Discussion 2021 Player X v Y v Z

[Caztheconquerer]

Hawkins vs dale

 

[Jiska]

Hawkins vs dale

Impossible. I’ve tossed this up all week. Landed on Dale but without any sense of confidence. Hawk has a high ceiling but a low floor. Dake more consistent I feel.

 

[Megabattimus]

As a betting man, I would bet on Edwards playing this week. Was one of the reasons they won last weekend, he was immense in the last quarter, usually the time when rookies die off and struggle. They have plenty of spuds that will get dropped before Edwards (Duggan, Waterman, O'Neill, Langdon, Jones, etc)

I'd take him over Bramble

The other option is to get neither, and get Briggs or another DEF or FWD option. Why? Because a midfield bench of Newcombe, a DEF/MID swing (eg. Bianco, with Laird in defence) and a MID/FWD swing (eg. FinMac, with Dusty up forward) is the way to go. Too many mid only rookies on your mid bench means you won't have DPP link on all lines. If you want cash gen, take Edwards, if you want cover, I'd avoid all mid only rookies

Yeah I'm definitely going Briggs next week if he gets named.

On Pixel 3 using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Judd_Magic]

How long is Mumford out?

Will Briggs only play this week and then Mumford comes back in next week for him?

I'm debating on grabbing Briggs as a downgrade and 16th scorer vs Edwards who has better JS but won't play this week.

Thoughts?

 

[Jiska]

How long is Mumford out?

Will Briggs only play this week and then Mumford comes back in next week for him?

I'm debating on grabbing Briggs as a downgrade and 16th scorer vs Edwards who has better JS but won't play this week.

Thoughts?

**** the Byes. Play the long game.

 

[Caztheconquerer]

Impossible. I’ve tossed this up all week. Landed on Dale but without any sense of confidence. Hawk has a high ceiling but a low floor. Dake more consistent I feel.

Yep that’s what I’m trying to figure out, like you have been tossing up between them most of the week. Dale playing down back and distributing and kicking out should be more consistent. Maybe leaning that way now

 

[Deliverance]

How long is Mumford out?

Will Briggs only play this week and then Mumford comes back in next week for him?

I'm debating on grabbing Briggs as a downgrade and 16th scorer vs Edwards who has better JS but won't play this week.

Thoughts?

Does Edwards have JS with Kelly and Shuey due back?

 

[Judd_Magic]

Does Edwards have JS with Kelly and Shuey due back?

He's playing well so would be stiff to be dropped.

Hai_Newman , Here2tellyouwhy thoughts?

 

[TempletonTheRat]

How long is Mumford out?

Will Briggs only play this week and then Mumford comes back in next week for him?

I'm debating on grabbing Briggs as a downgrade and 16th scorer vs Edwards who has better JS but won't play this week.

Thoughts?

I don't see it with Briggs, although only one game to base it on.
his JS has to be pretty shaky and when he does play what is he going to score?
he doesn't provide much cover or scream cash gen

 

[boulders]

Guthrie or Lyons?

 

[pieman123]

Guthrie or Lyons?

Lyons, with Danger back it may affect Guthrie's score like earlier in the year plus the dodgy shoulder.

 

[Jiska]

Hawkins vs dale

Impossible. I’ve tossed this up all week. Landed on Dale but without any sense of confidence. Hawk has a high ceiling but a low floor. Dake more consistent I feel.

I’m still torn on this. Hawk has five game at KP to come.

What do others think on this X v Y?

 

[Caztheconquerer]

I’m still torn on this. Hawk has five game at KP to come.

What do others think on this X v Y?

Think I’m going to go with Hawkins but still tossing up between them both

 

[Borgan]

walsh and langford

or

boak and hawkins/dale

 

[Megabattimus]

walsh and langford

or

boak and hawkins/dale

Boak and Hawkins

On Pixel 3 using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Hai_Newman]

He's playing well so would be stiff to be dropped.

Hai_Newman , Here2tellyouwhy thoughts?

I think he'll stick around for a while...lots of INs coming back though. I don't need to jump early so no stress on my part..I can get Newcombe this week so all good...5th pint cheers.

 

[DaveyBoy123]

Greene v Langford?

Think I need to trade Impey out before he bleeds $$ and it becomes too hard.

I have the same decision (although I'm trading Heeney to 1 of them). Did you land on either 1 as yet?

Very hard to make the decision, especially with Toby's kicking for goal inaccuracy this season, and him only being thrown into the middle as a last resort last week.

 

[richolovesgoal]

Bont at 680
Parish at 650
Guthrie at 600
Kelly at 570

Who do you take?

 

[marcmurphy3]

Josh Kelly or Cam Guthrie?

 

[ForeverHardcore]

Bont at 680
Parish at 650
Guthrie at 600
Kelly at 570

Who do you take?

Every chance jelly scores the most out of this lot imo
Great price and will help further upgrades
He’s in rare form as is bont who I see getting tagged tonight by O’Connor

parish plays for Essendon so don’t see a lot of teams worrying about tagging him going forward
Guthrie I would avoid with the shoulder

I like jelly

 

[ForeverHardcore]

Josh Kelly or Cam Guthrie?

Jelly a million times before guthrie if you’re trading for this week

if you can wait a week and see how Guthrie looks tonight then do that
But I would pick jelly who ironically has no injury issues

 

[ForeverHardcore]

walsh and langford

or

boak and hawkins/dale

Boak and Hawkins/dale
As a duo
I like safety

walsh starting to get tagged the last few games
Will get de boer tomorrow night
Langford I’m getting this week but think he’s a rung under both Dale and Hawkins

 

[ForeverHardcore]

Guthrie or Lyons?

Lyons
Guthrie shoulder still a concern for me

lions the most under appreciated premo in the game and deserves a spot in every team

 

[ForeverHardcore]

Hawkins vs dale

If I’m picking one for the rest of the year
I’m going Dale
We don’t know his ceiling yet which is exciting

he’s hall but in a bulldogs jumper
Less reliant on other factors to score

hawk is a champion and will score well but we know his range

i see it being
Dale 105+ Range going at 104 since he made the half back is own round 5
Hawk 95-105 range will have high scores but low end scores around that

 

[Caztheconquerer]

If I’m picking one for the rest of the year
I’m going Dale
We don’t know his ceiling yet which is exciting

he’s hall but in a bulldogs jumper
Less reliant on other factors to score

hawk is a champion and will score well but we know his range

i see it being
Dale 105+ Range going at 104 since he made the half back is own round 5
Hawk 95-105 range will have high scores but low end scores around that

Thanks mate, makes the decision slightly easier