Top option, every player. It lets me make changes but not save. My other team on UF in @Haychh’s league works fineWhen you log on to your team can you see the captaincy options next to every player? Like seen below?
View attachment 1061718
Or does it only show against the current captains? As in this case:
View attachment 1061720
Have you logged in to UF under a different e-mail that relates to other teams you may have?