside-50s.

Nick Hind (St Kilda) $117,300
Hind’s matchwinning multi-bounce run in the VFL semi-final gave Saints fans, and SuperCoach players, a glimpse of what to look forward to as he dashes off the halfback line in 2019. He averaged 22 disposals, four marks and 87 points a game for Essendon’s VFL side and ranked fourth in the comp for score assists.


Nick Hind can step straight into St Kilda’ best 22 and add some much-needed pace. Picture: Michael Klein
Tom Atkins (Geelong) $112,900
Is the 23-year-old from the Cats’ VFL team the next mature-age success story off master recruiter Stephen Wells’ production line? Atkins, a tough ball-winner and dual VFL best-and-fairest winner, hopes to follow in the footsteps of Tim Kelly, Sam Menegola and Tom Stewart. Put him on the pre-season watch list to see if he can break into Geelong’s star-studded midfield.

Zac Clarke (Essendon) $142,600
Essendon desperately needed ruck depth and that gives Clarke another opportunity at AFL level after being delisted by Fremantle at the end of 2017. He’s never been a big SuperCoach scorer, aside from averaging 96.3 back in 2013, but does have a solid record that includes averages of 83.2, 74.0 and 75.9, all of which would be decent cash builders. The question is: How many games will he play? Can he take the No.1 ruck mantle off Tom Bellchambers?

Darcy Fort (Geelong) $117,300
The 205cm giant finally gets a chance at an AFL club six years after playing for the Geelong Falcons in the TAC Cup. Since then he has spent time in the VFL and the SANFL, where he dominated this year for Central District, averaging 123 SuperCoach points a game. The biggest issue for the 25-year-old will be getting a regular game but the Cats never settled on a starting ruckman last season, trying Rhys Stanley, Zac Smith and Ryan Abbott at various stages. Can Fort go past all of them? Keep a close eye on his pre-season.

Jordan Sweet (Western Bulldogs) $102,400
Another mature-age recruit, Sweet gets a chance at the Dogs at age 20 after a great season for North Adelaide in the SANFL. A versatile big man who can also play up forward, he’s a chance to get a game in a side with limited ruck options.

Shane McAdam (Adelaide) $123,900
The Crows thought enough of the livewire forward to trade Mitch McGovern to Carlton for access to him via AFL rules that allowed the Blues to snare mature-age players before the draft. The nephew of former Saint and Lions star Gilbert McAdam — and cousin of current Blue Sam Petrevski-Seton — stood out for Sturt this year with his tackling pressure, big leap and eye for goal.

Josh Corbett (Gold Coast) $123,900
The third of Gold Coast’s priority mature-age recruits kicked 22 goals for Werribee in the VFL this year before his season was cut short by a nasty eye injury. Before then the North Warrnambool product was averaging almost eight marks a game and was awarded the Fothergill-Round Medal as the VFL’s most promising young talent. Previous winners include Bayley Fritsch, Luke Ryan, Nic Newman and Kane Lambert — names very familiar to SuperCoach players.

Tyson Stengle (Adelaide) $123,900
A clever indigenous goalkicker who didn’t do much wrong in his two seasons on Richmond’s rookie list apart from being fourth or fifth in the queue for a role as a small forward. Kicked 33 goals in 19 games in the VFL and is set to learn under Eddie Betts.

Matt Parker (St Kilda) $117,300
An explosive forward who was digging holes for underground gas pipes to pay the bills while playing in the WAFL this year. Inspired to not give up on his AFL dream by Geelong star and SuperCoach sensation Tim Kelly, Parker kicked 27 goals — and laid 84 tackles — for South Fremantle this year. He was recruited with pick 47 in the national draft and Saints coach Alan Richardson believes his speed and power will suit Marvel Stadium.

Robbie Young (St Kilda) $117,300
The Saints went all-in on ready-to-play state league guns in this year’s draft, with North Adelaide goalkicker Young joining the club via pick 67 in the draft. Likely to push for selection as a high-pressure forward, he wasn’t a big disposal winner this season but can still have a big impact. A six-goal game against Norwood was a season highlight.

