Player Watch Rory Laird

Remove this Banner Ad

Laird was probably the only fair winner. Top 10 is not too bad, thought Schoenberg would sneak in, but he was pretty unspectacular at times early in the year.

I think you're seeing the (underacknowledged) poor injury management of the club at play with McHenry sneaking in to equal 10th. The top 10 is basically just the only 10 players to play 20 games or more. Minus Schoenberg and plus Walker and Sloane.
 
Interloperer said:
Laird was probably the only fair winner. Top 10 is not too bad, thought Schoenberg would sneak in, but he was pretty unspectacular at times early in the year.

I think you're seeing the (underacknowledged) poor injury management of the club at play with McHenry sneaking in to equal 10th. The top 10 is basically just the only 10 players to play 20 games or more. Minus Schoenberg and plus Walker and Sloane.
Click to expand...

IIRC Schoenberg was 10th before the final round, so he wasn’t too far off
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Today is a day of reflection .....a day to savor, after being lambasted for being visionairies .....and as you know visionairies are often misunderstood and ostrasized for their non-group thinking

Yes Laird won a AA as a DEF ..... but Stiffy_18 and myself were calling for a move to the midfield way back in 2015/16

Laird was better than Brouch when playing at West Adelaide .....a natural ball finder in the Matt Crouch mould

A huge congratulations to lairdy ....and I can see Laird as part of the Crows next premiership, as a Midfielder

Also a huge result for Ned McHenry :whitecheck:.....fantastic fillip for the lads career
 
Last edited:
Golumless said:
We do seem to reward team first actions in the BNF under Nicks. Kelly certainly does this to a good degree.

Just a shame he's a pretty mediocre footballer.
Click to expand...

Nicks brought with him a different voting system. Playing your role is now purely aligned with impact on the game. So a wildly unlikely hypothetical. If Fog's role was to lead to the pocket at every opportunity and he did that to an elite level, then the voting system deems him to have had an elite impact on team performance. Even if not a single lead was honoured. So he gets maximum votes.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Pick4To6 said:
I always thought, when Simon Goodwin was club captain he was boring to listen to, but Rory Sloane is 10 times worse. He can not string a sentence together without stopping.

His speech tonight was massively cringeworthy. I stopped listening as I lost interest in what he was saying. I’m not sure I even believed a single word he said.

Great player, but he should not speak on behalf of the club ever again.
Click to expand...

Did he tell us again that Chappy was the protector and godfather of the footy club? Or has he moved on to other demented ramblings?
 
StonesThrow said:
Excellent year as an inside mid. Underrated on here imo.
Click to expand...

I don't think he is. Apart from Cummings recent rankings, almost all posters rate each of our 3 primary mids quite fairly. 4 including Crouch. The issue is what they become as a group. If you ranked them out of 10 individually they would accumulate say 32 points. But if you ranked a midfield group out of 40, that would be a smaller number. There's only 1 (Keays) that runs hard with the ball but he then reduces that impact with average decision making and inability to hit up targets. So we have 3 inside mids and a hybrid that can only clock efficient disposals by kicking to contests.

Individually they'd get a gig in most other midfields. As a group they suck balls.
 
1970crow said:
Nicks brought with him a different voting system. Playing your role is now purely aligned with impact on the game. So a wildly unlikely hypothetical. If Fog's role was to lead to the pocket at every opportunity and he did that to an elite level, then the voting system deems him to have had an elite impact on team performance. Even if not a single lead was honoured. So he gets maximum votes.
Click to expand...
So you're telling me Charlie Dixon would get 10s if he had zero touch games and just brought it to the ground for the smalls, while might get 7s if he actually clunks a mark and kicks a couple of goals
 
Dirty Bird said:
So you're telling me Charlie Dixon would get 10s if he had zero touch games and just brought it to the ground for the smalls, while might get 7s if he actually clunks a mark and kicks a couple of goals
Click to expand...

Depends the task assigned. But, if his role is to create a target and he does that to an elite level, there's no extra votes for slotting 6 as compared to 0 or executing 10 forward 50 tackles. Our previous system gave 2 for doing your job and then added for further impact on the game, defensively and/or offensively. Now there's pure alignment regardless of game impact. Argument as to right or wrong is up for grabs, that it's vastly different since Nicks' arrival is not. They made a point of it last year.
 
Great win by Rory . Very close in the voting. Three of vote getters in the top 10 surprised me. Smith, Sloane and Kelly mainly on how high the votes were. Seedsman and Keays thoroughly deserved their posits. Anyone know how MacKay polled?
 
1970crow said:
Did he tell us again that Chappy was the protector and godfather of the footy club? Or has he moved on to other demented ramblings?
Click to expand...
Far out… remind me again why you support Adelaide? Because surely there’s not one single thing you like about us.
 
jenny61_99 said:
Far out… remind me again why you support Adelaide? Because surely there’s not one single thing you like about us.
Click to expand...

Chapman hasn't been gone 12 months yet but we already seem like a better club.

Fagan gone, Smart gone, baseball team gone, decent football department appointments, etc.

Liked seeing the AFLW club champions presented with their gold jackets also. It's things like that that add to our authenticity as a club.
 
1970crow said:
Did he tell us again that Chappy was the protector and godfather of the footy club? Or has he moved on to other demented ramblings?
Click to expand...

No idea.

Stopped listening to his speech after he started discussing his 4th idea in about 30 seconds. Just random rambling became cringeworthy.

Great player. Horrible public speaker
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

JPetro83
Should the club tap Tex and Rory on the shoulder now? possible farewell game
2 3
Replies
52
Views
2K
dylan123
dylan123
C
Toast 2022 club champion awards - congrats Rory Laird!
4 5 6 7 8
Replies
195
Views
8K
Interloperer
I
1970crow
Universal Love Congratulations Rory Sloane - 250 games
Replies
14
Views
483
thebirdman 24
T
Vantz
Rory’s Tattoo
Replies
0
Views
2K
Vantz
Vantz

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top