List Mgmt. 2020 Trade and List Management Thread II

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.
Passmore said:
"Elite ball users who rack up possessions" won't be subject to a change of role due to the return of a good, solid player like Liberatore. Dunkley is a decent player, but not the type that should be attracting a big money bid.
Click to expand...
If you're no longer getting played in the same position where lots of touches are available then how do you expect him to keep his possession numbers?
He had a pretty good 2019.
1603669678382.png
 
Thewlis Dish said:
I think Cameron is overrated, I can just see why there is a perceived difference in value.
Click to expand...

I do too. For all the mocking, I would take Hawkins over Cameron 10 out of 10 times. There is a perceived difference in value because of the media narrative, that's what my point is. I agree that teams won't base their valuations on what Jon f***ing Ralph thinks, but what happens if Melbourne won't pay a fair price, and the media narrative gets out that "North have been offered a late second, that's a fair price, they need to stop being dicks about it"? Like it or not, the media narrative plays a role in how some of this stuff unfolds, and it would be easy for the AFL to come in as mediators and tell North to be more reasonable, everyone agrees he's only worth a late second.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Thewlis Dish said:
Who has said that though?

The media has correctly pointed out that clubs are likely not going to offer us a first rounder for Brown. That's not nasty reporting, that's likely to be fact.
Click to expand...

Ok mate, you can talk down North players as much as you like. Regardless of what Brown is worth today, I think the media has completely undervalued his performances of the past 5 years while making excuses for other non-performing players (Daniher has barely gotten on the park for 3 years but he's clearly a star worth a top 5 pick). We can agree to disagree.
 
Shinboner1 said:
If you're no longer getting played in the same position where lots of touches are available then how do you expect him to keep his possession numbers?
He had a pretty good 2019.
View attachment 995368
Click to expand...

Pretty good is not elite. If he was elite he wouldn't have been shunted aside. Any sensible team wouldn't be throwing big money at a pretty good player.
 
Mr_Nyah said:
Ok mate, you can talk down North players as much as you like. Regardless of what Brown is worth today, I think the media has completely undervalued his performances of the past 5 years while making excuses for other non-performing players (Daniher has barely gotten on the park for 3 years but he's clearly a star worth a top 5 pick). We can agree to disagree.
Click to expand...
To be fair we haven't helped ourselves by spending the whole year actively devaluing him.
 
 
Passmore said:
Pretty good is not elite. If he was elite he wouldn't have been shunted aside. Any sensible team wouldn't be throwing big money at a pretty good player.
Click to expand...

Yeah I tend to think the Dogs would be laughing if they end up with pick 7 for him, although it is complicated somewhat with the JUH bid.
 
Passmore said:
Pretty good is not elite. If he was elite he wouldn't have been shunted aside. Any sensible team wouldn't be throwing big money at a pretty good player.
Click to expand...

His 2019 could probably be rated elite. Had over 30 possessions in half of his games, and polled 15 Brownlow votes.
 
Sentence from a previous written article...

"The Cats won’t want Cameron falling into the pre-season draft as Essendon and Sydney Swans, in theory, could both entertain taking him for nothing"
.

l thought this sentence was interesting regarding Geelong and Cameron. l'm quite sure that North might have a say in it also if Brown goes...and a few other clubs before their picks...
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

From our resident nuffie, Chicken Nixon . I've bolded the main points regarding North

All the latest AFL Trade Scoops from
The Chicken Coop #AllAboard

Shaun McKernan has had huge interest in him with three clubs very keen Melbourne St Kilda North Melbourne

Ben Brown looks set to nominate Melbourne as his preferred destination Melbourne has offered him five year deal on table.

Majak Daw only one club has shown interest in him the last couple days and that is Collingwood.

Jared Polec despite being linked to a two year deal with Melbourne Hawthorn has also shown interest in him talks going around if a deal dose not get done Polec happy to stay at North depending if deal can not get done.

Brandon Matera ex doctor been linked to four clubs Bulldogs Carlton Sydney North Melbourne

Heath Shaw ex giant only one club did show interest in him was North Melbourne

Ben Jacobs delisted by North Melbourne linked two clubs Bulldogs Collingwood

Jasper Pittard ex north delisted player linked to Geelong and Adelaide if they decide to re rookie him.

Jamie Macmillan (delisted), north Melbourne player linked two clubs Richmond Essendon.

