List Mgmt. 2023 Draft Thread - Part I

[St Neil]

If Saints end up with pick 27 from Gold Coast, I wonder if we would look to package it up with 21 and try and get a draft pick in the mid teens?

Adelaide, NM and GWS are the sellers. Unless Sydney want to trade down because they have no picks between 12 and 45.

 

[Joffaboy]

If Saints end up with pick 27 from Gold Coast, I wonder if we would look to package it up with 21 and try and get a draft pick in the mid teens?

Adelaide, NM and GWS are the sellers. Unless Sydney want to trade down because they have no picks between 12 and 45.

If we get 27, I would select DiMattia at 13 and then again at 27 just to make sure [emoji846][emoji6]

On SM-S908E using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[saintmike65]

Long is not a great example.
Horrible draft choice, despite us somehow getting back some trade value.



Why didn't they put Murdoch back?

Murdoch was too slow!

 

[Significant]

If Saints end up with pick 27 from Gold Coast, I wonder if we would look to package it up with 21 and try and get a draft pick in the mid teens?

Adelaide, NM and GWS are the sellers. Unless Sydney want to trade down because they have no picks between 12 and 45.

Adelaide won't trade back, they are already trying to trade out..

I've convinced myself that DeMattia is a ruse to try and get someone before us to pick him and get Wilson to slide. If we are into Roberts as well, he is almost a bloody clone of DeMattia or what he projects to be at the next level.

 

[MrFoster]

I have faith in the club. Surely they know limitations of Demattia (low production/not a genuine mid), hopefully they are just playing games so they can draft him with our 2nd pick if he is still there.

 

[Mavefromdelburn]

Still would like after watching him live a few times and watching him singlehandedly pants Sandringham

 

[Winmar2Lockett]

Maybe adding a future 3rd? If that's possible, surely there would be a way around it

Add a F3 to? and for what?

We currently have our 1st, our 3rd, Carlton's 3rd & Freo's 3rd from memory.

We're rumoured to be sending one of our F3's to Melbourne for pick 42.

The only way around it is to jag a F2 back... so our F1, F3 for a pick in the teens & a late 2nd? Go into next year's draft with a 2nd, 3rd & 4th.

You never know, someone might jump at it (banking on us going backward) but it's probably highly unlikely they do.

 

[StCicatriz]

the adelaide recruiter just making cal twomey redundant live on air was ****in hilarious

 

[Saints_87]

Add a F3 to? and for what?

We currently have our 1st, our 3rd, Carlton's 3rd & Freo's 3rd from memory.

We're rumoured to be sending one of our F3's to Melbourne for pick 42.

The only way around it is to jag a F2 back... so our F1, F3 for a pick in the teens & a late 2nd? Go into next year's draft with a 2nd, 3rd & 4th.

You never know, someone might jump at it (banking on us going backward) but it's probably highly unlikely they do.

Pretty much like you said future 1st and 3rd for a 14,15 this year and future 2nd back

 

[stavro#4]

 

[BrutThough]

the adelaide recruiter just making cal twomey redundant live on air was *in hilarious

What happened?

 

[BrutThough]

ST KILDA​

Current picks: 13, 21, 40, 77, 82, 86

EARLY LOOK: Ross Lyon came out after the elimination final loss to the Giants and revealed his desire to improve the midfield – and the big-body and breakaway speed of Sandringham’s Charlie Edwards might be the perfect fit. The Saints have been linked to the late-season bolter with one of their first two calls, along with WA pair Lance Collard and Koltyn Tholstrup. Dashing defenders Riley Hardeman and Geelong Falcon Angus Hastie are also likely to be in the mix but, before any of those, St Kilda could bid on one – or both – father-son prospects Luke McCabe and Jordan Croft.

LATE MAIL: St Kilda has shown strong interest in Arie Schoenmaker, who looms as a potential option for their second pick. They are also believed to be among the leading contenders for 200cm Gippsland Power utility Wil Dawson.

 

[stavro#4]

ST KILDA​

Current picks: 13, 21, 40, 77, 82, 86

EARLY LOOK: Ross Lyon came out after the elimination final loss to the Giants and revealed his desire to improve the midfield – and the big-body and breakaway speed of Sandringham’s Charlie Edwards might be the perfect fit. The Saints have been linked to the late-season bolter with one of their first two calls, along with WA pair Lance Collard and Koltyn Tholstrup. Dashing defenders Riley Hardeman and Geelong Falcon Angus Hastie are also likely to be in the mix but, before any of those, St Kilda could bid on one – or both – father-son prospects Luke McCabe and Jordan Croft.

LATE MAIL: St Kilda has shown strong interest in Arie Schoenmaker, who looms as a potential option for their second pick. They are also believed to be among the leading contenders for 200cm Gippsland Power utility Wil Dawson.

Charlie

 

[SaintWWodonga]

If we end up with Wilson & Edwards (somehow) I'll be happy. Also later on Murphy may slip.

 

[SaintsSeptember]

Pretty much like you said future 1st and 3rd for a 14,15 this year and future 2nd back

Except in exceptional circumstances, the future pick is worth less than a current mid first round pick.
Future first and third for current first is a deal that could happen.
Why on earth would they consider sweetening it with a second?
They might as well just give us their future second for no reason.

 

[stfan]

Need to stop pussyfooting around

"St Kilda, Pick #13 - F Gump, University of Alabama"

Well the last St Kilda player to wear calipers as a boy became arguably the best player ever in AFL/VFL history.

