- Moderator
- #679
List Mgmt. 2022 AFL Draft & Rookie Draft
- Thread starter Stamos
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Aug 16, 2015
- 10,962
- 18,414
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- Arsenal
Your comments on Phillipou are interesting, when you say at AFL level he would be a forward, like what type of forward? Stringer type or Gunston type? We are drying out for either, yet you still don’t seem too interested.
Similar with Jefferson, can he play in the same forward line with Harry and Charlie? If not, I really don’t see why we would pick him, if he’s a third tall type or if he could play the second ruck role then sure, I just don’t see a need for that type.
The Return of the Paf
Club Legend
- Aug 22, 2020
- 1,357
- 1,607
- AFL Club
- Carlton
All I can say is that you draft players based on what they are, not on what they are not. I'd draft either of Phillipou or Jefferson, even if the latter makes it harder for someone like Silvagni.
Just talking talent, and I will share my thoughts on about 30 odd players soon
Phillipou reminds me more of a Fritsch at this stage. While I understand the fascination of people thinking most forwards or defenders can play further up the ground due to doing stints or even large portions of time through the middle, many aren't able to translate that aspect at AFL level.
I stated earlier in regards to Jefferson that he is and will be a player that warrants a top 12 pick, despite not being a priority need, so I would take others I rate at a similar level, that are more needs based.
Jefferson is a Harrison Jones type, you could let him develop naturally in the VFL and when ready, play as a 2nd KPF, with Charlie as a 3rd tall
But again, at our 1st pick, I would take Busslinger if he slid, or either Hotton or Hayes.
Hotton is perfect need based, quick, sharp, breaks lines, kicks goals
Busslinger or Hayes develop as KPDs in the VFL and or play 3rd tall at AFL level like Gibcus. Once ready to hold down a KPD role with Weitering, you could play Young forward/chopout ruck
Plenty of viable options
Justnetime
Team Captain
- May 18, 2021
- 521
- 1,047
- AFL Club
- Carlton
I’ve been a big fan of needs over best available within the span of a couple of picks. It’s ‘the opportunity‘ to get a best 22 spot that is the best development route for a young player. Setterfield is a decent player with no opportunity killing his career. So needs picking within reason offers a solution to this problem . Stocker another example. Kennedy under Teague.
Having said all of that, in the 2022 draft this year I’m all for best available. Our list has reached a state of class on every line. If not class then young class about to step up (TDK/Mirkov and Motlop/Durdin). For the wingers we have Acres and if we want Walsh. All class there. Every other line has strong players.
For this Year pick best available. For next year repeat except for the player type picked this year and so on for the next 4 years.
Having said all of that, in the 2022 draft this year I’m all for best available. Our list has reached a state of class on every line. If not class then young class about to step up (TDK/Mirkov and Motlop/Durdin). For the wingers we have Acres and if we want Walsh. All class there. Every other line has strong players.
For this Year pick best available. For next year repeat except for the player type picked this year and so on for the next 4 years.
From the main board.....I think PMBangers is on the rookie me central team - which is a great resource - as well as publishing the AFL DRAFT GUIDE. This is his latest phantom, although he does qualify it with 'best fit' to clubs, and of course this order will change during the trade period.
Going by the media commentary, you'd imagine that the top 10 or so are almost locked in - although the exact order may change - but suggests that players like Humphrey, Hotton, Jefferson, Hollands and Hewett etc could be available around our first pick along with a potential slider.
Anyway, I reckons it'd have Arr0w and Forty3 pretty chuffed with our two picks if this came to be.
Personally I'd love to grab Humphrey if he was still available at our pick, looks like he could be a real game changer.
www.bigfooty.com
Going by the media commentary, you'd imagine that the top 10 or so are almost locked in - although the exact order may change - but suggests that players like Humphrey, Hotton, Jefferson, Hollands and Hewett etc could be available around our first pick along with a potential slider.
Anyway, I reckons it'd have Arr0w and Forty3 pretty chuffed with our two picks if this came to be.
Personally I'd love to grab Humphrey if he was still available at our pick, looks like he could be a real game changer.