Ben Ronke from Sydney been linked two clubs Adelaide North Melbourne

Jack Higgins from Richmond been linked three clubs Bulldogs and North Melbourne and Melbourne.


Geelong now having second thoughts on what to offer Tom Hawkins who is out of contact and coming off another below average finals series and with Jeremy Cameron on the move do they need both ???
Jesse Hogan from Fremantle two clubs showing huge interest in him now Sydney and Brisbane with Sydney offering him three year deal.
Kyle Hartigan after nominating Hawthorn from Adelaide talks two-three year deal.
Alex Witherden from Brisbane been strongly linked to two Victorian clubs already Hawthorn Essendon
Max Lynch young back up Collingwood ruckman has had four clubs showing interest in him now are Richmond Fremantle GWS Adelaide
Josh Thomas from Collingwood linked to two clubs Hawthorn Melbourne
Nathan Broad from Richmond with two clubs showing huge interest in him is Gold Coast and Fremantle.
St Kilda's Jake Carlisle has the Hawks still showing huge interest in him after the Hawks offered him three year deal to try and lure him another old club Essendon showing interest in him again.
Jack Lonie from St Kilda been linked to four clubs Bulldogs Carlton Collingwood Sydney.
Paddy McCartin ex Saint former number one draft pick been linked to three clubs Geelong Essendon Sydney talks going around clubs want him to pass medical tests and fitness tests to prove that he’s good to go.
Dylan Roberton from St Kilda been linked two clubs Adelaide GWS
Aliir Aliir from Sydney been linked to two clubs Port Adelaide GWS.
Tom Hickey from West Coast been linked three clubs Sydney GWS Carlton.
Lachlan Hunter told Bulldogs he wants to stay after all the talk going on around him said he’s not going anywhere.
Delisted players who have interest in them.
Tim Broomhead ex pie been linked to three clubs West Coast Fremantle Adelaide
Cam McCarthy ex docker been linked to the pies in interest in him
Tom McDonald from Melbourne looks set to nominate Essendon with Essendon offered him four years on the table.
Neville Jetta talks going around Collingwood huge interest in him after they offered him two year deal to lure him from Melbourne.
Isaac Smith talks he will nominate a trade to Melbourne from Hawthorn Melbourne has offered him three year deal.
Peter Wright from Gold Coast been linked to three clubs already GWS Collingwood Sydney all showing huge interest in him.
Will Golds ex hawk (delisted), been linked to Fremantle talks Hawthorn may be keen on re rookie him through the draft
Kyle Dunkley brother of Josh delisted Melbourne player has been linked to two clubs Essendon and Bulldogs.
Riley Grundy delisted by Port Adelaide brother of Brodie been linked to Collingwood Melbourne
Hamish Brayshaw ex Eagle linked to Carlton and Melbourne.

And that the Scoops from the Coop .....have a great night
 
giantroo said:
From our resident nuffie, Chicken Nixon . I've bolded the main points regarding North

All the latest AFL Trade Scoops from
The Chicken Coop #AllAboard

Shaun McKernan has had huge interest in him with three clubs very keen Melbourne St Kilda North Melbourne

Ben Brown looks set to nominate Melbourne as his preferred destination Melbourne has offered him five year deal on table.

Majak Daw only one club has shown interest in him the last couple days and that is Collingwood.

Jared Polec despite being linked to a two year deal with Melbourne Hawthorn has also shown interest in him talks going around if a deal dose not get done Polec happy to stay at North depending if deal can not get done.

Brandon Matera ex doctor been linked to four clubs Bulldogs Carlton Sydney North Melbourne

Heath Shaw ex giant only one club did show interest in him was North Melbourne

Ben Jacobs delisted by North Melbourne linked two clubs Bulldogs Collingwood

Jasper Pittard ex north delisted player linked to Geelong and Adelaide if they decide to re rookie him.

Jamie Macmillan (delisted), north Melbourne player linked two clubs Richmond Essendon.

Ben Ronke from Sydney been linked two clubs Adelaide North Melbourne

Jack Higgins from Richmond been linked three clubs Bulldogs and North Melbourne and Melbourne.


