List Mgmt. 2022 List Management: Draft, Trade and FA

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.
Reader mode
So we've got to complete a puzzle and some of the pieces are Grundy, Lobb, Jackson, Franklin, Dusty? Is everyone thinking what I am thinking? The biggest trade in AFL history?

Fremantle Loses: Lobb, '22 1st Rounder, '23 First Rounder
Fremantle Gains: Jackson

Melbourne Loses: Jackson
Melbourne Gains: '22 First Rounder (Fremantle), '22 First Rounder (Bulldogs)

Sydney Loses: Franklin, 23' Second Rounder
Sydney Gains: Dusty

Western Bulldogs Loses: '22 First Rounder
Western Bulldogs Gain: Lobb, 22' Third Rounder (Magpies)

Collingwood Loses: Grundy, 22' Third Rounder
Collingwood Gains: '22 First Rounder (Port)

Richmond Loses: Dusty
Richmond Gains: '22 First Rounder (Essendon)

GWS Loses: Tim Taranto
GWS Gains: Grundy, '23 First Rounder (Fremantle)

Port Loses: '22 First Rounder
Port Gains: Franklin, 23' Second Rounder (Essendon)

Essendon Loses: '22 First Rounder, '23 Second Rounder
Essendon Gains: Tim Taranto

West Coast Loses: All Their Games
West Coast Gains: Wooden Spoon & F***ed List.
 
PavlichsNeighbour said:
So we've got to complete a puzzle and some of the pieces are Grundy, Lobb, Jackson, Franklin, Dusty? Is everyone thinking what I am thinking? The biggest trade in AFL history?

Fremantle Loses: Lobb, '22 1st Rounder, '23 First Rounder
Fremantle Gains: Jackson

Melbourne Loses: Jackson
Melbourne Gains: '22 First Rounder (Fremantle), '22 First Rounder (Bulldogs)

Sydney Loses: Franklin, 23' Second Rounder
Sydney Gains: Dusty

Western Bulldogs Loses: '22 First Rounder
Western Bulldogs Gain: Lobb, 22' Third Rounder (Magpies)

Collingwood Loses: Grundy, 22' Third Rounder
Collingwood Gains: '22 First Rounder (Port)

Richmond Loses: Dusty
Richmond Gains: '22 First Rounder (Essendon)

GWS Loses: Tim Taranto
GWS Gains: Grundy, '23 First Rounder (Fremantle)

Port Loses: '22 First Rounder
Port Gains: Franklin, 23' Second Rounder (Essendon)

Essendon Loses: '22 First Rounder, '23 Second Rounder
Essendon Gains: Tim Taranto

West Coast Loses: All Their Games
West Coast Gains: Wooden Spoon & F***ed List.
Click to expand...
Hang onto this for post-season. There’s normally a prize for most convoluted trade.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

PavlichsNeighbour said:
So we've got to complete a puzzle and some of the pieces are Grundy, Lobb, Jackson, Franklin, Dusty? Is everyone thinking what I am thinking? The biggest trade in AFL history?

Fremantle Loses: Lobb, '22 1st Rounder, '23 First Rounder
Fremantle Gains: Jackson

Melbourne Loses: Jackson
Melbourne Gains: '22 First Rounder (Fremantle), '22 First Rounder (Bulldogs)

Sydney Loses: Franklin, 23' Second Rounder
Sydney Gains: Dusty

Western Bulldogs Loses: '22 First Rounder
Western Bulldogs Gain: Lobb, 22' Third Rounder (Magpies)

Collingwood Loses: Grundy, 22' Third Rounder
Collingwood Gains: '22 First Rounder (Port)

Richmond Loses: Dusty
Richmond Gains: '22 First Rounder (Essendon)

GWS Loses: Tim Taranto
GWS Gains: Grundy, '23 First Rounder (Fremantle)

Port Loses: '22 First Rounder
Port Gains: Franklin, 23' Second Rounder (Essendon)

Essendon Loses: '22 First Rounder, '23 Second Rounder
Essendon Gains: Tim Taranto

West Coast Loses: All Their Games
West Coast Gains: Wooden Spoon & F***ed List.
Click to expand...
I’ll be mad as hell if we give up two first rounders and Lobb for Jackson. On the other hand, if that offer went to the doggies for Naughton... we need a proven goal kicker, not a bloke that nobody can decide where he best slots into our side. No disrespect to Jackson of course
 
"I'm not going to read the 129 previous pages, but I assume that somewhere in there it's been noted that Jackson's skillset is a better fit for West Coast than Fremantle.

The Dockers have Darcy, who is a very good ruckman, and will remain so for many years; he would best be complemented by a key forward who could take minutes in the ruck. The 2022 version of Rory Lobb is doing a pretty decent job of that. Obviously if Lobb goes there's room for Jackson, and Jackson is an outstanding player, but I see him as a ruckman who operates as an extra midfielder, and less as a key forward.

West Coast, on the other hand, need to replace an ageing Naitanui, and Jackson is as close to a like-for-like replacement as you could hope for. He'd be effective in the ruck and useful when the ball is in dispute, like Naitanui; and also good on the spread. He's more mobile than Naitanui but at this stage he can't quite replicate the freakish ruck work. If Jackson sees his future as a number 1 ruck, he'll be that for 10 years at West Coast.

