Remove this Banner Ad

List Mgmt. 2023 List Management thread

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Status
Not open for further replies.
Mod notice after Mr Bob did a lot of annoying work in moving days of posts out of here. As we are heading into offseason, this thread is for 2023 list management only. Getting upset on previous trades can be taken to the vent thread. Lets keep this thread on track in the part of the year it's actually relevant
 
Last edited:
Good news. I hope they get him.
Why would you hope they get him? Seriously Naughton is exactly what we need. Aint gonna win a premiership when your 2nd best tall forward has like 13 odd goals for the season :/
 
Why would you hope they get him? Seriously Naughton is exactly what we need. Aint gonna win a premiership when your 2nd best tall forward has like 13 odd goals for the season :/

You can make the case that our best tall forward has been injured all year, but your point is sound.

We won't win the flag this season.

Treacy will be better next season, but I'd be content with either Naughton or Treacy taking 20 marks a game and kicking exactly zero goals for the year if the likes of Frederick, Walters, Schultz kick 45 to 50 each on the back of that ball movement domination.

Naughton would be the most expensive player on our list by almost double the next highest paid player. I don't think that's worth it.
 
You can make the case that our best tall forward has been injured all year, but your point is sound.

We won't win the flag this season.

Treacy will be better next season, but I'd be content with either Naughton or Treacy taking 20 marks a game and kicking exactly zero goals for the year if the likes of Frederick, Walters, Schultz kick 45 to 50 each on the back of that ball movement domination.

Naughton would be the most expensive player on our list by almost double the next highest paid player. I don't think that's worth it.
Id actually be more than comfortable paying him 1 mill plus a season. At least then we would actually have a contested marking presence in our forward line and also down the line when we kick from defence. We are all putting our hopes in Treacy here who hasn't actually proved that he is even capable of kicking 30-40 goals a season
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Id actually be more than comfortable paying him 1 mill plus a season. At least then we would actually have a contested marking presence in our forward line and also down the line when we kick from defence. We are all putting our hopes in Treacy here who hasn't actually proved that he is even capable of kicking 30-40 goals a season

What if it's closer to two million than it is one million?
 
on Gettable today Twomey listed off a heap of clubs that could be in the running for gold coasts first pick in a pick swap.

We were not one of them 🙃

The scenario discussed on here where we swap our F1 and something for pick 5 was not on Twomeys radar. He must have named 8 or 9 other clubs vying for it however
Yeah I watched that yesterday. It was a bit of a strange one, Beveridge brought up basically moving the value to next year and Twomey said they need the points but no one ever discussed Flanders leaving and the impact that would have. Plus, the teams Twomey brought up were basically anyone with a first round pick but I dont see how any of the teams at or around their 1st pick are going to go for it that hard.

I'm probably just trying to cope on us having no chancee getting that pick despite my earlier posts but I dont think Cal addressed the possibilities very well. Would have liked better analysis on what result actually benefits GC more
 
hahaha. I feel like the new Salim (RIP).

reading on here about paying a mill a year to get back Naughton who is great but has issues kicking straight because Treacy possibly won't kick 30-40 goals per year, when we could have got JVR for 'free' (for Ras anyway) who is in his second year and is already kicking at 1.5 goals per year. Seriously laughable and so standard Dockers mentality. Doing what everyone tells us to do "cause draft rankings..blah blah blah...bs" rather than what is best for us. Sheep never lead. Should have been called the Fremantle Sheep Ships.
 
hahaha. I feel like the new Salim (RIP).

reading on here about paying a mill a year to get back Naughton who is great but has issues kicking straight because Treacy possibly won't kick 30-40 goals per year, when we could have got JVR for 'free' (for Ras anyway) who is in his second year and is already kicking at 1.5 goals per year. Seriously laughable and so standard Dockers mentality. Doing what everyone tells us to do "cause draft rankings..blah blah blah...bs" rather than what is best for us. Sheep never lead. Should have been called the Fremantle Sheep Ships.
I'm not sure if I'm mis-understanding but I'm not sure about attributing BF chat to Freo list team. I seriously doubt they care what other people say they should do and do what they think is best. In fact, given how much the fans and media lamented us not having a forwardline, I'd argue there's lots of evidence they don't give a shit what people think they should do
 
Yeah I watched that yesterday. It was a bit of a strange one, Beveridge brought up basically moving the value to next year and Twomey said they need the points but no one ever discussed Flanders leaving and the impact that would have. Plus, the teams Twomey brought up were basically anyone with a first round pick but I dont see how any of the teams at or around their 1st pick are going to go for it that hard.

I'm probably just trying to cope on us having no chancee getting that pick despite my earlier posts but I dont think Cal addressed the possibilities very well. Would have liked better analysis on what result actually benefits GC more
Well Twomey generally doesn't have much insight into what we're doing so I guess it makes sense why he didn't mention us for that pick.

At the very least we would be having conversations with the Suns for that pick, surely.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Outside of something beyond dumb like offering our future first and entire draft hand for this year we're not getting close to Gold Coast's first.

It's not that Twomey knows nothing about us - we aren't in the picture.

The Western Bulldogs' first rounders would be far more realistic targets for us imo.

As would Hawthorn who might pay quite a bit to get a second pick ahead of their current pick #30 to get some more early talent prior to matching their father son bid - assuming McCabe isn't a first round pick.
 
Aren't we supposedly attracting non-WA guys or some **** now? Wonder who they were referring to?

Dylan Stephens would make sense if Henry is leaving. Swans wings are good enough that he could be decent and still not get a game but I admit I can't remember watching him for a while.
 
Aren't we supposedly attracting non-WA guys or some **** now? Wonder who they were referring to?

Dylan Stephens would make sense if Henry is leaving. Swans wings are good enough that he could be decent and still not get a game but I admit I can't remember watching him for a while.
Think this season well and truly ****ed that for us
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

I don't think that's a given.

If the Lions can convince Neale after being dog**** for a decade and one season with 5 wins at 90% I can't see how that's more appealing than what we've got.
Still one of the most bizarre moves in my mind. Goes to a state he has no family connection too, to play for a team that had been even more garbage then us under a coach who hadn't really done anything yet.

Massive gamble that paid off for Lachie.
 
Still one of the most bizarre moves in my mind. Goes to a state he has no family connection too, to play for a team that had been even more garbage then us under a coach who hadn't really done anything yet.

Massive gamble that paid off for Lachie.
I'd argue that it hasn't paid off yet.
 
I'd argue that it hasn't paid off yet.
Yeah fair, a flag would mean it would have truly paid off.

Would love nothing more then to see us win a flag before he retires and Lachie ends up flagless.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top