WaynesWorld19
Finding Rhythm
- Joined
- Nov 6, 2003
- Posts
- 131,377
- Reaction score
- 186,402
- Location
- Melbourne
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
- Other Teams
West Adelaide
- Thread starter
- #490
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.

West Adelaide
West AdelaideWho is everyone rolling with at f5? At the moment is the bane of my team.. never happy with it. D rioli at the moment but it's uninspiring
Currently have 5 players priced within 43k of each other with Butters at F5, but does that mean I have 5 x F5's?Who is everyone rolling with at f5? At the moment is the bane of my team.. never happy with it. D rioli at the moment but it's uninspiring

Nah, you gotta think positively. You have five value F2s!Currently have 5 players priced within 43k of each other with Butters at F5, but does that mean I have 5 x F5's?![]()
Log in to remove this Banner Ad
Rayner, subject to changeWho is everyone rolling with at f5? At the moment is the bane of my team.. never happy with it. D rioli at the moment but it's uninspiring

Interesting. I think maybe you were less on the fence than you think and actually on the No Heeney side waiting for a reason not to pick himBeen on the fence, but this rules Heeney out for me now:
![]()
Heard this one before? Find out why it's actually happening
Coming off a strong pre-season, Isaac Heeney is eyeing more midfield minutes in 2022www.afl.com.au
Contrary to the article title, it actually highlights how Heeney will still play forward at times. Bye bye Heeney and bye bye Horse - no players from the Swans this year brings me a sigh of relief![]()
Interesting. I think maybe you were less on the fence than you think and actually on the No Heeney side waiting for a reason not to pick him
Nothing about that article says avoid to me.
1 lie about not being full time mid that involved no quotes
That 1st quote you made wasn’t a quote but the journalists own spin.Honestly, he's been in my team most of the pre-season - before alot of his midfield increase became widespread knowledge.
Been really keen on him given his price and his ability - but it's these couple of lines that make me think it's not a permanent midfield move, but rather, increased stints in there rotating with others:
"There's no suggestion Heeney will plonk himself into the midfield on a full-time basis, although that's where he's trained most during pre-season."
...
Parker said Sydney had been tinkering with its combinations, including pushing himself and Josh Kennedy into forward and wing rotations to keep fresh legs on the ball."
***********
Given the huge availability of underpriced forwards we have at our disposal, it's tough to pick someone like him without a guarantee that he will be a perma mid- given how injury prone he can be as well.
It's a big risk to take, and one that's burnt a lot of us before, so without absolute surety, I'm much less keen than I was prior to the practice match.
None.Also, how many of those underpriced fwds will be Full time mids themselves?
Loves a tackle tooNone.
I don't know why anyone expected Heeney to be a full time mid. Of course he will still play significant minutes up fwd, but he averages 90 odd in his better years as predominately a fwd. With an increase in midfield minutes I don't see why he couldn't still yet push triple figures.
Heeney feels safer with a few years of 90 odd averages in a row, excluding last yearIf you had to pick one, Heeney or Butters?
I had both, but moved Butters up to Weller, could just as easily have been Heeney, a toss of the coin really, both have injury issues and both are relying on significant mid minutes.If you had to pick one, Heeney or Butters?
Questionable stats for mine. Plenty of guess work given that many have said they could hardly see the field let alone the players. My guess is that Warner got all Heeney's stats. The take home for me is that the midfiekd role is there (pending Mills return).I still want to know where the fu** Heeney went for the second half of the game on 60 to half time then ****
Been on the fence, but this rules Heeney out for me now:
![]()
Heard this one before? Find out why it's actually happening
Coming off a strong pre-season, Isaac Heeney is eyeing more midfield minutes in 2022www.afl.com.au
Contrary to the article title, it actually highlights how Heeney will still play forward at times. Bye bye Heeney and bye bye Horse - no players from the Swans this year brings me a sigh of relief![]()
I honestly think people are just scarred from previous experiences with Heeney so they’re not seeing how low-risk he really is this year. Thankfully I’ve hardly ever owned him before because being a Swans supporter and watching a lot of their games I never really trusted the role, so I can bring a reasonably un-biased opinion…It's a big risk to take, and one that's burnt a lot of us before, so without absolute surety, I'm much less keen than I was prior to the practice match.
Weller and Thomas for me currentky but that is the car defining question!Who to leave out (x2)?
Heeney, Butters, Cogs , Weller or Thomas

Doesn't help the stream gave my all the nausea hahaQuestionable stats for mine. Plenty of guess work given that many have said they could hardly see the field let alone the players. My guess is that Warner got all Heeney's stats. The take home for me is that the midfiekd role is there (pending Mills return).
All quality players. I get these conundrums every year and feel the only solution is pick them all and roll with it if you think some are unmissable.Who to leave out (x2)?
Heeney, Butters, Cogs , Weller or Thomas
Who to leave out (x2)?
Heeney, Butters, Cogs , Weller or Thomas