2020 Non-Crows AFL Discussion

[GreyCrow]

I seem to remember Shiel was hit in the head twice in that prelim I thought it was Cotchin both times. Maybe in the same contest.

You were mistaken

Otherwise he would have been suspended

 

[Simmo28]

This is clear corruption

Did Wilson write anything criticising her club in the same way she went at the crows for our training breach?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[Drugs Are Bad Mackay?]

You look at Jones here and it's not exactly a Rowell - a mature kid ready to have an immediate impact. It's a skinny young kid who will take a few years to develop

 

[kirky]

There will be a Camp story this week to deflect.....

Sent from my SM-G965F using Tapatalk

Didn’t you hear her last week? Caro was inferring there is a class action regarding the camp in the winds however some of the players (even some still playing at the AFC) don’t want to commence until their playing carriers are over. Eddie is not one of those involved in the class.

What I don’t get is if you are still an AFC player and getting paid now by the AFC, how in gods name could you be part of a class action and yet still take the $$$ from that very club. If you want to be part of a class action, you should not be playing now for the AFC.

 

[kirky]

I wouldnt be surprised if they have kept some info as backup for special occasions in case a Vic team may appear to be in the media spotlight for all the wrong reasons.

Do you really believe this is the end of the Camp? Im sure more will come out, real or not, it wont matter.

Im just waiting for the day the Crows are linked to the Coronavirus.

Shouldn’t it be Port after all they are the ones with links to Chinah.

 

[kirky]

Did Wilson write anything criticising her club in the same way she went at the crows for our training breach?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Yes but listening to all the commentators we were gaining a competitive advantage.

Now you look back and say - really, that whole 8 minutes!

 

[MarcusP2]

Yes but listening to all the commentators we were gaining a competitive advantage.

Now you look back and say - really, that whole 8 minutes!

Imagine how terrible we would have been without it.

 

[Geoffa32]

Didn’t you hear her last week? Caro was inferring there is a class action regarding the camp in the winds however some of the players (even some still playing at the AFC) don’t want to commence until their playing carriers are over. Eddie is not one of those involved in the class.

What I don’t get is if you are still an AFC player and getting paid now by the AFC, how in gods name could you be part of a class action and yet still take the $$$ from that very club. If you want to be part of a class action, you should not be playing now for the AFC.

Class Action.

A legal term to tantalise the great unwashed.



Sent from my SM-G965F using Tapatalk

 

[GROTTO]

You look at Jones here and it's not exactly a Rowell - a mature kid ready to have an immediate impact. It's a skinny young kid who will take a few years to develop

View attachment 926118

Definitely bigger than this kid, who probably wont be able develop.

 

[DJ75]

Didn’t you hear her last week? Caro was inferring there is a class action regarding the camp in the winds however some of the players (even some still playing at the AFC) don’t want to commence until their playing carriers are over. Eddie is not one of those involved in the class.

What I don’t get is if you are still an AFC player and getting paid now by the AFC, how in gods name could you be part of a class action and yet still take the $$$ from that very club. If you want to be part of a class action, you should not be playing now for the AFC.

Going to be hard to justify the damage done etc... when you are still at the same club, still getting paid and still playing AFL.

 

[MarcusP2]

Definitely bigger than this kid, who probably wont be able develop.

Looks like a project player worth throwing somewhere in the 40s at in case he doesn't pan out, probably not a top 10.

 

[phill5158]

This post is for when new posters 10 years from now are asking the same question.

It didnt help that GrommoT and myself were trolling them regularly throughout 2019. But seriously they need to build a bridge and get over it, its 2020 FFS.

Time to move on.

Yeah agreed, it just makes them look stupid tbh

 

[radiojake]

Yeah agreed, it just makes them look stupid tbh

Let's be honest - They are champing at the bit to see another club fall to their level of mediocrity (that isn't just Melbourne)

and considering the recent trade history and back and forth between the boards, it's obvious to see why they are reveling in it

 

[marvin]

Yes but listening to all the commentators we were gaining a competitive advantage.

Now you look back and say - really, that whole 8 minutes!

That was exactly the line Jonathan Brown was pushing on the Collingwood Freo game. Buckley and Sanderson made an innocent mistake, which is different because Adelaide deliberately tried to get a competitive advantage in the Barossa...

 

[radiojake]

That was exactly the line Jonathan Brown was pushing on the Collingwood Freo game. Buckley and Sanderson made an innocent mistake, which is different because Adelaide deliberately tried to get a competitive advantage in the Barossa...

did he actually bring up Adelaide?

 

[Geoffa32]

Definitely bigger than this kid, who probably wont be able develop.

Nice coat-hanger body shape. Broad shoulders, big reach and nice height.

Will fill out nicely, may even win a Brownlow or two.





Sent from my SM-G965F using Tapatalk

 

[SaltPeter]

did he actually bring up Adelaide?

Yep

 

[kirky]

That was exactly the line Jonathan Brown was pushing on the Collingwood Freo game. Buckley and Sanderson made an innocent mistake, which is different because Adelaide deliberately tried to get a competitive advantage in the Barossa...

This was the same Jonathan Brown who said when the incident involving the Crows 2 or so months ago, that if they wanted to get a competitive advantage they would have sent their experienced players not the youngsters.

Oh how one forgets what one says.

 

[marvin]

did he actually bring up Adelaide?

Yes, he did in the pre-match

 

[Tex200]

You look at Jones here and it's not exactly a Rowell - a mature kid ready to have an immediate impact. It's a skinny young kid who will take a few years to develop

View attachment 926118

Well he’s had almost 2 since that photo.

 

[Drugs Are Bad Mackay?]

Well he’s had almost 2 since that photo.

Almost two is one!

Jury out no doubt but he was never likely a first couple of seasons impact player

 

[Tex200]

Almost two is one!

Jury out no doubt but he was never likely a first couple of seasons impact player

I thought completely opposite on the basis he was playing Tassie State League football and a bit of a star there from all accounts. As I recall this was used to pump up his tyres a bit too at draft time.

Anyway as you say - jury out

 

[Chase13]

Damo has been quite critical at times of the AFL on the AFL website. Why would they think there was any need to act on this? Did I miss the public outcry of support for Brooke Cotchin? She posted a clear breach of the rules on her Instagram, it doesn’t matter if she deleted it, she voluntarily posted it and therefore is available for anyone to republish. Cleary didn’t break the story either, that was done 48 hours earlier on radio.

I would love to know why they thought this was the story to send a message on, who complained?

 

[footy4ever]

Would this be the most games in a row and TOG he has played in his career.

Tackles is an "effort" stat.


Hence ours is generally low.


Fatigue could be setting in for him.

Edit. He also had the lowest ToG today for both teams.



Sent from my SM-G965F using Tapatalk

Cooked already. Didn't even last one season let alone 4.

 

[footy4ever]

So a journo finally does his job and gets fired

Finally posts the truth and gets fired.