Geelong now having second thoughts on what to offer Tom Hawkins who is out of contact and coming off another below average finals series and with Jeremy Cameron on the move do they need both ???
Jesse Hogan from Fremantle two clubs showing huge interest in him now Sydney and Brisbane with Sydney offering him three year deal.
Kyle Hartigan after nominating Hawthorn from Adelaide talks two-three year deal.
Alex Witherden from Brisbane been strongly linked to two Victorian clubs already Hawthorn Essendon
Max Lynch young back up Collingwood ruckman has had four clubs showing interest in him now are Richmond Fremantle GWS Adelaide
Josh Thomas from Collingwood linked to two clubs Hawthorn Melbourne
Nathan Broad from Richmond with two clubs showing huge interest in him is Gold Coast and Fremantle.
St Kilda's Jake Carlisle has the Hawks still showing huge interest in him after the Hawks offered him three year deal to try and lure him another old club Essendon showing interest in him again.
Jack Lonie from St Kilda been linked to four clubs Bulldogs Carlton Collingwood Sydney.
Paddy McCartin ex Saint former number one draft pick been linked to three clubs Geelong Essendon Sydney talks going around clubs want him to pass medical tests and fitness tests to prove that he’s good to go.
Dylan Roberton from St Kilda been linked two clubs Adelaide GWS
Aliir Aliir from Sydney been linked to two clubs Port Adelaide GWS.
Tom Hickey from West Coast been linked three clubs Sydney GWS Carlton.
Lachlan Hunter told Bulldogs he wants to stay after all the talk going on around him said he’s not going anywhere.
Delisted players who have interest in them.
Tim Broomhead ex pie been linked to three clubs West Coast Fremantle Adelaide
Cam McCarthy ex docker been linked to the pies in interest in him
Tom McDonald from Melbourne looks set to nominate Essendon with Essendon offered him four years on the table.
Neville Jetta talks going around Collingwood huge interest in him after they offered him two year deal to lure him from Melbourne.
Isaac Smith talks he will nominate a trade to Melbourne from Hawthorn Melbourne has offered him three year deal.
Peter Wright from Gold Coast been linked to three clubs already GWS Collingwood Sydney all showing huge interest in him.
Will Golds ex hawk (delisted), been linked to Fremantle talks Hawthorn may be keen on re rookie him through the draft
Kyle Dunkley brother of Josh delisted Melbourne player has been linked to two clubs Essendon and Bulldogs.
Riley Grundy delisted by Port Adelaide brother of Brodie been linked to Collingwood Melbourne
Hamish Brayshaw ex Eagle linked to Carlton and Melbourne.

And that the Scoops from the Coop .....have a great night
Click to expand...

Ben jacobs? Get ****ed
 
giantroo said:
From our resident nuffie, Chicken Nixon . I've bolded the main points regarding North

All the latest AFL Trade Scoops from
The Chicken Coop #AllAboard

Shaun McKernan has had huge interest in him with three clubs very keen Melbourne St Kilda North Melbourne

Ben Brown looks set to nominate Melbourne as his preferred destination Melbourne has offered him five year deal on table.

Majak Daw only one club has shown interest in him the last couple days and that is Collingwood.

Jared Polec despite being linked to a two year deal with Melbourne Hawthorn has also shown interest in him talks going around if a deal dose not get done Polec happy to stay at North depending if deal can not get done.

Brandon Matera ex doctor been linked to four clubs Bulldogs Carlton Sydney North Melbourne

Heath Shaw ex giant only one club did show interest in him was North Melbourne

Ben Jacobs delisted by North Melbourne linked two clubs Bulldogs Collingwood

Jasper Pittard ex north delisted player linked to Geelong and Adelaide if they decide to re rookie him.

Jamie Macmillan (delisted), north Melbourne player linked two clubs Richmond Essendon.

Ben Ronke from Sydney been linked two clubs Adelaide North Melbourne

Jack Higgins from Richmond been linked three clubs Bulldogs and North Melbourne and Melbourne.