 

[Winmar2Lockett]

Pretty much like you said future 1st and 3rd for a 14,15 this year and future 2nd back

Unless we do separate deals & come up with something like;

F1st to GWS for pick 8 (probably only worth doing if Sanders somehow falls & they are happy to gamble on our pick).

Pick 27 (from GC) to the Pies for their F2nd.

Take #8, #17 & #28 to the draft.

Sanders, C.Edwards & the best slider @ 28 (Hardeman, Murphy, Roberts, etc)

 

[Saintscomemarchingin]

ST KILDA​

Current picks: 13, 21, 40, 77, 82, 86

EARLY LOOK: Ross Lyon came out after the elimination final loss to the Giants and revealed his desire to improve the midfield – and the big-body and breakaway speed of Sandringham’s Charlie Edwards might be the perfect fit. The Saints have been linked to the late-season bolter with one of their first two calls, along with WA pair Lance Collard and Koltyn Tholstrup. Dashing defenders Riley Hardeman and Geelong Falcon Angus Hastie are also likely to be in the mix but, before any of those, St Kilda could bid on one – or both – father-son prospects Luke McCabe and Jordan Croft.

LATE MAIL: St Kilda has shown strong interest in Arie Schoenmaker, who looms as a potential option for their second pick. They are also believed to be among the leading contenders for 200cm Gippsland Power utility Wil Dawson.

He also mentioned that Steele was the only decent midfielder we had.
Edwards, McAuliffe, O'Leary, Simpson, will all do for mine.
Get a tall player when they come out of nappies.

 

[SaintsSeptember]

Unless we do separate deals & come up with something like;

F1st to GWS for pick 8 (probably only worth doing if Sanders somehow falls & they are happy to gamble on our pick).

Pick 27 (from GC) to the Pies for their F2nd.

Take #8, #17 & #28 to the draft.

Sanders, C.Edwards & the best slider @ 28 (Hardeman, Murphy, Roberts, etc)

Depending when the bids come in for the Gold Coast NGA's, ( could be real early ), those Gold Coast picks are likely to vanish very early.
They would trade them for enough later picks to give them a points advantage ( we don't have enough ), but unlikely to trade for a future pick.

GWS would be nuts to trade their pick 8 for a future first.

 

[Winmar2Lockett]

Depending when the bids come in for the Gold Coast NGA's, ( could be real early ), those Gold Coast picks are likely to vanish very early.
They would trade them for enough later picks to give them a points advantage ( we don't have enough ), but unlikely to trade for a future pick.

GWS would be nuts to trade their pick 8 for a future first.

They're considering it for WC's F1st if Curtin falls to them.

Clubs do things that may appear strange to the rank & file punter but they have a lot more intel into future drafts, etc than we do.

Just kicking around options while we wait for our 1st pick (at about 3am tomorrow morning).

 

[bergholt]

Well the last St Kilda player to wear calipers as a boy became arguably the best player ever in AFL/VFL history.

Lawrence Bingham?

 

[Mangus]

On Demattia the 14 Disposal Avg was for the National Champs where he did time in the back pocket including a shut down role on Nick Watson.

His TAC Cup average was 19 still not huge but a better representation

As comparisons maybe Zac Jones is the floor with him and maybe Chad Warner

1

Chad Warner

Age

24

Ht

185cm

Wt

82kg

Pos.

M/F

Career

Season

Last 5

D

7.0

2star

K

4.5

2star

HB

2.5

2star

M

1.5

2star

T

1.5

3star

CL

0.0

1star

D

7.0

1star

K

4.5

2star

HB

2.5

2star

M

1.5

2star

T

1.5

2star

CL

0.0

1star

D

7.0

2star

K

4.5

2star

HB

2.5

3star

M

1.5

2star

T

1.5

4star

CL

0.0

1star

as the ceiling. I think his speed alone makes him useful at AFL level and his kicking is decent certainly can get distance and hit targets. I actually think he is more certain to be an AFL player than Wilson or Edwards but maybe less likely to end up a permanent mid more likely a small running defender.

 

[StCicatriz]

On Demattia the 14 Disposal Avg was for the National Champs where he did time in the back pocket including a shut down role on Nick Watson.

His TAC Cup average was 19 still not huge but a better representation

As comparisons maybe Zac Jones is the floor with him and maybe Chad Warner as the ceiling. I think his speed alone makes him useful at AFL level and his kicking is decent certainly can get distance and hit targets. I actually think he is more certain to be an AFL player than Wilson or Edwards but maybe less likely to end up a permanent mid more likely a small running defender.

what were Zac Jones stats from the champs and U18... i remember him being a highly talked about inside mid

 

[George]

Footage of me cooking for Dard Ball Get, using DeMattia sauce, if he goes to us tonight ffs




Canned microwaved type operator

 

[Veer Right]

On Demattia the 14 Disposal Avg was for the National Champs where he did time in the back pocket including a shut down role on Nick Watson.

His TAC Cup average was 19 still not huge but a better representation

As comparisons maybe Zac Jones is the floor with him and maybe Chad Warner as the ceiling. I think his speed alone makes him useful at AFL level and his kicking is decent certainly can get distance and hit targets. I actually think he is more certain to be an AFL player than Wilson or Edwards but maybe less likely to end up a permanent mid more likely a small running defender.

19 disposal average at underage level... that's the mid the press want us to take?