Opinion 2020 Player X v Y v Z

[rocker_oz33]

I think Chad will go high 80's mid 90's soild option.

 

[Smooth Banana]

Hi folks

Brayshaw to Wingard, Simpkin, Viney or Rozee?

 

[Santoz]

Hi folks

Brayshaw to Wingard, Simpkin, Viney or Rozee?

Were any of those players on your radar before the season?

 

[Smooth Banana]

Were any of those players on your radar before the season?

Just Rozee, went brayshaw instead. He will breakout they said

 

[rocker_oz33]

Just Rozee, went brayshaw instead. He will breakout they said

Sprayshaw had a sore foot leading into round one.
I think he will av around 85.

Unsure on the other players you said.

 

[Santoz]

Just Rozee, went brayshaw instead. He will breakout they said

Then get Rozee.

 

[Santoz]

Sprayshaw had a sore foot leading into round one.
I think he will av around 85.

Unsure on the other players you said.

Want more than an 85 average for nearly 400k. He's out for me.

 

[toxic]

Hi folks

Brayshaw to Wingard, Simpkin, Viney or Rozee?

All 4

 

[Red Syrah]

All 4

Am looking at Lynch > Simpkin - is he a 1 round wonder or worth a trade? was thinking of getting the price rise for a couple of weeks at a bare minimum.

 

[Andrew Birch]

Am looking at Lynch > Simpkin - is he a 1 round wonder or worth a trade? was thinking of getting the price rise for a couple of weeks at a bare minimum.

There were huge fluctuations in Simps disposal numbers last year. It's as if he alternated between midfielder accumulator and fwd scrub from week to week and his SC scores reflected that.

 

[toxic]

Am looking at Lynch > Simpkin - is he a 1 round wonder or worth a trade? was thinking of getting the price rise for a couple of weeks at a bare minimum.

Done exactly that myself, Simpkin is the 2020 Worpel

 

[Gene Simmons]

I've got Dunkley & Bont as my M2 & M3...

Is it a waste of trade to go either Dunkley or Bont to Neale?

 

[SELFCONFESDAFLNERD]

I've got Dunkley & Bont as my M2 & M3...

Is it a waste of trade to go either Dunkley or Bont to Neale?

I suspect you will get a couple different answers to this question. There would be a couple schools of thought here. One would be to keep one or both of those 2 as i think people may be slightly underestimating how long the season is within their trading plans. However, devils advocate is that we have 5 trades which is a massive blessing and given prices change after 2 rounds we can afford to be liberal with the use of trades. What i would do in your position is look at the top 5 or more players who you think you need in your team and look at scenarios where you can get all 5 or as many of the 5 as possible.

Personally, for my team i want Naismith, Viney, Noble/Hill/Doedee/Georgiades, Neale/Fyfe/Titch & Rozee/Wingard. Ive separated them into 5 categories from 1-5 in terms of priority. I've decided Naismith and Viney are my top 2 priorities so they are definitely coming in but beyond that, there is uncertainty and a lot depends on teams etc. Guaranteed i cant get all of my 5 priorities but i should be able to get 3 and if lucky, i could get 4.

TL/DR If you dont do the above at least partially in your head then i will give you my short answer, which is to hold both. However, i dont mind the idea of trading 1 of them. Trading both could come off but i think it is too short-sighted. Good luck with whatever you decide to do!

 

[Gene Simmons]

I suspect you will get a couple different answers to this question. There would be a couple schools of thought here. One would be to keep one or both of those 2 as i think people may be slightly underestimating how long the season is within their trading plans. However, devils advocate is that we have 5 trades which is a massive blessing and given prices change after 2 rounds we can afford to be liberal with the use of trades. What i would do in your position is look at the top 5 or more players who you think you need in your team and look at scenarios where you can get all 5 or as many of the 5 as possible.

Personally, for my team i want Naismith, Viney, Noble/Hill/Doedee/Georgiades, Neale/Fyfe/Titch & Rozee/Wingard. Ive separated them into 5 categories from 1-5 in terms of priority. I've decided Naismith and Viney are my top 2 priorities so they are definitely coming in but beyond that, there is uncertainty and a lot depends on teams etc. Guaranteed i cant get all of my 5 priorities but i should be able to get 3 and if lucky, i could get 4.

TL/DR If you dont do the above at least partially in your head then i will give you my short answer, which is to hold both. However, i dont mind the idea of trading 1 of them. Trading both could come off but i think it is too short-sighted. Good luck with whatever you decide to do!

Thanks for your insight!

I'm more inclined to go Bont -> Neale now, only $35k difference. I believe after Round 3, there'll be a $100k difference in price.

 

[Hai_Newman]

I've got Dunkley & Bont as my M2 & M3...

Is it a waste of trade to go either Dunkley or Bont to Neale?

If Neale can load up, like the little piglet he was last year early, which I suspect he can I'd get on!!

 

[DaveyBoy123]

Ceglar & Brand/Cumming/S.Hill

vs

Fort & Crozier/Milera/H.Clark

 

[Obese Arachnid]

View attachment 887373

Is someone orf their nut in the wrong fred?

 

[Dazza the Viking]

Zurk-Thatcher
VS
McAsey

Got both, trading Mcasey out this week, Zerk-Thatcher on the chopping block

 

[Prince Barry]

Is someone orf their nut in the wrong fred?

Sorry I was on wrong thread deleted!

 

[Prince Barry]

Got both, trading Mcasey out this week, Zerk-Thatcher on the chopping block

Depends on selection but Zerk-Thatcher looks on the outer.

 

[Prince Barry]

Forward cash cows.
Darcy Fort $262,000 / Ben Long $283,000/ Brett Bewley $252,000/ Jacob Townsend $222,000?
Which one? I'm a little worried on Fort's job security but he's the frontrunner

 

[Andrew Birch]

Forward cash cows.
Darcy Fort $262,000 / Ben Long $283,000/ Brett Bewley $252,000/ Jacob Townsend $222,000?
Which one? I'm a little worried on Fort's job security but he's the frontrunner

Ben Long most likely to have a breakout season from that lot if he plays HB all year.

I've got Fort, but have very little confidence in his JS.

Bewley & Townsend = Traps

 

[SC fish]

Forward cash cows.
Darcy Fort $262,000 / Ben Long $283,000/ Brett Bewley $252,000/ Jacob Townsend $222,000?
Which one? I'm a little worried on Fort's job security but he's the frontrunner

Ben Long listed as having a foot injury on the SC site. Anyone got an update on this?

 

[Spacedog]

Forward cash cows.
Darcy Fort $262,000 / Ben Long $283,000/ Brett Bewley $252,000/ Jacob Townsend $222,000?
Which one? I'm a little worried on Fort's job security but he's the frontrunner

If Fort plays the whole year he'll average enough to be a keeper, but as you said his JS is bad. After that I'd go Bewley > Long > Townsend

 

[Andrew Birch]

Ben Long listed as having a foot injury on the SC site. Anyone got an update on this?

Fully recovered.