List Mgmt. 2022 Trade, Draft, etc thread

[Scythe94]

Dory_77 – might be worth pinning this? Gets updated after every move.

 

[Mich0]

Out: Bedford
In: 44

Out: 27, 54
In: Grundy

Out: Jackson, F3
In: 13, Freo F1, Freo (not North) F2

Out: Tomlinson
In: Pick around 40-45

That then leaves us with: 13, 44, ~45.

If Tomlinson goes, I expect we'll need to use all three picks. That being said, armed with 13, our F1 and Freo's F1, I imagine we'll try and move up to the top-10 this year.

Freo can’t trade out both future 1st n 2nd rounders.

They also want a future 2nd for Sharp (which is why they are being a pain in the ass for us). They want there F2 for Sharp and keep North F2 due to future pick trading rules.

Only way it could work is if Dees F2 goes back their way somewhere in there.

 

[Mich0]

No mention of a top 20 pick for Weid?

Weid straight swap for Whitfield according to Ralph’s twitter.

 

[KAYNE]

Realistically, this is how I see it playing out for us.

Out: Bedford
In: 44

Out: 27, 54
In: Grundy

Out: Jackson, F3
In: 13, Freo F1, Freo (not North) F2

Out: Tomlinson
In: Pick around 40-45

That then leaves us with: 13, 44, ~45.

If Tomlinson goes, I expect we'll need to use all three picks. That being said, armed with 13, our F1 and Freo's F1, I imagine we'll try and move up to the top-10 this year.

We don't want picks this year in the 40+ range. Draft doesn't have depth apparently. We might get those picks to send to Brisbane for an earlier pick but they are trying to get Dunkley in.

 

[KAYNE]

Weid straight swap for Whitfield according to Ralph’s twitter.

I think he was highlighting how stupid Trade Radio was though to be fair

 

[Bluelegs]

Is it just me or does it feel like every draft has been shallow for like five years now.

 

[Scythe94]

No mention of a top 20 pick for Weid?

I'd attach the top 20 pick from Freo to get rid of him, but we'll need to use all three selections

 

[Topkent]

Is it just me or does it feel like every draft has been shallow for like five years now.

There was the one SuperDraft year that we traded out of, 2018 maybe?

 

[Scythe94]

Freo can’t trade out both future 1st n 2nd rounders.

They also want a future 2nd for Sharp (which is why they are being a pain in the ass for us). They want there F2 for Sharp and keep North F2 due to future pick trading rules.

Only way it could work is if Dees F2 goes back their way somewhere in there.

Imagine there'll be a way for them with whatever compensation they receive for Lobb.

 

[Bluelegs]

There was the one SuperDraft year that we traded out of, 2018 maybe?

Sparrow, Jordon, Nietscheke, Hore and Bedford for picks 27, 33, 53, 56 and 75.

The pick we traded to get Lever in ended up at Carlton as pick 19 and was used for Liam Stocker but honestly there wasn't much on offer in that range anyway. Looking at it, the first round was pretty good but most of pleyers picked after that made it are just role players.

 

[Benwah83]

Realistically, this is how I see it playing out for us.

Out: Bedford
In: 44

Out: 27, 54
In: Grundy

Out: Jackson, F3
In: 13, Freo F1, Freo (not North) F2

Out: Tomlinson
In: Pick around 40-45

That then leaves us with: 13, 44, ~45.

If Tomlinson goes, I expect we'll need to use all three picks. That being said, armed with 13, our F1 and Freo's F1, I imagine we'll try and move up to the top-10 this year.

Yep, seems about right. Not entirely convinced we'll get a F2 back for Jacko as an upgrade on our F3, but we'll see.

Not sure who will take a punt on Tomlinson.

I wonder what happened to the the talk about Hunter? That seems to have died off.

 

[TheBoss]

His worth the same as they got for hill. 2nd rounder.

It isn’t common for 2 x 2nd rounders to be traded up for a first.

Bedford has no currency.

GWS are only interested because he fills a need and it is a cheap punt on a guy that has had 4 years development. He won't be detrimental to them if he fails to fire a shot.

