Review 2022 AFL National (& Rookie) Draft(s) Thread II (North's picks - Sheezel, Wardlaw, B.George, Harvey, Drury,Free,Howe,Turner)

Remove this Banner Ad

Might not be as many as you'd think, a lot of those guys just find something else to do with their lives. Can't expect them to wait around forever

A lot of the 195+cm kids that don’t get drafted don’t really get the chance to physically mature in the state leagues. Many of them can’t compete physically at state league level as 19 year olds.
They end up playing a few games, but for the vast majority then end up playing local footy or reserves if they are based in SA or WA.

Sam Paea is a good example, was on the fringe of getting drafted last year, signed at Werribee but didn’t get much of a chance in the seniors because he lacking 5-8kg to really be a force. Ended up playing most of his footy this year in the EDFL for Aberfeldie. You aren’t getting drafted from there.

Josh Rentsch is another one. He was on the fringe to get drafted last year, ended up going over to Sturt in the SANFL. Played mostly reserves, managed a few senior games but avg’d less then 10 disposals and a goal per game because he is playing on a lot of ex AFL listed 26+ y.o key defenders.

Then the lure of $$$ from country and metro footy usually means a lot of them walk away from state leagues before they reach their potential.
 

AFL News: Ultimate guide to the 2022 off-season and draft winners​

Sam Landsberger gives a final overview of this year’s trade and draft periods as club call for an overhaul of the rules on draft night.

Sam Landsberger


December 4, 2022 - 11:58AM
News Corp Australia Sports Newsroom
https://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/.../33faf509df04d5d0120c7eb348ccc35c#share-tools

Which clubs really won the AFL draft? And what do recruiters really think of the talent pathways system? Which rules need changing and which player needs lifts to training? Sam Landsberger takes a different look at the draft.


GOLD MEDAL
Geelong won the trade period and North Melbourne banked who most clubs believed were the best two players in the open draft. But Brisbane Lions enjoyed the No. 1 off-season. They traded for Jack Gunston and Josh Dunkley, signed Conor McKenna for nothing and drafted father-son guns Will Ashcroft and Jaspa Fletcher without going into points deficit. That could be five players slotting into the best 22 for a top-four team in premiership mode. Ashcroft was clearly the best teenager in the land and is a $3.50 favourite for the 2023 Rising Star after producing similar numbers to Nick Daicos, Fletcher is an outside midfielder who is as hard as nails and kicks long goals while Darcy Wilmot and Kai Lohmann from last year’s draft look good.

WHY EVERYONE WAS A WINNER
North Melbourne had Brayden George ranked in the top 10 after he booted 17 goals in the first five NAB League games. Later, he ruptured his ACL. But the Roos got him at No. 26 after taking who most clubs ranked as the best two players in the open draft – Harry Sheezel and George Wardlaw. Similarly, the Bombers thought father-son Jayden Davey was a first-rounder until he ruptured his ACL in pre-season. They got him at No. 54. Sydney’s three draftees, ex-soccer star Jacob Konstanty (No. 20), Cooper Vickery (No. 27) and Caleb Mitchell (No. 40), were ranked in the club’s top 20. Hawthorn suspected it was done until it traded back into the draft when Bailey Macdonald was still there at No. 51, securing five players for the first time in 13 years. Finalist Fremantle wanted maturity after farewelling David Mundy, Rory Lobb, Griffin Logue, Darcy Tucker and Lloyd Meek, so it secured 21-year-old Tom Emmett and 25-year-old Corey Wagner, who was the only recycled player taken in the national draft. The Giants think Max Gruzewski complements No. 1 pick Aaron Cadman. Everyone sees it differently, and in a draft that was as open as a 7/11 store after the first dozen or so it is little surprise most clubs walked away smiling.

