Discussion 2021 Player X v Y v Z

[TempletonTheRat]

Ignoring Williams suspension Dunkley and Williams vs Daniel and Butters

 

[AFDogs]

Ignoring Williams suspension Dunkley and Williams vs Daniel and Butters

Daniel > Dunkley
Williams > Butters

IMO.

 

[TempletonTheRat]

Helmet v Shorty

 

[stevebbb]

Clark, Impey, Dow and Campbell. Pick 2

 

[AFDogs]

Clark, Impey, Dow and Campbell. Pick 2

Dow and Campbell.

Clark most potential but likely to be in and out the side.

 

[PoopingHindi]

Clark, Impey, Dow and Campbell. Pick 2

Clark and Campbell based purely on hope.
The other 2 have already proven that they’re bog average.

 

[Andrew Birch]

Clark, Impey, Dow and Campbell. Pick 2

Clark & Campbell. We need a cheap mid-priced D5 and he's the best option with handy dpp. Campbell for role and kick/handball ratio, elite kick & handy dpp




Oliver & Taranto vs Jelly & Rowell?

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

Clark & Campbell. We need a cheap mid-priced D5 and he's the best option with handy dpp. Campbell for role and kick/handball ratio, elite kick & handy dpp




Oliver & Taranto vs Jelly & Rowell?

Bitch please.

Oliver never misses Jelly is toast
Taranto is semi proven, Rowell is still in nappies.

 

[stevebbb]

Clark & Campbell. We need a cheap mid-priced D5 and he's the best option with handy dpp. Campbell for role and kick/handball ratio, elite kick & handy dpp




Oliver & Taranto vs Jelly & Rowell?

Not worried about Campbell not playing with Lloyd in the side?
adding PoopingHindi and AFDogs who also picked Campbell



Oliver and Taranto for me.

 

[Andrew Birch]

Not worried about Campbell not playing with Lloyd in the side?
adding PoopingHindi and AFDogs who also picked Campbell



Oliver and Taranto for me.

Interesting. I hadn't thought about whether Campbell would still be picked with Lloyd in the team. Thanks, b.

To the Swans board

 

[Cookiemon]

Helmet v Ridley
Short v Docherty
Cripps v Walsh

Cheers in advance

 

[stevebbb]

Helmet v Ridley
Short v Docherty
Cripps v Walsh

Cheers in advance

Can't go wrong with either, but Daniel for me. Slightly safer maybe?
Short
Cripps

 

[pinchhitter]

Walsh & T.Phillips vs Taranto & Rowell

 

[Barnzy]

Walsh & T.Phillips vs Taranto & Rowell

Taranto and Rowell and it's not close

 

[rocker_oz33]

Piggy and Phillips.

Vs.

BONT and LDU.

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

Helmet v Ridley
Short v Docherty
Cripps v Walsh

Cheers in advance

Helmet is a bit safer in his role and average
Short but I have both. Doc is very juicy plum
Walsh. **** Cripps. He is dead to me (InB4 150+ first half of year and he in my team)

Walsh & T.Phillips vs Taranto & Rowell

Gotta go Taranto and Rowell

Piggy and Phillips.

Vs.

BONT and LDU.

Any combo of.
Ive got Bont and phillips but man LDU is juicy

 

[Cookiemon]

Can't go wrong with either, but Daniel for me. Slightly safer maybe?
Short
Cripps

Helmet is a bit safer in his role and average
Short but I have both. Doc is very juicy plum
Walsh. fu** Cripps. He is dead to me (InB4 150+ first half of year and he in my team)

Thankyou gentlemen
Helmet it is
Have managed to include Doc & Short in backline as well with Laird now in mids
Final question now being do I keep Laird or take Walsh/Cripps (Or alternative $560k ish max mid)

Appreciate your thoughts

 

[timtimtim]

Helmet v Shorty

Helmet purely for consistency

 

[MagicGnome97]

Steele vs Oliver

&

Ridley vs Stewart

 

[rocker_oz33]

Steele vs Oliver

&

Ridley vs Stewart

Piggy and Stewart.

 

[ak11]

gawn and dusty or grundy and danger? (my second ruckman is witts)

 

[Keg still on legs]

I took Helmet out last night and had Short. I didn't like how it looked so Helmet is back in now

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

I took Helmet out last night and had Short. I didn't like how it looked so Helmet is back in now

go on...

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

Thankyou gentlemen
Helmet it is
Have managed to include Doc & Short in backline as well with Laird now in mids
Final question now being do I keep Laird or take Walsh/Cripps (Or alternative $560k ish max mid)

Appreciate your thoughts

Laird

He's likely to be the Crows highest scoring player.

Flip him to D1/2 around the byes and grab a discounted M6/7/8

 

[Cookiemon]

Laird

He's likely to be the Crows highest scoring player.

Flip him to D1/2 around the byes and grab a discounted M6/7/8

You sound like you're still sober