List Mgmt. 2021 draft pool.

[Lore]

 

[Roksman]

You're free to use other people's opinions as your own.

Everyone uses available information to form their own opinion - including yourself. Let's not pretend you watched these kids for the past 3 years.

No need for the condescending grandstand.

 

[_RT_]

Draft should be ran on a forum like a Big Footy Phantom draft. After the first club picks they're required to tag the next team and then that team gets X amount of time to take their pick. If they don't then they get the next highest ranked player on Knightmares list. This means that after each selection supporters could then give them instant feedback.

 

[richoatthedisco]

Everyone uses available information to form their own opinion - including yourself. Let's not pretend you watched these kids for the past 3 years.

No need for the condescending grandstand.

I'm not grandstanding or condescending, I'm reacting to you arguing something using someone else's thoughts.

I haven't watched them for three years, neither have the draft central children.

I know what I look for in a footballer and I know what I see when I look at footballers. I certainly don't use others' opinions as mine.

 

[AstuteTiger]

No Hobbs interestingly

Chesser at 8 enough said.

 

[PMBangers]

I haven't watched them for three years, neither have the draft central children.

 

[Drunken Wookie]

Sinn’s average of 17 touches a game is a bit of a red flag for me. Obviously amount of touches a game isn’t everything, but generally speaking, the kids who struggle to find the ball at underage level only struggle further in the big league

Struggling to find the ball as a HBFer, who are basically given the ball, is an even bigger red flag.

 

[Marcel Proust]

1. ?
2. Diacos.
3. Darcy.
4. ?
5. Andrews (suns)

6. Hobbs (crows)
7. Ward (hawks)
8. Rachele (freo)
9.
10.


(The later) Tigers board draft - if it turns out something like that it'd be hard to overlook a gibcus - balta long term partnership (?)

The like of Sinn. Erasmus. Johnson etc. Look good smaller options too

 

[eDPS]

I mean is he wrong?

 

[PMBangers]

I mean is he wrong?

Yes, I haven't watched them at all let alone for 3 years

 

[tigs2010]

1. ?
2. Diacos.
3. Darcy.
4. ?
5. Andrews (suns)

6. Hobbs (crows)
7. Ward (hawks)
8. Rachele (freo)
9.
10.


Tigers board draft - if it turns out something like that it's be hard to overlook a gibcus - balta long term partnership (?)

The like of Sinn. Erasmus. Johnson etc. Look good smaller options too

Daicos was 1 and Darcy 4 FYI

Gibcus tempting but think I want Johnson

 

[Marcel Proust]

Daicos was 1 and Darcy 4 FYI

Gibcus tempting but think I want Johnson

Johnson at 15 would be kinda cool

 

[Rioli2Rioli]

1. ?
2. Diacos.
3. Darcy.
4. ?
5. Andrews (suns)

6. Hobbs (crows)
7. Ward (hawks)
8. Rachele (freo)
9.
10.


(The later) Tigers board draft - if it turns out something like that it'd be hard to overlook a gibcus - balta long term partnership (?)

The like of Sinn. Erasmus. Johnson etc. Look good smaller options too

With another 4 selections remaining , Overlooking Gibcus/Andrew would be crazy

 

[Marcel Proust]

With another 4 selections remaining , Overlooking Gibcus/Andrew would be crazy

I forgot Andrew that would be the most fun pick and the most complaining here.

I reckon I would still take Andrew. Could be the ideal jack replacement ..



Like you have said pick 15 looks interesting if the tigers hold it. Should get somehow that's got some upside

 

[richoatthedisco]

Yes, I haven't watched them at all let alone for 3 years

You sure didn't watch them last year.

Apologies for the children crack, that was a bit cheap. Everyone's a child to me, I'm 100.

You blokes do a good job, certainly better than say Knightmare. It's an opinion business. I just looked at your rankings - you have Taylor and JVR about where I have them, although I'm not sure why your phantom has us taking Taylor at 17 when you rank him at 30? I don't rate Knevitt or Motlop and think you've got Rachele ridiculously low at 20. But hey, it's an opinion business. Good on you guys for having a crack, the draft guide looks great.

 

[Rioli2Rioli]

I forgot Andrew that would be the most fun pick and the most complaining here

LOl Well i took him for Richmond in 'My' Phantom


And i would do that again , I dont see him as just a ruck or a KP player

Think Bigger , Faster and more agile - Adam Goodes type player in 5 years time

 

[Marcel Proust]

With another 4 selections remaining , Overlooking Gibcus/Andrew would be crazy

Hang on Andrews went at 5 so he wouldn't be an option

 

[PMBangers]

I'm not sure why your phantom has us taking Taylor at 17 when you rank him at 30?

Something in that hey

What I'm tryna say is I heard interest, and doing my phantom so far out from the actual draft just went with it

 

[Roksman]

I'm not grandstanding or condescending, I'm reacting to you arguing something using someone else's thoughts.

I haven't watched them for three years, neither have the draft central children.

I know what I look for in a footballer and I know what I see when I look at footballers. I certainly don't use others' opinions as mine.

Well, you're watching a 2 minute highlights clip, if you think that tells you the whole story of a players ability then all power to you.

Either way we'll all be hindsight heroes such as the nature in this Bigfooty caper. End of the day the recruiters have more data than anyone so I'll back their judgement.

I still remember everyone freaked when we chose "another small" with Baker in the rookie draft... The rest is history.

Hurry up Wednesday.

 

[Roksman]

Love you work, keep it up [emoji106]

 

[PMBangers]

Love you work, keep it up [emoji106]

You shouldn't, I'm a nuffie with too much free time.

but thank you regardless

 

[richoatthedisco]

Well, you're watching a 2 minute highlights clip

No. I'm not.

 

[Wrenny]

Just listened to the final podcast mock draft. There was no trading.

#9 - Josh Ward (Hobbs #7/Andrew #8
#17 - JVR (Amiss #15/Sonsie #16
#28 - Angus Sheldrick
#29 - Zac Taylor
#30 - Jack Williams
(Tom Brown #26/Judson Clarke #27)

Blake Howes went to WC @31

Thoughts?

 

[Hamsatma]

You shouldn't, I'm a nuffie with too much free time.

but thank you regardless

you're not special in that regard - anyone who spends any time at all on bigfooty is a nuffie with too much spare time!

 

[richoatthedisco]

Something in that hey

What I'm tryna say is I heard interest, and doing my phantom so far out from the actual draft just went with it

You didn't factor in that we have three picks in the range that you rightly rate Taylor?

 

[Rioli2Rioli]

Something in that hey

What I'm tryna say is I heard interest, and doing my phantom so far out from the actual draft just went with it

Rachele rating was the interesting one for me , Love to know why so low