List Mgmt. 2023 List Management and Trading

[Betts are off]

With Rankine and hopefully Pedlar coming in I was assuming Murphy would be relegated to the ressies.

And I thought he was dropped last year, but now I look at the stats he still played 17 games.

Obviously he should be dropped but I'm not sure the coaches are going to see it this way?

I've said this for years, I like Murphy, I respect what he's gotten out of himself. But at some point we need to prioritize higher ceiling players.

I mean he's been snaking games away from 1st rounders since we had Jordan Gallucci on the list. And he hasn't played since 2019

 

[jackster83]

With Rankine and hopefully Pedlar coming in I was assuming Murphy would be relegated to the ressies.

And I thought he was dropped last year, but now I look at the stats he still played 17 games.

Obviously he should be dropped but I'm not sure the coaches are going to see it this way?

Nicks loves his scrapper types.

 

[George CantStandYa]

I've said this for years, I like Murphy, I respect what he's gotten out of himself. But at some point we need to prioritize higher ceiling players.

I mean he's been snaking games away from 1st rounders since we had Jordan Gallucci on the list. And he hasn't played since 2019

I’d have him in defence before Jones

 

[Betts are off]

I’d have him in defence before Jones

As long as he's not taking up Rachele and Rankine's minutes!

 

[Drugs Are Bad Mackay?]

Re McHenry vs Jones

The one thing I'll say in McHenry's favour is that at least he's struggling in a difficult role.

Jones has looked average even in his bread and butter role of midfield and also looked average in an easier role down back.

One thing against both of them is that their fitness and work ethic has never been questioned. There's no Bernie Vince coasting going on so no new level they can jump to by upping the ante. I know they're still young-ish but are they at or near what they are capable of?

 

[Scorpus]

Seedsman on the inactive list.

Should have two spots for rookies

 

[Danger in Texas]

Seedsman on the inactive list.

Should have two spots for rookies

Will be interesting to see if we keep it open for the MSD or if we decide to give use the spot

 

[jackster83]

Seedsman on the inactive list.

Should have two spots for rookies

The Tyler Brown thing makes more sense now.

 

[Drugs Are Bad Mackay?]

Is that year over for Seedsman?

Or can they come off the inactive list during the season?

 

[Danger in Texas]

Is that year over for Seedsman?

Or can they come off the inactive list during the season?

Sounds like year over, reading the AFC website article

 

[cleanhands]

Sounds like year over, reading the AFC website article

Did someone post not so long ago that there may be more to it, or was someone trolling?

 

[jackster83]

Is that year over for Seedsman?

Or can they come off the inactive list during the season?

It's farewell lap in the back of a HiLux time for Seeds sadly.

 

[Drugs Are Bad Mackay?]

Did someone post not so long ago that there may be more to it, or was someone trolling?

Someone did post the comment that he may be having some health issue(s) outside of the concussion symptoms. But didn't add any detail or clarify

 

[Bearded Clam]

Is that year over for Seedsman?

Or can they come off the inactive list during the season?

Article says he wont play this year..

You’d have to think, given he’s out of contract at years end, that at his age, with his concussion risk issue and now two whole years out of the game that he wont play again..

Strange that he hasnt simply retired.. surely the AFL would allow a full payout of remaining contract and just let him move on with his life instead of still having to remain on the list (as an inactive) for another year..

 

[Scorpus]

Unfortunately that's probably curtains for Seedsman's career.

Hopefully he can recover to the point where he can live a good life beyond football

 

[Scorpus]

Article says he wont play this year..

You’d have to think, given he’s out of contract at years end, that at his age, with his concussion risk issue and now two whole years out of the game that he wont play again..

Strange that he hasnt simply retired.. surely the AFL would allow a full payout of remaining contract and just let him move on with his life instead of still having to remain on the list (as an inactive) for another year..

I imagine like when we re-rookied Sam Shaw a few years back it has to do with health benefits and entitlements for a listed player vs retired

 

[martyparty]

I don't believe in evidence, I just trust my own eyes ...

There's probably a few out there, but he does two or three in these highlights, when he gets 3 goal assists. It was the first video I looked at, as 3 GA's is about as good as he's ever done.

Nice work by McHenry and Murphy in those highlights but some (much?) of the defensive stuff by various Crows is a little cringeworthy.

 

[Magma]

not a surprise, doesnt seem like anyone really comes back after being out with concussion for a large period of time. marcus adams at brisbane also got moved to the inactive list

 

[George CantStandYa]

We knew it was coming but that sucks, life can be a bitch at times.

Come off your best year, one friggin concussion we you don’t have a history of it and bang, life’s not the same.

 

[Betts are off]

Did I just read that Seeds if out for the year again with Concussion?

Just retire mate

 

[GreyCrow]

I wish Seeds all the best - I hope he has a productive life going forward

 

[JPetro83]

Did I just read that Seeds if out for the year again with Concussion?

Just retire mate

I also read that "this opens up another list spot for the Crows"

So with us likely to sign Tyler Brown who is a likely signing to cover Seedsman being put on the inactive list?

 

[Mutineer]

So the player people on here keep mentioning as a KPD prospect Ethan Phillips overlooked again in favour of an Irish journey man who has played 13 AFL games in his 6 years on an AFL list with the Saints. Seems Brisbane Lions list Manager Dom Ambrogio and Head Recruiter Stephen Conole don't rate him either?

Former Saint chasing AFL lifeline at Brisbane

With Marcus Adams sidelined due to concussion, Brisbane has invited Darragh Joyce to audition for a spot on its list

www.afl.com.au

 

[WeeBlake]

Mutineer tell us about some project or overlooked players with serious upside we could go get

 

[rabidcrow]

Article says he wont play this year..

You’d have to think, given he’s out of contract at years end, that at his age, with his concussion risk issue and now two whole years out of the game that he wont play again..

Strange that he hasnt simply retired.. surely the AFL would allow a full payout of remaining contract and just let him move on with his life instead of still having to remain on the list (as an inactive) for another year..

Possibly stays on due to insurance, treatments etc - not sure of the rules for payments around that type of stuff


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com