Remove this Banner Ad

Position 2021 Defenders

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Status
Not open for further replies.
Am I the only one considering menadue at D6? I've paid 200k for worse in the DEF before. Yes, I was burned by him "that year" but on the other hand, he has tonned up the same number of times as LUD in his career and North wouldn't have recruited a squaddie in their rebuild stage, would they?
 
Am I the only one considering menadue at D6? I've paid 200k for worse in the DEF before. Yes, I was burned by him "that year" but on the other hand, he has tonned up the same number of times as LUD in his career and North wouldn't have recruited a squaddie in their rebuild stage, would they?

Still having nightmares of just hearing his name. Need more scotch and cokes.

Although I did have the campaigner on the ground that time when he tonned up! 😄
 
Still having nightmares of just hearing his name. Need more scotch and cokes.

Although I did have the campaigner on the ground that time when he tonned up! 😄
Same here
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Am I the only one considering menadue at D6? I've paid 200k for worse in the DEF before. Yes, I was burned by him "that year" but on the other hand, he has tonned up the same number of times as LUD in his career and North wouldn't have recruited a squaddie in their rebuild stage, would they?

 
Am I the only one considering menadue at D6? I've paid 200k for worse in the DEF before. Yes, I was burned by him "that year" but on the other hand, he has tonned up the same number of times as LUD in his career and North wouldn't have recruited a squaddie in their rebuild stage, would they?

Considering he was a VFL-listed player in 2020 and picked up in the rookie draft, he's crazily over-priced IMO. He should be 102k. I'm not sure that he has the job security you might be prepared to pay 200k for.
 
Considering he was a VFL-listed player in 2020 and picked up in the rookie draft, he's crazily over-priced IMO. He should be 102k. I'm not sure that he has the job security you might be prepared to pay 200k for.
If Menadue is a walk up best 22 player for North then they are in an even worse position than I thought.
 
Last edited:
Jordan Dawson looks a decent proposition. His last 7 games saw 4 tons and only one score under 90. Definitely a pre season watch.
 
Jordan Dawson looks a decent proposition. His last 7 games saw 4 tons and only one score under 90. Definitely a pre season watch.
Did the same thing the year before & I got sucked in last year.

Also anyone tempted by Blicavs D/M?
 
Did the same thing the year before & I got sucked in last year.
Took Tracca a few years to break out, impossible to tell without track watchers or inside info.

Billings took me for a ride my anooz will never forget, I'm still experiencing lube issues. :$
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Jordan Dawson looks a decent proposition. His last 7 games saw 4 tons and only one score under 90. Definitely a pre season watch.

Currently tossing up between him and Doedee for D4, both had great runs of form to finish off their years. Favouring Doedee due to his earlier poor scores being due to injury as opposed to Dawson's just being due to poor form, but I wouldn't begrudge anyone picking Dawson.
 
Currently tossing up between him and Doedee for D4, both had great runs of form to finish off their years. Favouring Doedee due to his earlier poor scores being due to injury as opposed to Dawson's just being due to poor form, but I wouldn't begrudge anyone picking Dawson.
Just had a look back at Doedee scores. Yep a good choice. Will play a SuperCoach friendly role.
 
I doubt I'll have the balls to pick him but Jack Scrimshaw is another interesting one. Former top 10 draft pick, priced at 74, average of 86 and only one score under 80 from his last 6 games (which, possibly not coincidentally, is the exact game after James Sicily did his knee).
 
Last edited:

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Any player that does their knee is going to miss a season.

Biggest concern is actually that Doedee is priced bang on his max average.
The Crows traded Kyle Hartigan although not a good player it will be hard to replace a tall back in a hurry and Doedee might have a more defensive role. It would be a big risk starting with a player that has only played 10 games in 2 years with multiple injuries on the back of a couple of 100+ games
 
The Crows traded Kyle Hartigan although not a good player it will be hard to replace a tall back in a hurry and Doedee might have a more defensive role. It would be a big risk starting with a player that has only played 10 games in 2 years with multiple injuries on the back of a couple of 100+ games
The value is just not there this year, if Doedee can put it together though, he may be a top 10 SC defender one day.

He'll need to show some durability first though before I pick him at his current price.
 
The Crows traded Kyle Hartigan although not a good player it will be hard to replace a tall back in a hurry and Doedee might have a more defensive role. It would be a big risk starting with a player that has only played 10 games in 2 years with multiple injuries on the back of a couple of 100+ games

AbandonedShyAdmiralbutterfly-max-1mb.gif
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top