List Mgmt. 2023 List Management thread

[Snuffaluphagus]

Mod notice after Mr Bob did a lot of annoying work in moving days of posts out of here. As we are heading into offseason, this thread is for 2023 list management only. Getting upset on previous trades can be taken to the vent thread. Lets keep this thread on track in the part of the year it's actually relevant

 

[Hazelsnuts]

Love your optimism on Henry but he’s already got one foot out the door.

Woof?

 

[Joao]

Sharp (or similar) is a no brainer if Henry leaves. We've seen with Brodie that there is a chance a bloke in their 2s can be AFL standard.

Williams and Stanley look promising long term but neither get much of the ball yet so probably a bit to work on.

 

[Polo342]

If the big name was Mcdonald then im all for it. If Darcy did decide to leave next year then Jackson would go to the ruck and you would be left with Amiss, Mcdonald and Treacy as the key targets. Not bad

 

[Cobbler]

In Twomey's top25 latest, not a single winger... Means the best winger may fall to our pick?

On SM-A205YN using BigFooty.com mobile app

Also means the best winger is shite!

 

[Vimal Anand]

Also means the best winger is shite!

Caleb windsor and joel freijah are the ones in the top 40 but not in top 25

On SM-A205YN using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Ysaye]

In Twomey's top25 latest, not a single winger... Means the best winger may fall to our pick?

On SM-A205YN using BigFooty.com mobile app

Riley Hardeman (at 18) will likely be a wingman at afl level.

 

[s_wd6]

Can’t see a single reason why we should play Henry for these last two games. Won’t affect his value. Which btw we should demand Brisbanes first or let him walk. We don’t owe him anything. If we’re not gonna get a decent pick from him we should just throw him back in the draft for anyone to take.

 

[Polo342]

Can’t see a single reason why we should play Henry for these last two games. Won’t affect his value. Which btw we should demand Brisbanes first or let him walk. We don’t owe him anything. If we’re not gonna get a decent pick from him we should just throw him back in the draft for anyone to take.

Absolutely agree with this!! Take a stand if they dont wanna pay up.

 

[Purple Suit]

If the big name was Mcdonald then im all for it. If Darcy did decide to leave next year then Jackson would go to the ruck and you would be left with Amiss, Mcdonald and Treacy as the key targets. Not bad

I see two problems with McDonald. He’s too similar to Amiss in that he’s a F50 forward who kicks goals and not much else. With our setup & Amiss, not sure we need him, need a forward to bring our smalls into it.

Sydney really need him, therefore it’s going to be hard to pry him away without paying too much for a slight upgrade on Treacy.

 

[Purple Suit]

Can’t see a single reason why we should play Henry for these last two games. Won’t affect his value. Which btw we should demand Brisbanes first or let him walk. We don’t owe him anything. If we’re not gonna get a decent pick from him we should just throw him back in the draft for anyone to take.

Why do you think he has decided to leave? He will 100% leave if we drop him for jumping at shadows and being petty.

 

[s_wd6]

Why do you think he has decided to leave? He will 100% leave if we drop him for jumping at shadows and being petty.

Because there’s two weeks left in the season and he hasn’t signed. Because every interview he’s given he’s extremely non committal and either somewhat justifies why he wants to leave (But I was dropped to Peel in the middle of the year so yeah…) or stumbles over he words to the point where he inadvertently tells everyone that he can’t wait till the trade request is made public. Because he already requested a trade last year and has probably had his mind set on Melbourne for two years now. Because JL and Bell have declared that the ball is in his court and the fact that he hasn’t signed means he’s probably going to request a trade (which they’re not going to outwardly say).

They need to sit down with him this week and get a definite answer from him-he’s not going to change his mind in two weeks.

 

[Dayts]

Can’t see a single reason why we should play Henry for these last two games. Won’t affect his value. Which btw we should demand Brisbanes first or let him walk. We don’t owe him anything. If we’re not gonna get a decent pick from him we should just throw him back in the draft for anyone to take.