Ben Cavarra (Western Bulldogs) $117,300
One of the genuine feel-good stories of the draft after the Dogs called out his name at pick 45. The 22-year-old won a Morrish Medal in the VFL as a midfielder but switched to a small forward role for Werribee in the past two seasons, winning Williamstown’s goalkicking both years. Kicked 34 goals this year but has enough strings to his bow to still average 97 SuperCoach points a game.

Lachlan Schultz (Fremantle) $117,300
Flies west with Williamstown teammate Brett Bewley after joining the Dockers in the fourth round of the draft. The 20-year-old emerged as a classy small forward over the past three years in the VFL with stints in the midfield.

Tom Wilkinson (North Melbourne) $102,400
A small forward plucked from the Southport Sharks after stints with Williamstown and Sandringham (where he won a best-and-fairest) in the VFL. After being overlooked in four drafts, Wilkinson rated elite in the NEAFL in 2018 for goals, accuracy, forward-50 tackles, marks, score assists and contested marks. Can he break into the Kangaroos’ best 22?
 

cfx_1

Club Legend
Joined
Feb 7, 2010
Posts
1,253
Likes
180
Location
New Farm
AFL Club
Collingwood
#7
Xavier O'halloran and Ian Hill from GWS look promising, as does Noah Answerth and Ely Smith from the Lions. Ely the most likely to get a round 1 berth depending on JLT form. Throw these onto your watch list. My write up on these guys;


Xavier O’Halloran (Pick 22 Mid only 117k)

Great size and speed give Xavier an all-round package that is hard to pass up. Similar in style to Jordan De Goey he is AFL ready in size and has great marking power and has X factor at stoppages. Also has great leadership qualities both captaining the Western Jets and Vic Country at the Under 18 champs.

- 187cm, 83kg (AFL Ready)

- 5th in the Yo-Yo test at the national combine

- 9 goals in 13 games in the TAC Cup

- Averaged 18.8 Disposals, inc 13.9 kicks and 4.9 handballs, great kick to handball ratio

- Averaged 4.7 tackles, 3.3 marks, 5.5 clearances and 9.2 CP’s

Ian Hill (Pick 24, Mid-Fwd 117k)

Ian Hill is Stephen and Brad Hill’s cousin. And plays quite similarly to the pair, pacey small forward or outside midfielder with legs to burn. Has a high vertical leap also and could yet become a highlight reel player. The giants live traded up 4 spots to grab Ian Hill as they had him much higher on their talent board than where he fell, giving up a second round pick swap and a future 5th round pick to elevate themselves.

- 175cm, 76kgs

Ely Smith (Pick 21 - Mid only 117k)

Will be a popular rookie in peoples starting teams. People will watch with eagerness in the JLT to see if he can grab a starting berth in a now stacked midfield.

- 187cm, 86kgs (AFL ready)

- Finished first in the standing jump and high on the single jump on either foot tests

- Also scored highly in the kicking test so is considered accurate by foot

- Played 17 games for Murrray Bushrangers polling votes in 16 of them

- Won the BnF by 5 votes

- 5th in the Morrish Medal (Tac Cup)

- Tac cup team of the year


Noah Answerth (Pick 55 Def-Mid 117k)

Really good value pick here at the Lions with Noah Answerth. A year older than most as he missed the draft in 2017 with a fracture in his back. Came back to captain the Oakleigh Chargers to a Grand Final this year. Can play all over the park but with his kicking skills is considered a great rebounding defender. Has an AFL frame but is a little short to be the prototype defender these days.

- Height may be an issue as a defender at 182cm, 82kg

- Averaged 19.6 Disposals, 9.1 kicks, 10.5 hbs, 3.1 marks per game, 8.29 CPs, 4.14 tackles but played a variety of positions. He can definitely find the pill.