Geelong now having second thoughts on what to offer Tom Hawkins who is out of contact and coming off another below average finals series and with Jeremy Cameron on the move do they need both ???
Jesse Hogan from Fremantle two clubs showing huge interest in him now Sydney and Brisbane with Sydney offering him three year deal.
Kyle Hartigan after nominating Hawthorn from Adelaide talks two-three year deal.
Alex Witherden from Brisbane been strongly linked to two Victorian clubs already Hawthorn Essendon
Max Lynch young back up Collingwood ruckman has had four clubs showing interest in him now are Richmond Fremantle GWS Adelaide
Josh Thomas from Collingwood linked to two clubs Hawthorn Melbourne
Nathan Broad from Richmond with two clubs showing huge interest in him is Gold Coast and Fremantle.
St Kilda's Jake Carlisle has the Hawks still showing huge interest in him after the Hawks offered him three year deal to try and lure him another old club Essendon showing interest in him again.
Jack Lonie from St Kilda been linked to four clubs Bulldogs Carlton Collingwood Sydney.
Paddy McCartin ex Saint former number one draft pick been linked to three clubs Geelong Essendon Sydney talks going around clubs want him to pass medical tests and fitness tests to prove that he’s good to go.
Dylan Roberton from St Kilda been linked two clubs Adelaide GWS
Aliir Aliir from Sydney been linked to two clubs Port Adelaide GWS.
Tom Hickey from West Coast been linked three clubs Sydney GWS Carlton.
Lachlan Hunter told Bulldogs he wants to stay after all the talk going on around him said he’s not going anywhere.
Delisted players who have interest in them.
Tim Broomhead ex pie been linked to three clubs West Coast Fremantle Adelaide
Cam McCarthy ex docker been linked to the pies in interest in him
Tom McDonald from Melbourne looks set to nominate Essendon with Essendon offered him four years on the table.
Neville Jetta talks going around Collingwood huge interest in him after they offered him two year deal to lure him from Melbourne.
Isaac Smith talks he will nominate a trade to Melbourne from Hawthorn Melbourne has offered him three year deal.
Peter Wright from Gold Coast been linked to three clubs already GWS Collingwood Sydney all showing huge interest in him.
Will Golds ex hawk (delisted), been linked to Fremantle talks Hawthorn may be keen on re rookie him through the draft
Kyle Dunkley brother of Josh delisted Melbourne player has been linked to two clubs Essendon and Bulldogs.
Riley Grundy delisted by Port Adelaide brother of Brodie been linked to Collingwood Melbourne
Hamish Brayshaw ex Eagle linked to Carlton and Melbourne.

And that the Scoops from the Coop .....have a great night
Click to expand...
* me, talk about "throw enough darts".
 
giantroo said:
From our resident nuffie, Chicken Nixon . I've bolded the main points regarding North

All the latest AFL Trade Scoops from
The Chicken Coop #AllAboard

Shaun McKernan has had huge interest in him with three clubs very keen Melbourne St Kilda North Melbourne

Ben Brown looks set to nominate Melbourne as his preferred destination Melbourne has offered him five year deal on table.

Majak Daw only one club has shown interest in him the last couple days and that is Collingwood.

Jared Polec despite being linked to a two year deal with Melbourne Hawthorn has also shown interest in him talks going around if a deal dose not get done Polec happy to stay at North depending if deal can not get done.

Brandon Matera ex doctor been linked to four clubs Bulldogs Carlton Sydney North Melbourne

Heath Shaw ex giant only one club did show interest in him was North Melbourne

Ben Jacobs delisted by North Melbourne linked two clubs Bulldogs Collingwood

Jasper Pittard ex north delisted player linked to Geelong and Adelaide if they decide to re rookie him.

Jamie Macmillan (delisted), north Melbourne player linked two clubs Richmond Essendon.

Ben Ronke from Sydney been linked two clubs Adelaide North Melbourne

Jack Higgins from Richmond been linked three clubs Bulldogs and North Melbourne and Melbourne.