 

[booshboy]

Jackson has been back in Perth for 3 weeks, how is he not already ******* sick of his Mum and signed a new deal with us yet?

 

[Tulip]

Realistically, this is how I see it playing out for us.

Out: Bedford
In: 44

Out: 27, 54
In: Grundy

Out: Jackson, F3
In: 13, Freo F1, Freo (not North) F2

Out: Tomlinson
In: Pick around 40-45

That then leaves us with: 13, 44, ~45.

If Tomlinson goes, I expect we'll need to use all three picks. That being said, armed with 13, our F1 and Freo's F1, I imagine we'll try and move up to the top-10 this year.

I think it'll be this, but we'll pay Freo our F2 for North's F2.

Don't think Tommo will go anywhere, and if he does we'll get a very late pick.

 

[Tulip]

On another note, I'd quite like to start lurking on the phantom drafts board like a nuffy so can we get some picks in pls?

 

[Mich0]

Bedford has no currency.

GWS are only interested because he fills a need and it is a cheap punt on a guy that has had 4 years development. He won't be detrimental to them if he fails to fire a shot.

GWS can’t get anyone to nominate them. You think when they finally get someone to nominate them they won’t pay a little extra to get the deal done?

Won’t be good optics for anyone else considering a move to GWS

 

[Tulip]

I wonder what happened to the the talk about Hunter? That seems to have died off.

I reckon that was contingent on Harmes leaving

 

[Tulip]

GWS can’t get anyone to nominate them. You think when they finally get someone to nominate them they won’t pay a little extra to get the deal done?

Won’t be good optics for anyone else considering a move to GWS

GWS have stacks of picks that they won't be using. I'm sure we'll get something good - too good, given he's IMO pretty limited - for Bedford.

 

[Scythe94]

I reckon that was contingent on Harmes leaving

Yeah, Hunter signed his current deal straight after winning their B&F, so imagine it's decent money that we can't fit in as we're already taking on Grundy's big deal.

 

[LarryDavidNeitz]

Is it just me or does it feel like every draft has been shallow for like five years now.

“Draft experts” say that every year.
Makes them feel more expert by saying all the good players are in next year’s crop. You wouldn’t know them

 

[A11dAtP0w3R]

Jackson has been back in Perth for 3 weeks, how is he not already ******* sick of his Mum and signed a new deal with us yet?

He likes being tucked into his single racing car bed and getting read a story each night before bed too much

 

[KAYNE]

GWS can’t get anyone to nominate them. You think when they finally get someone to nominate them they won’t pay a little extra to get the deal done?

Won’t be good optics for anyone else considering a move to GWS

This and the fact they have a lot of good early picks. Think that is thee reason we are asking a high price because they have a lot of picks. GWS have offered a 3 year deal so they obviously rate him enough to do that.

 

[TheBoss]

This and the fact they have a lot of good early picks. Think that is thee reason we are asking a high price because they have a lot of picks. GWS have offered a 3 year deal so they obviously rate him enough to do that.

Bedford deal is probably going to be a bunch of R3&4 pick swaps that are contingent on us bedding down the Jackson and Grundy trades first.

 

[Mich0]

Bedford deal is probably going to be a bunch of R3&4 pick swaps that are contingent on us bedding down the Jackson and Grundy trades first.

Bedford is probably worth more to them than a top 20 pick as he actually wants to go to GWS opposed to any top 20 picks who will piss off back to Victoria after 2 years for a lower pick then what they were taken for.

 

[Proper Gander]

Exactly, Bowes is pretty irrelevant in the deal. The prize is pick 7 to allow you to move into the top 3. We come out like bandits, replace Jackson with another top 3 elite talent with a first and second left over to make other deals with in the future if we don't have the cap space this year.

This scenario skips the possibility that we too, like many clubs, try to get the good deals. We miss out like many others because players seem to want Geelong

 

[Scythe94]

Ned Guy, hey? Expect Collingwood to be paying part of Bowes' salary then.