WHO DRAFTED REALLY WELL?
St Kilda and West Coast’s hauls were among those highly-rated in the industry. Saints’ indigenous development manager Katrina Amon (Hawk Karl’s mum) sat in their recruiting box and they took Isaac Keeler at No. 44. As a 16-year-old Keeler looked like Paddy Ryder at – kicking goals, taking big marks and winning hit-outs. His development plateaued, and Adelaide chose not to nominate him in its academy, but the talent is there. The Eagles brought in a good balance and their final pick, Noah Long (No. 58), is a small forward with big potential, even though he couldn’t recapture his best form after a broken collarbone. Collingwood was legitimately surprised Ed Allan reached its first pick given his athletic profile, while Carlton ticked off its needs for outside run, run and more run. The Blues bagged two draftees from the draft combine’s 2km time trial podium, winner Oliver Hollands (5 min 54sec) and third-placed Jaxon Binns (6min), after trading in Blake Acres. What does that mean for 2022 wings Lochie O’Brien and Matthew Cottrell?

SHALLOW POOL
Only 70 players were drafted or rookie-listed from 886 nominations, a figure that alarmed some clubs. “We just need to find more talent and develop more talent, because these draft pools are so thin,” one recruiter said. ”From all the academies and all the games we watch throughout the year, only 70 get a chance. We need to expand the draft pool to 100 kids who are worthy of getting on a list. Clubs passing picks is quite sad.”

SHOW US THE MONEY
Respected recruiter Simon Dalrymple (Sydney) told the Herald Sun’s draft podcast the NAB League needed more funding. “I've been frustrated over the last few years with the NAB League,” Dalrymple, one of the game’s best talent-spotters, said. “Obviously we’ve had Covid, but just the lack of training with some of the players, and (there’s) too much reliance on paying personal trainers or outside providers instead of the NAB League being a high-performance centre. That’s so important. I was at Eastern Ranges when Sam (Mitchell) was coming through and those boys were doing three weights sessions a week at the Croydon Leisure Centre as part of their program with the NAB League. We’ve addressed it with the AFL, and obviously there’s been funding issues. Hopefully (AFL talent pathways boss) Grant Williams and his team are all over that.” Rivals echoed Dalrymple. They are worried NAB League clubs now have to service boys and girls footy from under-16s – which is an ”enormous amount of people”. One recruiter said NAB League clubs should invest more in the draftable talents, rather than those bound for local leagues. “Midway through the year they should say, ‘These are the eight guys in contention to get drafted. Others, off you go, and we’ll bring up 17-year-olds, because we know clubs won’t go near these 12 players’”. The AFL recently announced full-time NAB League coaches for both boys and girls at each of the programs, as well as additional development, support and wellbeing resources.

RULE TWEAKS
Clubs love the idea of trading draftees, and not just picks, on the night. For example, if the Giants desperately wanted Jacob Konstanty (Sydney) or Josh Weddle (Hawthorn) they could have offered up one of their future first-round selections to execute a live trade, with a draftee’s destination not locked in until the draft is over. There is also widespread support for the AFL to allow clubs to trade two years of future picks, rather than one. However, some are against that fearing the strong clubs would get even stronger, because the likes of Richmond and Geelong — who traded valuable future picks in the trade period — would again be well-equipped to strike deals for established stars who request trades next year. Salary dumping rules could be tightened, too, with one suggestion that contracts must be honoured as they were signed, rather than smoothing the cash out on a renegotiated deal. Clubs also want the AFL to simplify the process of demoting players from the primary list to rookie list, rather than having to delist and redraft them, in the event both parties agree to it.

FAMOUS NAMES
South Australia’s squad will be littered with large names across the next two years. There’s father-sons Will McCabe (Hawthorn, son of Luke), Tyler Welsh (Adelaide, son of Scott), high-flyer Louie Montgomery (Port Adelaide, son of Brett), Lucas and Ben Camporeale (Carlton, son of Scott) and Rome Burgoyne (Port Adelaide, son of Peter).

