List Mgmt. 2023 List Management thread

[Snuffaluphagus]

Mod notice after Mr Bob did a lot of annoying work in moving days of posts out of here. As we are heading into offseason, this thread is for 2023 list management only. Getting upset on previous trades can be taken to the vent thread. Lets keep this thread on track in the part of the year it's actually relevant

 

[sumavich]

I’m up for trading one of the rucks, have to be Darcy. He’s worth $ and 2 rucks is just not working

 

[Taylor]

I’m up for trading one of the rucks, have to be Darcy. He’s worth $ and 2 rucks is just not working

Yes it is.

The other one is injured and still kicking a quarter of the goals.

We need natural progression out of Treacy. It's the mark up the line that's the problem

 

[sumavich]

Bullshit. Treacy is a marginal AFL player, and 2 rucks does not work. Its been horrific List Mgt

 

[Taylor]

Bullshit. Treacy is a marginal AFL player, and 2 rucks does not work. Its been horrific List Mgt

I think you're objectively wrong, but you're welcome to be.

 

[sumavich]

I think you are too purple rose glasses.
Treacy kicked a goal excellent, but he's marginal.
Getting Jackson has killed us s/term

 

[Taylor]

I think you are too purple rose glasses.
Treacy kicked a goal excellent, but he's marginal.
Getting Jackson has killed us s/term

When Jackson isn't injured he is our highest impact player. You've forgotten already.

Sean Darcy is one of our others.

We need a mature body who can take a mark, that's what is missing.

 

[Dockeroo]

When Jackson isn't injured he is our highest impact player. You've forgotten already.

Sean Darcy is one of our others.

We need a mature body who can take a mark, that's what is missing.

If only a premiership winning AFL gameplan were as simple as finding someone to mark our long bombs up the line.
At one point a couple of years ago we had two of the top 4 contested marks in the AFL
Tabs & Lobb

Guess what? We were still shite

 

[apuchar]

When Jackson isn't injured he is our highest impact player. You've forgotten already.

Sean Darcy is one of our others.

We need a mature body who can take a mark, that's what is missing.

Waste of time having, essentially a tap ruckman who isn't very Mobile if our mids are not good enough to capitalise. May as well get a ruckman who is good at ground level.

 

[Taylor]

If only a premiership winning AFL gameplan were as simple as finding someone to mark our long bombs up the line.
At one point a couple of years ago we had two of the top 4 contested marks in the AFL
Tabs & Lobb

Guess what? We were still shite

It's a key part of most clubs plans. It's what will turn our game plan on.

 

[Taylor]

Waste of time having, essentially a tap ruckman who isn't very Mobile if our mids are not good enough to capitalise. May as well get a ruckman who is good at ground level.

Got one of them too already. I'll be playing them both at the stoppage next year

 

[sumavich]

Darcy is injury prone as well, ring Geelong

 

[sumavich]

I was at Gage Roads b4 season started and saw Darcy and Jackson together walking with a jug of gage!
Warning signs

 

[Caldera]

It's a key part of most clubs plans. It's what will turn our game plan on.

Alternatively we could get a game plan that doesn’t need us to stick marks up the line to win.

 

[Taylor]

Alternatively we could get a game plan that doesn’t need us to stick marks up the line to win.

It's not about depending on it, it's about having it there whenever the options dry up.

 

[Taylor]

Sam Flanders is getting a lot of ball against the Saints.

 

[freo_leo29]

I was at Gage Roads b4 season started and saw Darcy and Jackson together walking with a jug of gage!
Warning signs

Grown men drink alcohol

Stop the presses!!!!!

 

[Dockeroo]

It's a key part of most clubs plans. It's what will turn our game plan on.

this statement is simply not true

 

[Taylor]

this statement is simply not true

Well we look and play much better when we can take a mark between the arcs but you make a good point here...

Go watch the Sydney game again.

 

[sumavich]

Grown men drink alcohol

Stop the presses!!!!!

Well in pre-season I'd say no boozing.
Started St Kilda well this season.
Basically 2 Rucks is a bad strategy, Hence why Melbourne played with1 last night.
They won btw

 

[Taylor]

So call Jackson a mid/fwd and we don't have a second ruck.

 

[sumavich]

He's not a forward, he's a ruck. We paid shedloads for him, gave up 3 pieces. Play him as our number 1 ruck, and trade Darcy.
Get some picks ffs

 

[mightymouse75]

Henry comes good.
Moves to Melbourne at the end of the year

 

[Taylor]

He's not a forward, he's a ruck. We paid shedloads for him, gave up 3 pieces. Play him as our number 1 ruck, and trade Darcy.
Get some picks ffs

That midfielder Jackson just laced out the leading forward beautifully.

He's a big mid who rests forward.

 

[freo_leo29]

Well in pre-season I'd say no boozing.
Started St Kilda well this season.
Basically 2 Rucks is a bad strategy, Hence why Melbourne played with1 last night.
They won btw

So Pre season no boozing and in season no boozing


So don't drink alcohol for your 15 year career?

 

[freo_leo29]

He's not a forward, he's a ruck. We paid shedloads for him, gave up 3 pieces. Play him as our number 1 ruck, and trade Darcy.
Get some picks ffs

Hes an awful ruck