- Had 27 Disposals and 6 Rebound 50s in the TAC Cup GF
 

WaynesWorld19

Formerly 'Wayne's-World'
Joined
Nov 6, 2003
Posts
57,980
Likes
46,409
Location
Melbourne
AFL Club
Adelaide
Other Teams
West Adelaide
#8
Xavier O'halloran and Ian Hill from GWS look promising, as does Noah Answerth and Ely Smith from the Lions. Ely the most likely to get a round 1 berth depending on JLT form. Throw these onto your watch list. My write up on these guys;


Xavier O’Halloran (Pick 22 Mid only 117k)

Great size and speed give Xavier an all-round package that is hard to pass up. Similar in style to Jordan De Goey he is AFL ready in size and has great marking power and has X factor at stoppages. Also has great leadership qualities both captaining the Western Jets and Vic Country at the Under 18 champs.

- 187cm, 83kg (AFL Ready)

- 5th in the Yo-Yo test at the national combine

- 9 goals in 13 games in the TAC Cup

- Averaged 18.8 Disposals, inc 13.9 kicks and 4.9 handballs, great kick to handball ratio

- Averaged 4.7 tackles, 3.3 marks, 5.5 clearances and 9.2 CP’s

Ian Hill (Pick 24, Mid-Fwd 117k)

Ian Hill is Stephen and Brad Hill’s cousin. And plays quite similarly to the pair, pacey small forward or outside midfielder with legs to burn. Has a high vertical leap also and could yet become a highlight reel player. The giants live traded up 4 spots to grab Ian Hill as they had him much higher on their talent board than where he fell, giving up a second round pick swap and a future 5th round pick to elevate themselves.

- 175cm, 76kgs

Ely Smith (Pick 21 - Mid only 117k)

Will be a popular rookie in peoples starting teams. People will watch with eagerness in the JLT to see if he can grab a starting berth in a now stacked midfield.

- 187cm, 86kgs (AFL ready)

- Finished first in the standing jump and high on the single jump on either foot tests

- Also scored highly in the kicking test so is considered accurate by foot

- Played 17 games for Murrray Bushrangers polling votes in 16 of them

- Won the BnF by 5 votes

- 5th in the Morrish Medal (Tac Cup)

- Tac cup team of the year


Noah Answerth (Pick 55 Def-Mid 117k)

Really good value pick here at the Lions with Noah Answerth. A year older than most as he missed the draft in 2017 with a fracture in his back. Came back to captain the Oakleigh Chargers to a Grand Final this year. Can play all over the park but with his kicking skills is considered a great rebounding defender. Has an AFL frame but is a little short to be the prototype defender these days.

- Height may be an issue as a defender at 182cm, 82kg

- Averaged 19.6 Disposals, 9.1 kicks, 10.5 hbs, 3.1 marks per game, 8.29 CPs, 4.14 tackles but played a variety of positions. He can definitely find the pill.

- Had 27 Disposals and 6 Rebound 50s in the TAC Cup GF
The two knocks on Hill are a) he's terribly thin, but highly skilled b) he didn't develop that much this year ......overall I think there's more chance some of last years draft crop will get a spot in the GWS side this year .....although Ely Smith looks a real likely type
 

cfx_1

Club Legend
Joined
Feb 7, 2010
Posts
1,253
Likes
180
Location
New Farm
AFL Club
Collingwood
#9
The two knocks on Hill are a) he's terribly thin, but highly skilled b) he didn't develop that much this year ......overall I think there's more chance some of last years draft crop will get a spot in the GWS side this year .....although Ely Smith looks a real likely type
Yeah i agree whole heartedly, but there are some AFL players that just are thin, and use their evasiveness and skills, such as his cousins. Brad Hill is 6cm taller but only 2kgs heavier. Stephen is 7cm taller and 5kgs heavier. If he has a good preseason he could easily gain 2kgs and with Shiel and Scully gone they will lack outside pace. There is a spot for grabs. Who grabs it is anyones guess. :)
 

cfx_1

Club Legend
Joined
Feb 7, 2010
Posts
1,253
Likes
180
Location
New Farm
AFL Club
Collingwood
#11
cfx_1 ....from GWS ...Rookie prospects

Isaac Cumming ...$173K
Aiden Bonar ........$249K
Jye Caldwell ........$162K
Jye Caldwell i'm very interested in. Only played 3 games the entire last season due to injury but is rated very highly. Is 184cm and 74kgs so probably needs to hit the weights room. I would be super impressed if he got an early gig but he will be a star.

