Chewy316
Norm Smith Medallist
- Jul 1, 2014
- 6,752
- 17,901
- AFL Club
- Port Adelaide
- Other Teams
- Lakers, Ducks, Yankees
Whatever Mayock and Gruden were doing was far worse. The should have used PFF player grades.
The biggest problem above all else with the Raiders drafting has been the 1st round picks. Rounds 2 through 7 I can live with. Getting guys like Moehrig, Hobbs, Crosby, Renfrow etc. But they've whiffed big time on first round picks.
One person described it well to me - Mayock is a good talent evaluator and is on top of the draft as much as anyone. However, it's a completely different ball game talking about a player in terms of a scouting report as opposed to being the guy making a pick when you're on the clock and you have to pick the right guy and you've got say half a dozen players all with a similar grade. Odds are that a few are going to flame out, one will be great, and 2 will be solid. You have to find that great one. That's an art - and that's not something that can be inherently taught.