Draft Expert - PMBangers' (and ‘friends’) 2022 Draft Board
As a non expert on Vic, I really liked that kid Murdoch......apart from the big names, he's the one I really noticed. There's something about those low possession but highly effective lockdown players that gets me too, but I just don't think I've seen Sheezel so obviously struggle in an U18's...
www.bigfooty.com
Love Weddle, would be gutted to see Hewett go to the Pies though!From the main board.....I think PMBangers is on the rookie me central team - which is a great resource - as well as publishing the AFL DRAFT GUIDE. This is his latest phantom, although he does qualify it with 'best fit' to clubs, and of course this order will change during the trade period.
Going by the media commentary, you'd imagine that the top 10 or so are almost locked in - although the exact order may change - but suggests that players like Humphrey, Hotton, Jefferson, Hollands and Hewett etc could be available around our first pick along with a potential slider.
Anyway, I reckons it'd have Arr0w and Forty3 pretty chuffed with our two picks if this came to be.
Personally I'd love to grab Humphrey if he was still available at our pick, looks like he could be a real game changer.
Draft Expert - PMBangers' (and ‘friends’) 2022 Draft Board
As a non expert on Vic, I really liked that kid Murdoch......apart from the big names, he's the one I really noticed. There's something about those low possession but highly effective lockdown players that gets me too, but I just don't think I've seen Sheezel so obviously struggle in an U18's...
I really like Weddle, would like him even more if he grew a little.
Hewett is a strange one, had a great back end to his junior year, but has been a little "off" this year and not sold on his disposal
From the main board.....I think PMBangers is on the rookie me central team - which is a great resource - as well as publishing the AFL DRAFT GUIDE. This is his latest phantom, although he does qualify it with 'best fit' to clubs, and of course this order will change during the trade period.
Going by the media commentary, you'd imagine that the top 10 or so are almost locked in - although the exact order may change - but suggests that players like Humphrey, Hotton, Jefferson, Hollands and Hewett etc could be available around our first pick along with a potential slider.
Anyway, I reckons it'd have Arr0w and Forty3 pretty chuffed with our two picks if this came to be.
Personally I'd love to grab Humphrey if he was still available at our pick, looks like he could be a real game changer.
Draft Expert - PMBangers' (and ‘friends’) 2022 Draft Board
As a non expert on Vic, I really liked that kid Murdoch......apart from the big names, he's the one I really noticed. There's something about those low possession but highly effective lockdown players that gets me too, but I just don't think I've seen Sheezel so obviously struggle in an U18's...
He would also get some reasonable club mail, so not surprised with Hotton and I do like him
Would love Barnett to drift a couple more spots, reminds me of Ben Miller
Hayes that late? Can't see it
Jeremias
Moderator
- Sep 26, 2004
- 46,218
- 62,614
- AFL Club
- Carlton
But, does a power of work, love his content
Technically it's still a top 10
Hotton at our pick. I liked what I've seen in the games I've watched v metro
No it won't. Don't be surprised if we attack it again next year with future picks coming in, in stronger draft
100% those 2 have better footy traits than what jsos has
- May 29, 2009
- 29,793
- 14,710
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- LA Lakers
Hewett had some real battles with his lungs after covid this year. If he gets that sorted out someone is getting a steal. If…
4flagsin5yrs
Premiership Player
Could you advise where I might watch some of the earlier U18 national games?
I have Kayo, there?
NameoftheGame
Rookie
- Jul 4, 2022
- 29
- 67
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
Yep Kayo still have them. If you select sport at the top of the screen/then AFL/ then AFL local you can scroll through and see all the games
- Jul 13, 2018
- 812
- 1,683
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Is there a link anywhere to the NAB league GF or has that ship sailed?
4flagsin5yrs
Premiership Player
thanks.
- Moderator
- #1,046
Indicative draft order: Wednesday 28 September
A look at where Carlton's picks lie heading into trade period.
I have kayo, go on Afl local it's all there
ferrisb
Brownlow Medallist
The top 10 most valuable open market trade assets in the entire AFL
Kane Cornes has done the work and come up with his top 10.
www.sen.com.au
Cornes (I know, I know) names his 10 highest trade value players in the league (imagine if every player was on the trade table).
Has Harry at #4
And Charlie at #1
Righto let's trade both of 'emThe top 10 most valuable open market trade assets in the entire AFL
Kane Cornes has done the work and come up with his top 10.
Cornes (I know, I know) names his 10 highest trade value players in the league (imagine if every player was on the trade table).
Has Harry at #4
And Charlie at #1