Like Bonar alot, and Cumming not at all. Was very disappointing in his games last year and surprised with the amount of injuries in defence GWS had that he didn't get more AFL game time.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

WaynesWorld19

Formerly 'Wayne's-World'
Joined
Nov 6, 2003
Posts
57,980
Likes
46,409
Location
Melbourne
AFL Club
Adelaide
Other Teams
West Adelaide
#12
Jye Caldwell i'm very interested in. Only played 3 games the entire last season due to injury but is rated very highly. Is 184cm and 74kgs so probably needs to hit the weights room. I would be super impressed if he got an early gig but he will be a star.

Like Bonar alot, and Cumming not at all. Was very disappointing in his games last year and surprised with the amount of injuries in defence GWS had that he didn't get more AFL game time.
You'd think Bonar will get a good go this year .....but Caldwell, I agree is a star
 

Changa10

Club Legend
Joined
Feb 10, 2008
Posts
2,849
Likes
2,380
Location
Hobart
AFL Club
Hawthorn
Other Teams
DCowboys, ManU, Celtics, Blackhawks
#13
Jye Caldwell i'm very interested in. Only played 3 games the entire last season due to injury but is rated very highly. Is 184cm and 74kgs so probably needs to hit the weights room. I would be super impressed if he got an early gig but he will be a star.

Like Bonar alot, and Cumming not at all. Was very disappointing in his games last year and surprised with the amount of injuries in defence GWS had that he didn't get more AFL game time.
Interesting that you like a Bonar but no Cumming :$
 

Hai_Newman

Norm Smith Medallist
Joined
Oct 17, 2017
Posts
6,516
Likes
22,036
Location
Puppies are scary.
AFL Club
West Coast
#15
The two knocks on Hill are a) he's terribly thin, but highly skilled b) he didn't develop that much this year ......overall I think there's more chance some of last years draft crop will get a spot in the GWS side this year .....although Ely Smith looks a real likely type
Yeap. Hill is going to need 2 x:rooster:'s a day and 3 seasons in the gym.
 

samFFC

Norm Smith Medallist
Joined
Jul 1, 2013
Posts
8,773
Likes
6,229
AFL Club
Fremantle
Other Teams
Fulham, 76ers, Cubs, Bills
#21
Cheap mature agers or expensive top picks?
Doedee, Worpel, Higgins, Fritsch, Murray, Holman, Telly the better options last year than Rayner, Dow, LDU.

Lots of cash savings if you go cheap options and it pays off.
 

turtles

Senior List
Joined
Jun 7, 2014
Posts
168
Likes
499
AFL Club
West Coast
#23
Round 1 2018, 29 players under $200k played:
upload_2018-12-22_17-57-23.png


With a basic 3/3/0/2 on field rookie structure you could have scored 700 points from 8 rookies at an average of 87.5 :fire:.

Or with the same structure you could have also gotten 294 points from 8 rookies at an average of 36.75 :poo:.

406 point difference after just round 1.
 

gutsroy

Brownlow Medallist
Joined
May 12, 2013
Posts
12,664
Likes
17,610
Location
Switzerland
AFL Club
Collingwood
#24
Rookies key. And bye planning makes a difference, so many come a gutser over the bye rds every year, you can launch a attack on the pointy end or salvage something from the wreckage and sneak into the finals if you plan well for them.
Fine work from Turtles, there, that’s got spreadsheet written all over it and makes a salient point to boot.
 

bananatigz

Premiership Player
Joined
Apr 26, 2012
Posts
4,912
Likes
12,586
AFL Club
Richmond
Other Teams
Liverpool
#25
Atm haven’t gone super cheap with rookies, easier to downgrade rookies once it all becomes clear then having to find funds to upgrade them. These guys are also my best bet who could line up round 1 at this stage.

D: Collins, Clark (McKay, Burgess)
M: Smith, Setterfield, Bewley (Constable, Hind, Gibbons*)
R: (Fort)
F: McAdams, Cavarra (Corbett, Parker)
 
Top Bottom