MVP 2020 Best & Fairest - Thursday 29th October 7.30pm start

Remove this Banner Ad

Log in to remove this ad.

Andre

Brownlow Medallist
Sep 3, 2002
25,287
30,048
Adelaide
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
Finals award really depends on how it was delivered. I have no problem with Ollie being commended for a great finals series, and he honestly deserves recognition for how he's gone about it this year - after the drama and the loss of the co-captaincy he's approached everything with maturity and looks like he is becoming the leader we've always wanted him to be.

The only issue is the mission accomplished type sh*t that certain people have been speaking (to be fair a lot of this comes from outside Port people). We blew an opportunity this year and should be angry and wanting to make amends, not patting ourselves on the back for getting close.
Did they reveal how that was determined? AFL finals should be weighted for voting. Week 1 - votes given, Week 2 - votes given x 2, Prelims - votes given x 4, GF - votes given x 8. The more important the final, the more it should count.
 

RussellEbertHandball

Flick pass expert
Nov 16, 2004
63,225
91,738
SE Oz
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
Other Teams
The Mighty Blacks
Couldn't find a page on the club's website re voting per game so scanned Friday's paper with the results.

Maximum votes per game = 20. Highest votes

18 Dixon v WCE Rd 4
17 Boak + Wines v Rich Rd 11
16 DBJ v Adel Rd 2
16 Butters v WB Rd 10
16 Rockliff v Coll Rd 18

All played well type games

Rd 2 v Adel- 21 players got votes, Jonas didn't poll a vote.
Rd 3 v Freo - 20 players got votes, Jonas and Motlop didn't poll a vote.
Rd 4 v WCE - 22 players got votes
Rd 9 v Melb- 21 players got votes, Ebert didn't poll a vote.
Rd 17 V Ess - 21 players got votes, Farrell didn't poll a vote.
QF v Geelong - 22 players got votes

Rd 11 v Rich - 19 players got votes, Duursma, Farrell, and Georgiades didn't poll a vote



1604232993078.png

1604233026742.png
 

Daylight2nd

Debutant
Mar 6, 2011
87
126
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
Couldn't find a page on the club's website re voting per game so scanned Friday's paper with the results.

Maximum votes per game = 20. Highest votes

18 Dixon v WCE Rd 4
17 Boak + Wines v Rich Rd 11
16 DBJ v Adel Rd 2
16 Butters v WB Rd 10
16 Rockliff v Coll Rd 18

All played well type games

Rd 2 v Adel- 21 players got votes, Jonas didn't poll a vote.
Rd 3 v Freo - 20 players got votes, Jonas and Motlop didn't poll a vote.
Rd 4 v WCE - 22 players got votes
Rd 9 v Melb- 21 players got votes, Ebert didn't poll a vote.
Rd 17 V Ess - 21 players got votes, Farrell didn't poll a vote.
QF v Geelong - 22 players got votes

Rd 11 v Rich - 19 players got votes, Duursma, Farrell, and Georgiades didn't poll a vote



View attachment 1000835
View attachment 1000836
For those interested I did a quick manual count of totals for players placed 15th and lower.
15th Ebert - 73 votes (played 14 games),
16th Clurey - 71 (18 games)
17th Duursma - 61 (15)
18th Motlop - 54 (14)
19th Rozee - 52 (16)
20th Marshall - 50 (14)
21st Burton - 46 (8)
22nd Ladhams - 42 (10)
23rd Westhoff - 31 (12)
24th Farrell - 23 (11)
25th Lienert - 21 (5)
26th Mayes - 19 (6)
27th Bonner - 17 (9)
28th Woodcock - 11 (5)
29th Georgiades - 10 (7)
30th Sutcliffe - 1 (4)

Might not be 100% accurate, but you get the general idea of the coach's rating of each players season.
 
Last edited:

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Enviable Tradition

Professional Procrastinator
Oct 12, 2007
20,084
25,413
The Hills
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
For those interested I did a quick manual count of totals for players placed 15th and lower.
15th Ebert - 73 votes (played 14 games),
16th Clurey - 71 (18 games)
17th Duursma - 61 (15)
18th Motlop - 54 (14)
19th Rozee - 52 (16)
20th Marshall - 50 (14)
21st Burton - 46 (8)
22nd Ladhams - 42 (10)
23rd Westhoff - 31 (12)
24th Farrell - 23 (11)
25th Lienert - 21 (5)
26th Mayes - 19 (6)
27th Bonner - 17 (9)
28th Georgiades - 10 (7)
28th Woodcock - 10 (5)
30th Sutcliffe - 1 (4)

Might not be 100% accurate, but you get the general idea of the coach's rating of each players season.
So Burton>Lienert>Mayes>Bonner.

With Jones and Bergman to come in.

On SM-G960F using BigFooty.com mobile app
 

RussellEbertHandball

Flick pass expert
Nov 16, 2004
63,225
91,738
SE Oz
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
Other Teams
The Mighty Blacks
For those interested I did a quick manual count of totals for players placed 15th and lower.

20th Marshall - 50 (14)

Might not be 100% accurate, but you get the general idea of the coach's rating of each players season.
I counted Marshall had 43 at the end of Rd 8 the St Kilda game, the game he busted his hand in.

8+9+7+4+0+4+8+3 = 43. He returned Rd 14, Rd 15 was a bye, he got 0+bye+2+4+0+1+0 = 7.

At the end of Rd 10, the top 10 was as per the graphic below. Rd 9 and 10 votes
Mckenzie 0+10 = 10 => 56 after rd 8 and didn't play Rd 9
Dixon..... 1+9 = 10 => 54 after rd 8
Boak..... 10+0 = 10 => 53 after rd 8
Houston 10+8 = 18 => 36 after rd 8
Amon.... 13+6 =19 => 35 after rd 8
Hartlett.. 4+8 = 12 => 41 after rd 8
Clurey.. 4+10 = 14 => 33 after rd 8

So Marshall was 7th after Rd 8. Indicates his busted thumb was a lot bigger issue than we probably realized. Yes he needs to do more, but some of the commentary on here was a bit over the top and his first 7 full games and even in the 8th one playing with his broken thumb strapped up shows how well the coaches thought he was going.



1604304086899.png
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Top Bottom