MARQUEE PICKS (Players drafted with one of the selections received after trading a star)
North Melbourne: George Wardlaw (Jason Horne-Francis)
Gold Coast: Bailey Humphrey (Izak Rankine)
West Coast: Elijah Hewett (Junior Rioli)
Melbourne: Matthew Jefferson (Luke Jackson)
Western Bulldogs: Charlie Clarke (Josh Dunkley)

WHY SWANS POACHED HAWKS KID
The frightening form of matchwinners Kozzie Pickett, Charlie Cameron and Cody Weightman contributed to Sydney’s decision to draft Cooper Vickery out of Hawthorn’s Next Generation Academy … with the No. 27 pick the Hawks handed the clever Swans 24 hours earlier. Sydney loved the task-orientated Orbost boy who travelled far and wide to play footy this year, and the Hawks didn’t have priority access in the first 40 selections.

THE BEST CELEBRATOR:
Charlie Clarke (Western Bulldogs) – infectious energiser who goes crazy like Tom Papley. Crumbing forward who will complement Cody Weightman and wreak havoc at the feet of Rory Lobb, Sam Darcy and Aaron Naughton.

MR RESILIENT:
Tom Emmett (Fremantle) – The 21-year-old accountant who was diagnosed with a rare subtype of non-Hodgkin's lymphoma (cancer) before his 17th birthday. Amazing story.

THE BOLTER:
Oliver Sestan (Melbourne) – Rookie-listed off the back of a training session for draftees organised by Connors Sports. Well done, Paul Connors. Kicked 24 goals in a game for Mansfield.

THE GROWER:
Josh Weddle (Hawthorn) – Shot up 20cm in two years to go from little-known rover to buzz utility at 193cm. Former cross-country runner clocked 6min 2sec 2km in the 2km and has run with Olympic Games competitor Tamsyn Lewis. Played on talls (Cadman) and smalls (Sheezel) this season.

THE SLIDER: Harry Lemmey (Carlton) – 200cm key forward who started the year a top-10 prospect, but looked uncompetitive at times and was swung into defence as he dropped down the grades. Can it click again at Carlton?

TOP CHARACTER: Hugh Bond (Adelaide) – Takes big hits, plays with courage and is the sort of professional you can build a club around. Crows traded a future pick to get Bond when he remained on the board at No. 50.

HAPPY TO BE HERE: Mattaes Phillipou (St Kilda) – Blown away by St Kilda’s impressive facilities in Moorabbin, which Ross Lyon described as “like Disneyland for St Kilda” compared to Seaford. The confident 17-year-old goalkicker reminds some of Christian Petracca, given his power and explosion. Still growing.

DESIGNATED DRIVER: George Wardlaw (North Melbourne) – The No. 4 draft pick drives through traffic on the field, but requires lifts to Arden St because he doesn't yet have his licence.

EARLY SURPRISE: Toby McMullin (GWS) – Most had the Sandringham speedster pegged as a late pick or in the rookie range. But the Giants wanted a point of difference to round out their package, so McMullin went at No. 34, which was their final selection.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

I just keep thinking about the number of mid-size forwards on our list ...

I wouldn't be surprised if someone decent gets traded out over the next couple of years.

It will be sad, although it's been a while since we've had players of currency - imagine actually taking one ... 🤯

Clarko has traded young players before.
 
I just keep thinking about the number of mid-size forwards on our list ...

I wouldn't be surprised if someone decent gets traded out over the next couple of years.

It will be sad, although it's been a while since we've had players of currency - imagine actually taking one ... 🤯

Clarko has traded young players before.

Yeh but which of them have proven themselves worth a pinch of **** over a sustained period yet other than Zurhaar?

We often think we have a logjam for spots until we realise we actually don't.
 
Yeh but which of them have proven themselves worth a pinch of **** over a sustained period yet other than Zurhaar?
Outside of Zurhaar...

season 10 episode 22 GIF
 
I just keep thinking about the number of mid-size forwards on our list ...

I wouldn't be surprised if someone decent gets traded out over the next couple of years.

It will be sad, although it's been a while since we've had players of currency - imagine actually taking one ... 🤯

Clarko has traded young players before.
Brayden George could be the next Petracca. Or could be the next Taylor Garner...

Point is, lets not count our chicks until they've hatched.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top