However: maybe the Eagles just can't afford him, in picks or dollars; or maybe he doesn't want to come to a club at the wrong end of the ladder. In that case, why wouldn't he just stay at Melbourne and take over from Gawn in time? Gawn is 7 years older than Darcy, so Jackson's time would arrive sooner at Melbourne than Fremantle."

Geez, what a slacker! Kids these days don't know the meaning of hard work! :laughing:
 
PavlichsNeighbour said:
So we've got to complete a puzzle and some of the pieces are Grundy, Lobb, Jackson, Franklin, Dusty? Is everyone thinking what I am thinking? The biggest trade in AFL history?

Fremantle Loses: Lobb, '22 1st Rounder, '23 First Rounder
Fremantle Gains: Jackson

Melbourne Loses: Jackson
Melbourne Gains: '22 First Rounder (Fremantle), '22 First Rounder (Bulldogs)

Sydney Loses: Franklin, 23' Second Rounder
Sydney Gains: Dusty

Western Bulldogs Loses: '22 First Rounder
Western Bulldogs Gain: Lobb, 22' Third Rounder (Magpies)

Collingwood Loses: Grundy, 22' Third Rounder
Collingwood Gains: '22 First Rounder (Port)

Richmond Loses: Dusty
Richmond Gains: '22 First Rounder (Essendon)

GWS Loses: Tim Taranto
GWS Gains: Grundy, '23 First Rounder (Fremantle)

Port Loses: '22 First Rounder
Port Gains: Franklin, 23' Second Rounder (Essendon)

Essendon Loses: '22 First Rounder, '23 Second Rounder
Essendon Gains: Tim Taranto

West Coast Loses: All Their Games
West Coast Gains: Wooden Spoon & F***ed List.
Click to expand...
Franklin should go to St Kilda - That way that club can finally claim they got their " Big Fish"
 
Polo342 said:
Could we actually afford Buddy in the cap? People before were saying if we recruit Jackson that we would be struggling capwise
Click to expand...
Can Freo find $700-$800,000 a year to get buddy Franklin as a free agent for 1 or 2 seasons? Absolutely.

Even with Rory Lobbs $700,000 a year contract still on freos books.

Anyone think it's a bad idea getting Franklin on as a free agent needs to take this into consideration.

Remember the Jesse Hogan trade back In 2018? That cost us picks 6 and 23 didn't it? Or the Lachie Neale compo picks. Didn't prevent Freo in having a good season in 2022 didn't it?


Also back at the end of 2011, Freo nearly got Mitch Clark and were we're gonna pay him $700,000 a year and trade picks 16 and 20 to get him.
 
Tobiko said:
Nah, strong pass from me. Have faith in the champs we got to win the Holy Grail. Not a fan of this messianic fantasy
Click to expand...
No one is claiming he’s the messiah anymore, just would be perfect to fill a Lobb sized hole in our forward line. Cost the same money and zero draft picks, why wouldn’t you try to get him for two years? Gives Amiss and Treacy two years to develop and we strengthen our draft hand with whatever picks we get for Lobb. The only downside I can see is we can’t make a play for Gus Brayshaw as well as that would break the bank. As many have already alluded to, our midfield is stacked and we can’t find room for Raz and Johnson as it is.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Buddy would be great but as others have said I can't see his Mrs being too keen to move to WA.

Obviously you have to fit everyone inside the cap but from a financial perspective $750,000 to Buddy is a great investment. Ticket sales and merchandise would spike and we'd get more Friday night games.
 
Does anyone have the Luke Jackson article written by Paul Hasleby? 🤗
 
Actual proper list management and curation to meet a strategy versus a shopaholic bipolar "oh look some old superstar that is available but totally superfluous or even counter to the plan - but we should BUY it!" / "Oh no! we don't have enough money to keep young players! SELL the farm!"....

The conspiracy theorist in me posits that clubs do this (ie. "lowball", let speculation go around some players etc.) just to try and throw other list managers of their game just in the hope that this happens and people screw their overall plans up.

 
dominguez said:
That's not our problem is it. JLo has said that he's told Lobb he's a required player but it looks like Lobb wants out.
Click to expand...

Lobb is a fool then. Life for him post AFl career could be much easier as a Premiership player than not, assuming we’re more likely to get one with him in the side than if he goes to the dogs. Sure, there’s no guarantee of that or of the dogs not getting one with him in their side but the odds are more favourable if he sticks fat with Freo.
 
Reader mode
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Similar threads

go_the_dockers
List Mgmt. 2025 List Management thread - Trade Targets
2 3 4
Replies
75
Views
6K
yakamoto
Y
Lach72
List Mgmt. 2025 List management
4 5 6 7 8
Replies
197
Views
10K
Superkoops
Superkoops
E
  • Poll
Strategy Load Management
Replies
6
Views
360
eastfreo75
E
go_the_dockers
  • Locked
  • Poll
List Mgmt. 2024 List Management thread - Trade Targets
459 460 461 462 463
Replies
12K
Views
945K
s_wd6
s_wd6
go_the_dockers
  • Locked
List Mgmt. 2024 List Management thread - Trade Targets Part 2
397 398 399 400 401
Replies
10K
Views
182K
fnerd
F
T
List Mgmt. The Case Against Chad.
2
Replies
44
Views
2K
pK75
pK75
Tonga Bob
Welcome Welcome to Freo Jaren Carr - pick 63 of the 2024 Draft (a real life Father-Son selection!!!)
2 3
Replies
72
Views
4K
freoextra
freoextra

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top