I don't think Doogs is there yet...maybe in another year or two. I was surprised with his finish in the B&F to be honest...so clearly rated as an emerging talent and leader. Frawley I'm sure is impressive...and obviously been brought over to do a job, but for mine Carlisle makes guys like Coffield and Clark (when at HBF) play a lot more confidently, and makes the backline better, as evidenced last year.With a fit frawley in the mix I dunno about that.
Frawley FB + Doogs CHB could well be a decent improvement on the jake doogs combo.
Dougal has all the tools to be a dominant AA CHB and frawley is the best FB on our list.
Guess, we'll see.