Geelong now having second thoughts on what to offer Tom Hawkins who is out of contact and coming off another below average finals series and with Jeremy Cameron on the move do they need both ???
Jesse Hogan from Fremantle two clubs showing huge interest in him now Sydney and Brisbane with Sydney offering him three year deal.
Kyle Hartigan after nominating Hawthorn from Adelaide talks two-three year deal.
Alex Witherden from Brisbane been strongly linked to two Victorian clubs already Hawthorn Essendon
Max Lynch young back up Collingwood ruckman has had four clubs showing interest in him now are Richmond Fremantle GWS Adelaide
Josh Thomas from Collingwood linked to two clubs Hawthorn Melbourne
Nathan Broad from Richmond with two clubs showing huge interest in him is Gold Coast and Fremantle.
St Kilda's Jake Carlisle has the Hawks still showing huge interest in him after the Hawks offered him three year deal to try and lure him another old club Essendon showing interest in him again.
Jack Lonie from St Kilda been linked to four clubs Bulldogs Carlton Collingwood Sydney.
Paddy McCartin ex Saint former number one draft pick been linked to three clubs Geelong Essendon Sydney talks going around clubs want him to pass medical tests and fitness tests to prove that he’s good to go.
Dylan Roberton from St Kilda been linked two clubs Adelaide GWS
Aliir Aliir from Sydney been linked to two clubs Port Adelaide GWS.
Tom Hickey from West Coast been linked three clubs Sydney GWS Carlton.
Lachlan Hunter told Bulldogs he wants to stay after all the talk going on around him said he’s not going anywhere.
Delisted players who have interest in them.
Tim Broomhead ex pie been linked to three clubs West Coast Fremantle Adelaide
Cam McCarthy ex docker been linked to the pies in interest in him
Tom McDonald from Melbourne looks set to nominate Essendon with Essendon offered him four years on the table.
Neville Jetta talks going around Collingwood huge interest in him after they offered him two year deal to lure him from Melbourne.
Isaac Smith talks he will nominate a trade to Melbourne from Hawthorn Melbourne has offered him three year deal.
Peter Wright from Gold Coast been linked to three clubs already GWS Collingwood Sydney all showing huge interest in him.
Will Golds ex hawk (delisted), been linked to Fremantle talks Hawthorn may be keen on re rookie him through the draft
Kyle Dunkley brother of Josh delisted Melbourne player has been linked to two clubs Essendon and Bulldogs.
Riley Grundy delisted by Port Adelaide brother of Brodie been linked to Collingwood Melbourne
Hamish Brayshaw ex Eagle linked to Carlton and Melbourne.

And that the Scoops from the Coop .....have a great night
Click to expand...
Brown for 5 years ..........Well done Rama... 😂
 
giantroo said:
Geelong now having second thoughts on what to offer Tom Hawkins who is out of contact and coming off another below average finals series and with Jeremy Cameron on the move do they need both ???
Click to expand...

rofl
 
benbanjo said:
So in other words we are linked to everyone and all our delisted players are linked to everyone else.
Click to expand...

inline-graphic-1.gif


A visual representation of a Ricky Nixon's trade rumour tweet.

It's 2nd only to Rooboys Rool posts for fictitious complexity.
 
Gallagher didn’t want to be drawn into the specifics over the length and financial figure for Crouch, but confirmed Shaun McKernan was a player of interest for the Saints.

“It is more one that we were so impressed in Kingy in basically his first year of AFL. We see a big future for Max and we love having him at our footy club,” he said.

“But I reckon we are a little bit exposed if we get the wrong injury in the wrong spot, that’s not just Max. Our team worked well when we had the two tall forwards and Membrey.

“We don’t want to be compromised with our structure if we get the wrong injury in the wrong position.

“It’s not an area of the ground that we will throw a lot of assets and money at. We think we’ve got our number one forward, but we just need some more support if we get the wrong injury in the wrong position.

“He (McKernan) is one of a few. He has finished up at Essendon. There’s a few marking forward types who are out of contract or finishing up at their current clubs and we have made number of calls to their management, but he‘s one.

As for Ben Brown, Gallagher said “I’m not going to rule anyone in or out, it’s early days. We’ve got a guy in Max King that we think is going to be our No.1 key forward and we will make sure that is the case and he gets the support and development that we hope he becomes.”
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads

giantroo
List Mgmt. 2023 Trade & List Management Thread III
139 140 141 142 143
Replies
4K
Views
203K
The Nostradamus
The Nostradamus
giantroo
List Mgmt. 2024 Trade & List Management Thread
74 75 76 77 78
Replies
2K
Views
106K
King Hansen
King Hansen
scottywiper
List management 101 (69?)
7 8 9 10 11
Replies
253
Views
9K
ohmygewd
O
Blightys Barrel
List Mgmt. 17 decisions required by EOY for the list management team
Replies
7
Views
411
Flawed Genius
Flawed Genius
giantroo
  • Locked
List Mgmt. 2023 Trade & List Management Thread II - Goldy&Bucket➡️✅/'24 EoFR & #44➡️Stephens&#25✅/#21&#25➡️Fisher&#17✅/'24 EoFR➡️#18✅
397 398 399 400 401
Replies
10K
Views
535K
Psicosis
Psicosis
giantroo
  • Locked
List Mgmt. 2023 Trade & List Management Thread
396 397 398 399 400
Replies
10K
Views
537K
Groucho
Groucho
Arthur Cloke
If you were list manager…
2 3
Replies
70
Views
3K
kool kangas
kool kangas

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top