Also to take out the injury risk.
He blow a knee out now gonna kill us and him in deal negotiations

 

[Dayts]

I see two problems with McDonald. He’s too similar to Amiss in that he’s a F50 forward who kicks goals and not much else. With our setup & Amiss, not sure we need him, need a forward to bring our smalls into it.

Sydney really need him, therefore it’s going to be hard to pry him away without paying too much for a slight upgrade on Treacy.

Not if they’ve got Naughton in the 50

 

[Purple Suit]

Because there’s two weeks left in the season and he hasn’t signed. Because every interview he’s given he’s extremely non committal and either somewhat justifies why he wants to leave (But I was dropped to Peel in the middle of the year so yeah…) or stumbles over he words to the point where he inadvertently tells everyone that he can’t wait till the trade request is made public. Because he already requested a trade last year and has probably had his mind set on Melbourne for two years now. Because JL and Bell have declared that the ball is in his court and the fact that he hasn’t signed means he’s probably going to request a trade (which they’re not going to outwardly say).

They need to sit down with him this week and get a definite answer from him-he’s not going to change his mind in two weeks.

Non committal because maybe he’s still deciding and all the offers / info are not in yet?

Pav signed long contracts at the end of the season a few times, yet you would have dropped him.

 

[pK75]

Not if they’ve got Naughton in the 50

He’s not exactly a big fish if he’s being pushed out of their B22 by an actual big fish

 

[s_wd6]

Non committal because maybe he’s still deciding and all the offers / info are not in yet?

Pav signed long contracts at the end of the season a few times, yet you would have dropped him.

Pav, the greatest player to ever play for this club, is not on the same level as Liam Henry, who has played about 10 good games in 4 years here.

 

[freo_leo29]

Logan McDonald and Josh Treacy AFL Stats Comparison

Logan McDonald and Josh Treacy AFL Stats Comparison.

www.footywire.com

If Treacy wasn’t required to ruck, I think he would have made up the goal difference between them.

You reckon that Treacy kicks more than double his goals because he doesn't spend 20% time in the ruck over about 5 or 6 games?


Fat chance

 

[Sweetback]

How much of the Henry palaver is due to Colin Young’s TV show wanting to draw out the drama?

 

[pK75]

Pav, the greatest player to ever play for this club, is not on the same level as Liam Henry, who has played about 10 good games in 4 years here.

Pav also had the media bit sorted, with line like, “I bleed purple” “fully invested in the club” and “just want to concentrate on playing my best football and the contract will sort itself out”
The fact Henry was so nervous in his response is the sign he has something to hide. Like he’s already gone but can’t tell anyone yet.

 

[pK75]

You reckon that Treacy kicks more than double his goals because he doesn't spend 20% time in the ruck over about 5 or 6 games?


Fat chance

Going from 0.9 to 1.6 is not “more than double” it is a big jump though.

 

[freo_leo29]

Going from 0.9 to 1.6 is not “more than double” it is a big jump though.

13 to 28 is more than double

 

[pK75]

13 to 28 is more than double

Logan has played more games. Their averages are 0.9 vs 1.6

 

[freo_leo29]

Logan has played more games. Their averages are 0.9 vs 1.6

I replied to a post saying that he would make up the "goal difference"

it's a 15 goal difference

 

[Purple Suit]

Pav, the greatest player to ever play for this club, is not on the same level as Liam Henry, who has played about 10 good games in 4 years here.

So we need to pick and choose who we show respect to and who we chuck the toys out of the cot for?

 

[Tonga Bob]

You know what list needs managing?

The 2023 AFLW Buddy list!

Draft nominations are now open, get around it.

Women's Footy - AFLW Buddy Draft 2023

Well folks the dubs season is finally almost upon us, so it's time to assign some posters to some players and have us a good old fashioned Buddy Draft! Usual format applies: Reply in this thread if you wanna get involved, listing your top three (3) choices for your 2023 buddy, I will fire up...

www.bigfooty.com