2019 Rookies

[Seymour Skinner]

What’s the word on Wilkie? Is he any good? I just flicked him for Baby John D8 but I could easily be persuaded to switch again

A bloke on SCS had a glowing review of him and it sold me.
Killed the WAFL last year, BnF in a flag winning side.

 

[Papa Caz]

A bloke on SCS had a glowing review of him and it sold me.
Killed the WAFL last year, BnF in a flag winning side.

Think he is a better option then burgess? Been looking at him all day had a few people say he will take Robertons spot in the side

 

[Kadog]

A bloke on SCS had a glowing review of him and it sold me.
Killed the WAFL last year, BnF in a flag winning side.

SOLD!

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

A bloke on SCS had a glowing review of him and it sold me.
Killed the WAFL last year, BnF in a flag winning side.

SANFL campaigner
NORTH ADELAIDE campaigner

 

[Tulendeena]

So really the question is Collins vs McKay/Wilkie for D5/8

 

[SHAKESPEARE]

So really the question is Collins vs McKay/Wilkie for D5/8

Collins

 

[Kadog]

Who to start at M8. KentStable or Scott?

 

[DaTBird187]

The rest of the rookies should save anyone from having to pick either.

 

[Judd_Magic]

Who to start at M8. KentStable or Scott?

I'm debating this one myself.

Probably KentStable.

 

[majortinkle]

Think he is a better option then burgess? Been looking at him all day had a few people say he will take Robertons spot in the side

He is a natural replacement for Robbo.

The only issue he may have is if Battle struggles at CHB. If he does, Joyce may stay in and join Brown as the key position pairing and Battle would get Wilkies spot next week.

 

[JRyan23]

Leave one out: Hore, Duursma, Drew, Constable, Atkins, Wilkie, Petrucelle, Parker,

 

[balmainforever]

Leave one out: Hore, Duursma, Drew, Constable, Atkins, Wilkie, Petrucelle, Parker,

petrol jelly or hore

 

[Guardian Hawk]

Collins

Why Collins? Obviously has good JS but is high priced and with Thompson's injury, looks like having to play the whole season at FB.

Can't see much cash generation as a result - which is the whole reason to have a rookie in the first place.

Edit: just looked up Wilkie's JLT scores - 26 and 18 - yuk!

 

[Kadog]

Why Collins? Obviously has good JS but is high priced and with Thompson's injury, looks like having to play the whole season at FB.

Can't see much cash generation as a result - which is the whole reason to have a rookie in the first place.

Edit: just looked up Wilkie's JLT scores - 26 and 18 - yuk!

****. That's Balta-esque!

 

[Donald Duck]

I’m sure it’s here somewhere but what was Wagner’s JLT score? I’m starting with 4 rookie mids so I’m scraping the barrel at the moment. Currently Walsh, Butters, Atkins, Scott, Gibbons, Constable + 1 other. Drew + Setterfield in the forward line


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[DEAN0]

Constable or Scott as M8 has stumped me, leaning towards scott as he was apperently very SC friendly and is going against the freo mids who don't bat as deep as Collingwood, though constable has had an extra year in the system and I'd trust he gets more midfield minutes.

Hmm

 

[Guardian Hawk]

I’m sure it’s here somewhere but what was Wagner’s JLT score? I’m starting with 4 rookie mids so I’m scraping the barrel at the moment. Currently Walsh, Butters, Atkins, Scott, Gibbons, Constable + 1 other. Drew + Setterfield in the forward line


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

38 (80% TOG) and DNP

 

[Hai_Newman]

****. That's Balta-esque!

Makes Menaspew look Juddesque.

 

[vast]

Leave one out: Hore, Duursma, Drew, Constable, Atkins, Wilkie, Petrucelle, Parker,

Petrosmelly

 

[vast]

Who to start at M8. KentStable or Scott?

Im going for the pig. So u should prob pick scott lol.

 

[Changa10]

Anyone running with Lewis Pierce at R2/3?

 

[Chism]

Only Rookie loophole available is tonight with Atkins carrying the E Tag!

If he goes big ( Over 90ish ) my roving DPP Spud comes on the field in Sammy Wicks and Butters sits out in the Midfield.

Starting Walsh / Constable and Butters depending what Atkins does in the middle.

 

[mochacinolatte]

Does Wilke have better JS than petroljelly?

 

[Flandersss]

Does Wilke have better JS than petroljelly?

We’re shit so yes

 

[ForeverHardcore]

Reckon Balta will get dropped?

balmainforever Spacedog

Nah balta was stiff

The 3 frees against were all dumb
And played half a game
That wont happen each week
The weather was mild so the ball was slippery and I’ll back him in for 3-4 marks a week
His ruck work wasn’t bad either was convinced he had 10-15 hit outs.

Potential to play key back now too with rance on holiday!