List Mgmt. 2020 Trade Thread.....

[King Corey]

Why would Williams leave McGWS?

 

[DesertRoo]

Why would Williams leave McGWS?

Why would McGWS get rid of a rare homegrown.

 

[The Nostradamus]

Why would Williams leave McGWS?

$
same reason a bunch of their players left over the years

 

[King Corey]

$
same reason a bunch of their players left over the years

Shiel and Treloar would've both wanted to come home. They'd have been paid handsomely up there too.

As a NSW product they can fix him up with whatever he likes via some ambassadorial type of garbage.

He's only gettable imo if he actively wants out of the club or Sydney, not sure his head is going to be turned otherwise.

 

[New_Roo]

Shiel and Treloar would've both wanted to come home. They'd have been paid handsomely up there too.

As a NSW product they can fix him up with whatever he likes via some ambassadorial type of garbage.

He's only gettable imo if he actively wants out of the club or Sydney, not sure his head is going to be turned otherwise.

They have a few more to sign up again don't they this year.... finlayson Cameron perryman?


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Ether]

The gaps in our so called "good list" will become evident as the season rolls on. Personally i hope their crap form continues .... until trade period.

Sorry sir, the realism thread is thataway -->

How good was our list looking 1.5 games ago at half time v St Kilda?

 

[Passmore]

Why would Williams leave McGWS?

To come to the "cash cowboys" of course!!!!

It's happening.

Sent from my SM-A908B using Tapatalk

 

[shimaburnsgrieg]

So you wouldnt want either of those two in our side in 21 ??, thats plain crazy.

If they were FA's then I would welcome them with open arms.

If either of them are costing 2 first rounders then forget it.

 

[New_Roo]

Sorry sir, the realism thread is thataway -->

How good was our list looking 1.5 games ago at half time v St Kilda?

The list was still really good against st Kilda just we weren't playing to our capabilities and corrected it accordingly....


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[RobZombie]

So you wouldnt want either of those two in our side in 21 ??, thats plain crazy.

"wouldn't want" vs "worth what it would cost"? Would Kelly or Whitfield on the wing be an upgrade on Dumont? Well, yeah. Enough of an upgrade to spend 2 1sts on? Meh. Kelly & Whitfield have 5 peak years left. Get them as free agents if we want them.

ZWilliams would be ideal, and a bigger upgrade on older players in his role at the cost of no draft picks. We're bugger all chance of getting him unless COVID changes to payments screw everyone's cap space but ours.

 

[Billy Not Really]

I'd be pretty happy if we walked away with Zac Williams in the trade season and that was about it.

We can go to the draft for midfielders, we already have a few coming good quickly.

A quick injection on the HB line might be the only thing we need in any immediate sense.

 

[Ether]

The list was still really good against st Kilda just we weren't playing to our capabilities and corrected it accordingly....


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

You weren't reading the match day thread then.

 

[Pykie]

Shiel and Treloar would've both wanted to come home. They'd have been paid handsomely up there too.

As a NSW product they can fix him up with whatever he likes via some ambassadorial type of garbage.

He's only gettable imo if he actively wants out of the club or Sydney, not sure his head is going to be turned otherwise.

He's not really a "real NSW product" he's from Narrandera, which is a closer drive to Melbourne than it is Sydney.

Also, knowing quite a few blokes from Narrandera and Leeton, kids often play both RL and AFL around there, although AFL is definately more popular.

Most of the kids board in Melbourne, go to uni in Melbourne etc. Relate much more to Melbourne than Sydney.

 

[DesertRoo]

How about Jordan Gallucci from the crows, highly rated athlete, stuck at the crows?
Would be good company for Pittard in Brunswick.

 

[New_Roo]

Sorry sir, the realism thread is thataway -->

How good was our list looking 1.5 games ago at half time v St Kilda?

The list was still really good against st Kilda just we weren't playing to our capabilities and corrected it accordingly....


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[The Nostradamus]

How about Jordan Gallucci from the crows, highly rated athlete, stuck at the crows?
Would be good company for Pittard in Brunswick.

As a delisted free agent?

 

[DesertRoo]

As a delisted free agent?

He’ll be cheap..
Has a lot of pace and skill. Could be someone who fills that Williams role without the price tag.

and the way the crows have been since he was drafted, I wouldn’t take much notice of his form.

 

[GarnerSmash]

He’ll be cheap..
Has a lot of pace and skill. Could be someone who fills that Williams role without the price tag.

and the way the crows have been since he was drafted, I wouldn’t take much notice of his form.

Yeah, dunno. He just hasn't improved at all it seems.

Last year he played 12 SANFL games as a 21 year old and averaged only 15 touches a game. He averaged 16 a game the year before that. Maybe he just doesn't have it. I would give anything up for him.

 

[Passmore]

Yeah, dunno. He just hasn't improved at all it seems.

Last year he played 12 SANFL games as a 21 year old and averaged only 15 touches a game. He averaged 16 a game the year before that. Maybe he just doesn't have it. I would give anything up for him.

Worth a spot on next year's rookie list.

Sent from my SM-A908B using Tapatalk

 

[Snake_Baker]

If they were FA's then I would welcome them with open arms.

If either of them are costing 2 first rounders then forget it.

I reckon we could land the Crouch's for a modest trade & contracts.

 

[roos_fanatic08]

How about Jordan Gallucci from the crows, highly rated athlete, stuck at the crows?
Would be good company for Pittard in Brunswick.

I was keen on him in his draft year. I had the feeling that he could be one of the best from his class.

But he is yet to fire a shot at AFL level, has started pre-season out of shape a number of times.

The work ethic and intensity just isn't there I reckon.

 

[the flying ham]

I was keen on him in his draft year. I had the feeling that he could be one of the best from his class.

But he is yet to fire a shot at AFL level, has started pre-season out of shape a number of times.

The work ethic and intensity just isn't there I reckon.

He wouldn't get a game in front of Taylor or Thomas, which is the role he is currently playing at Adelaide. And not a great kick.

 

[DesertRoo]

I was keen on him in his draft year. I had the feeling that he could be one of the best from his class.

But he is yet to fire a shot at AFL level, has started pre-season out of shape a number of times.

The work ethic and intensity just isn't there I reckon.

Imagine being drafted to the crows the year of the infamous camp, not surprising a lot of the players have fallen away.

He wouldn't get a game in front of Taylor or Thomas, which is the role he is currently playing at Adelaide. And not a great kick.

My idea would be to have him as a running hb, similar to what Williams plays at GWS, I thought his kicking skills were pretty decent when he was a junior.
Doesn’t really matter much, I was just throwing out some names, apart from the usual suspects, who I think would be great value compared to the asking price.

 

[King Corey]

I was keen on him in his draft year. I had the feeling that he could be one of the best from his class.

But he is yet to fire a shot at AFL level, has started pre-season out of shape a number of times.

The work ethic and intensity just isn't there I reckon.

Thought he was another crows ace pick in the vein of Dangerfield, Lever, Bock, Davis et al.

So far he's achieved SFA though.

 

[Rad Roo]

We need a replacement for Higgins, an ollie wines would be very good, of course josh kelly as a FA would be decent and very likely in that by then, GWS would have fallen further as they are not likely to win a flag with an overpaid team that has been scarred from multiple failures.