List Mgmt. 2020 Trade and List Management Thread III

Mar 25, 2002
11,313
12,210
37° 70' 12"
AFL Club
North Melbourne
Carlton fan suggesting a Jack Silvagni and a future second rounder for Jed

NOW AS YOU KNOW I am possibly the North boards ONLY Silvagni fan, but I don't like the deal, readers

FTFY

:)
 

billnats

All Australian
Feb 4, 2012
747
2,307
AFL Club
North Melbourne
Other Teams
SMFC & Tottenham
Threeway deal:
Geelong: Higgins
Pies: 51
Us: Stephenson, 30

Assuming we take Stephensons full salary and I'd be sold.
We may need to tip in a late pick to sell the dream.
Don’t think Pies go for that. I actually think the Dees should negotiate with the Pies what pick gets Stephenson to us. Either one of their 31, 33 or late 40’s. It’s in their best interest to haggle.

So our outcome would be:
IN: 26, 30 and Stephenson
OUT: Higgins, Brown and whatever pick Dees pass on to Pies for us
 
Carlton fan suggesting a Jack Silvagni and a future second rounder for Jed

NOW AS YOU KNOW I am possibly the North boards BIGGEST Silvagni fan, but I don't like the deal, readers
Wait, he has fans?
 

Shinboner1

Norm Smith Medallist
Aug 13, 2020
8,899
16,804
AFL Club
North Melbourne
Alir is a decent player when he doesn't have to be the focus of the backline.
 

Shinboner1

Norm Smith Medallist
Aug 13, 2020
8,899
16,804
AFL Club
North Melbourne
Geelong getting a few early 2nd round picks to make the Cameron deal happen.
Wouldn't assume that 30 would be a set use for Higgins.
 

samoodan

Cancelled
Nov 4, 2020
254
320
AFL Club
North Melbourne
It's hard to place a true indicative value as we don't publicly, or truly, know why he's even contemplating leaving. We can guess of course. It will be like the Brown deal I suspect in the sense that the player is normally worth more, but extenuating circumstances have driven down the trade value.

And if the Pies have to salary dump, why would they be pushing out one of their most promising youngsters and rising star winner? There has to be something else going on there.
 

FlyHigh18

Arden St Parking Inspector
May 8, 2017
2,555
6,758
AFL Club
North Melbourne
A bit of fun with a Sliding Doors moment:

Round 17 GWS vs Melbourne - GWS up by 2 goals in third quarter. GoDees flip that in the fourth.
A frenzy in the final 2 mins.
GWS kicks a goal to get within 5 points. North fans cheer.
Less than 30 seconds to go... GWS clear the ball, Whitfield marks ... but delivers a shocking kick forward, gives no chance for Heath, Rivers spoils. Game over.

Fun fact: Had GWS won that game we'd have pick 9 instead of pick 11 (which could go further out)
 
Hypothetically, if we got hold of Picks 7+8 as part of the Dunkley deal, would you guys do

Pick 2 + Pick 28 + future 2nd or 3rd
For
Pick 7 + Pick 8 + Pick 14

Or is McDonald too enticing?
The last sentence is the one....
 
Jul 26, 2007
93,508
161,868
The Tree
AFL Club
North Melbourne
Other Teams
Arsenal, Coney Island Warriors
Hypothetically, if we got hold of Picks 7+8 as part of the Dunkley deal, would you guys do

Pick 2 + Pick 28 + future 2nd or 3rd
For
Pick 7 + Pick 8 + Pick 14

Or is McDonald too enticing?

I think the top 5 is too enticing.
 
Back