- May 23, 2019
- 14,217
- 35,772
- AFL Club
- Western Bulldogs
Enjoying the phantom. The early pick of Darcy Jones means that either Ginbey or the Buss makes it to our first.
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.

Due to a number of factors, support for the current BigFooty mobile app has been discontinued. Your BigFooty login will no longer work on the Tapatalk or the BigFooty App - which is based on Tapatalk.
Apologies for any inconvenience. We will try to find a replacement.
I respect your opinion, it's not unreasonable, but I'll stake my entire reputation (so, nothing really) on Jones being a much much better player than Allan. I'm too lazy to elaborate why but if I'm wrong you can dig this up and absolutely humiliate me, like just **** me up with shame.Yeah I get that but at 174cm he’s just too undersized for me at pick 11 when there’s likely to be some pretty decent players on the board still.
Realistically will he ever be able to play anywhere but small forward? Probably too short to spend considerable time on the wing these days and I get the Bolton example but he’s very much the exception not the rule.
He’d have to be a very good forward to be worth it at pick 11, if we think he can do that then I’m happy to take the punt as it’s something we need but he strikes me more as an undersized mid than natural small forward - sort of in the similar mould to our own Arthur Jones.
His athletic profile is insane though, more the agility for mine over his speed that stands out as a real point of difference that will see him make it at the level, but then you look at Allan who has a similar athletic profile but stands at 194cm and it would be hard for me to not gravitate towards the upside of the 194cm prospect to be honest

Never heard of him! I haven't been following it as obsessively this year as I have in previous. What do you like about him (besides the name)?CaptainMurphy whilst we are looking at Darcy Jones, I actually like his ‘partner in crime’ Steely Green to
Your thoughts?
And yes, his name is awesome![]()
Log in to remove this Banner Ad
Hahaha will do.I respect your opinion, it's not unreasonable, but I'll stake my entire reputation (so, nothing really) on Jones being a much much better player than Allan. I'm too lazy to elaborate why but if I'm wrong you can dig this up and absolutely humiliate me, like just * me up with shame.
Enjoying the phantom. The early pick of Darcy Jones means that either Ginbey or the Buss makes it to our first.
Ginbey. Ginbey. Ginbey.
Odds on there's a slider who slides right past us tooHighly doubt it pans out that way in the real thing but it does show we're in a pretty good spot for a slider at our first pick.
Odds on there's a slider who slides right past us too
Busslinger makes a lot of sense for Geelong. He’s perfectly suited to their narrow ground and DeKoning taking the main forward.Rumour is Geelong will take Busslinger even if Clark is available and many of their supporters seem to think it makes sense.
From what I've read looking at rumours, news sources and "inside info" etc. It could go something like this
Pick 1 - GWS - Cadman
Pick 2 - Brisbane (bid) - Ashcorft
Pick 3 - North - Sheezel
Pick 4 - North - Wardlaw/Tsatas
Pick 5 - Essendon - Tsatas/Wardlaw
Pick 6 - Gold Coast - Ginbey
Pick 7 - Hawthorn - Humphrey
Pick 8 - Geelong - Busslinger
Pick 9 - West Coast - Clark
Pick 10 - St Kilda - McKenzie
Pick 11 - Carlton - Hollands
- Pretty confident the top 5 will play out something like that, maybe with GWS bidding on Ashcorft instead. Seems consistent with a lot of sources
- Sounds like Gold Coast are after some big body mids and like Ginbey and Humphrey
- The West Coast list/recruiting dude said that if there are 2 very similar prospects they would favour the WA player over the interstate one. They may not have a WA choice and may have to go an interstate player at 9
- St Kilda have a good NGA system going after taking two last year and if McKenzie is available I think they will likely go and draft him after putting time and development into him
- Carlton have apparently met with Hollands a few times. Rumour they also like Hayes
- Jefferson may still go top 10, but some clubs question if he has enough mongrel. Apparently a very nice guy, maybe a bit too nice and gets pushed off the ball a bit too easily
- Phillipou has supposed character issues, but nobody knows what they are so I'm guessing it's a complete load of crap. Maybe there's some truth to it and he slides down the order though. Wishful thinking I know.
Herald Sun mock has us taking Philippou and George.
Would be pretty wrapped with that
No current season stats available
not 100% on George when Weddle was still available, but he's a talent

Herald Sun mock has us taking Philippou and George.
Would be pretty wrapped with that
Yeah would be a tough decision. Also has Hewitt going outside 25 which is interestingnot 100% on George when Weddle was still available, but he's a talent
After taking Philipou…. And then double dipping on George…. How are we going to fit two more centre square players into our team?
Rather Weddle or Clarke (although Clarke is already off the board).
I think George in particular could be primarily a forward.After taking Philipou…. And then double dipping on George…. How are we going to fit two more centre square players into our team? That is they’re eventual slot…. I guess Libba will eventually retire…. But still.
Rather Weddle or Clarke (although Clarke is already off the board).
Libba has deified my expectations by still doing everything he is now to such a standard but for guys like him the cliff comes quickly (whenever that may be). With George coming off an ACL I can't imagine him pushing for afl selection for awhile, with the club having the enviable option of letting him regain confidence in his body and get good continuity at vfl level before even considering afl footy.After taking Philipou…. And then double dipping on George…. How are we going to fit two more centre square players into our team? That is they’re eventual slot…. I guess Libba will eventually retire…. But still.
Rather Weddle or Clarke (although Clarke is already off the board).
Libba has deified my expectations by still doing everything he is now to such a standard but for guys like him the cliff comes quickly (whenever that may be). With George coming off an ACL I can't imagine him pushing for afl selection for awhile, with the club having the enviable option of letting him regain confidence in his body and get good continuity at vfl level before even considering afl footy.
Personally I'd prefer more outside types this year but can see the reasoning behind it.