Lore
Moderator ❀
- Dec 14, 2015
- 48,919
- 73,337
- AFL Club
- Essendon
- Moderator
- #203
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.

Due to a number of factors, support for the current BigFooty mobile app has been discontinued. Your BigFooty login will no longer work on the Tapatalk or the BigFooty App - which is based on Tapatalk.
Apologies for any inconvenience. We will try to find a replacement.
2 months of garbage on the trade thread to go firstwhen is the draft ?
Log in to remove this Banner Ad
that and medium sized forwardsAfter watching Oliver and Petracca tear that apart, I’m all for drafting the next gun mid. Midfield is 80-90% where games are won and lost now
It's been like that for 20 years. That, and an elite defence is generally the premiership combo.After watching Oliver and Petracca tear that apart, I’m all for drafting the next gun mid. Midfield is 80-90% where games are won and lost now
The days of the small forward who cannot hold his own in marking contests are numbered. Unless of course they have another weapon ie blistering speedthat and medium sized forwards
I think our defence is going to be elite next year. Balta, Grimes, Broad, Vlastuin, Tarrant, Short. That’s as good as anyIt's been like that for 20 years. That, and an elite defence is generally the premiership combo.
Unfortunately that could probably only be via trade. Pick 7 isn't going to get us a Walsh, Rowell or Dusty that's a gun from year 1.I think our defence is going to be elite next year. Balta, Grimes, Broad, Vlastuin, Tarrant, Short. That’s as good as any
Need that gun mid that has an impact from
Day 1 and I think we will be right in the picture again next year
Yep.Unfortunately that could probably only be via trade. Pick 7 isn't going to get us a Walsh, Rowell or Dusty that's a gun from year 1.
Exactly. Petracca is 25, Oliver 24, Brayshaw 25, Viney 26.Unfortunately that could probably only be via trade. Pick 7 isn't going to get us a Walsh, Rowell or Dusty that's a gun from year 1.
which makes sense for us to trade up if Dimma thinks we can go again with this group. Thats why i think we would go for Ward who would play round one next year for sure.Exactly. Petracca is 25, Oliver 24, Brayshaw 25, Viney 26.
Our picks aren't high enough, and even then, they won't be game winning style mids for a handful of years, and by then Dusty, Grimes, Broad, Lynch (let alone Cotchin, Riewoldt) are gone.
Our best chance is to jag one last flag with this group. Otherwise we really need to get a bunch of high quality players to that mid 20's, 100+ games mark together (i.e. a few lean years, and high draft picks).
Sent from my CPH1951 using Tapatalk
I think people severely overrated draft picks impact in their first year. Very, very few make a tangible difference in year 1.which makes sense for us to trade up if Dimma thinks we can go again with this group. Thats why i think we would go for Ward who would play round one next year for sure.
Unfortunately that could probably only be via trade. Pick 7 isn't going to get us a Walsh, Rowell or Dusty that's a gun from year 1.
To draft who though? Daicos is gone, Horne-Francis maybe the other that could be a year 1 impact will be gone.Unless we end up snaring GC pick 3 in a deal.
To draft who though? Daicos is gone, Horne-Francis maybe the other that could be a year 1 impact will be gone.
I dont think the next mids are going to be year 1 guys. That's a very, very rare group.
Big Strong midsAfter watching Oliver and Petracca tear that apart, I’m all for drafting the next gun mid. Midfield is 80-90% where games are won and lost now
Ollie Wines was pick #7 Cripps was #13 just to name a fewUnfortunately that could probably only be via trade. Pick 7 isn't going to get us a Walsh, Rowell or Dusty that's a gun from year 1.
I think people severely overrated draft picks impact in their first year. Very, very few make a tangible difference in year 1.
If we want a recruit to drive a flag it'd have to be a Cerra/Green type trade. Someone who is ready to go AFL seasoned and developed.
The players that come to mind that will fall to our picks that are big body athletic 'beast' like players are Josh Goater & Ned LongTo draft who though? Daicos is gone, Horne-Francis maybe the other that could be a year 1 impact will be gone.
I dont think the next mids are going to be year 1 guys. That's a very, very rare group.
Even Dusty MK2 in his first year is unlikely to be much more than a role player. Far more critical to our flag chances will be keeping Cotch, Prestia, Nank, Edwards etc. fit and fresh.which makes sense for us to trade up if Dimma thinks we can go again with this group. Thats why i think we would go for Ward who would play round one next year for sure.
Even Dusty MK2 in his first year is unlikely to be much more than a role player. Far more critical to our flag chances will be keeping Cotch, Prestia, Nank, Edwards etc. fit and fresh.
Rowell a couple of years ago was probably about the only player to come in at near A grade level from year 1. And he was widely regarded as about the most complete, ready made AFL player to ever come into the system.
Sent from my CPH1951 using Tapatalk
^The idea is to have moments in games and bring about a youthful engergy back into the club. Also being decent enough to be in the 22. Not asking for game winners as we have those. Just players that take to position of a Geroge, Pickett, Aarts