Remove this Banner Ad

List Mgmt. 2023 List Management thread

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Status
Not open for further replies.
Mod notice after Mr Bob did a lot of annoying work in moving days of posts out of here. As we are heading into offseason, this thread is for 2023 list management only. Getting upset on previous trades can be taken to the vent thread. Lets keep this thread on track in the part of the year it's actually relevant
 
Last edited:
Worst case is actually pick 19 (obviously, that's a good result overall) but even a decent finals run means we have pick 12+ (before any bids).
I think matching bids is so easy that realistically we are matching anything that doesn’t give a top 10 pick
 
I think matching bids is so easy that realistically we are matching anything that doesn’t give a top 10 pick

That's the thing here.

But I'd like to trade him this year of he's asked to go.

One of those top 3 picks, plus plus is doable
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Roos board thought pick #1 was enough for Brayshaw end of last year with the MVP, B&F win and about three years contracted.

If North will pay Sean Darcy $1,500,000 a year for seven years then good luck to them, he has to take that deal and they have to get it done. Fremantle aren't required to make that easy and should start at #2, #3 and future first knowing it will have them spit their coffee out - but it's also the biggest deal in the league while under contract.
 
I think matching bids is so easy that realistically we are matching anything that doesn’t give a top 10 pick
Even if it's North? They have no good players, surely we can't go with them?

The idea of Kangaroos

2, and the two future picks should be fine. Or 2 and Zurhaar

No to Zurhaar. We obviously had limited interest before for a reason and now we have Emmett.
 
That's the thing here.

But I'd like to trade him this year of he's asked to go.

One of those top 3 picks, plus plus is doable
You and me are the same, I was more concerned about Cox because we can’t replace him. At least we can replace Darcy to a degree and I know given Senior staff jobs are on the line next year, it’s taking some ungodly deal to get Darcy
 
Even if it's North? They have no good players, surely we can't go with them?



No to Zurhaar. We obviously had limited interest before for a reason and now we have Emmett.
Until someone proves me otherwise, there is no restrictions on when payments are made, only that you have to match total payments and years which means you just say you’ll pay him $6m one season down the track. RFA is simply to stop bad teams getting ****ed and help players to make a lot of money.
 
My thoughts are similar to Carnthedockers and DragoDelph
Barrett is an absolute cum stain but he’s still the most senior journo in the business pretty much.
He doesn’t need to make s**t up at this stage of his career. Why would he? There is clearly some smoke behind it.
For me, we should simply not trade him unless there’s a godfather offer this off season. We are talking a monstrous trade price to consider it.
I personally value the extra season of footy we will get from Darcy next year if we hold him to contract. We will still get a top 10 pick next year as a FA, worst case scenario.
I’d literally want Aaron Naughton or Sam Taylor in the door instead of him if he leaves.
No to Naughton. What is the main lesson we have learnt this finals series? Inaccurate teams get punished.

Taylor is a player I want but he can't play in the same backline as Pearce. Replacing Pearce with Taylor is a no brainer but not necessarily good for culture. Young's contract ends in 2025 which is when I would give Pearce the punt.
 
Last edited:

Remove this Banner Ad

I maintain that we should wait until they get pick #1 from WC, then trade pick #1 involved for Darcy, take Curtin with it.

#2 and #19 for #1 from WCE
then
#1 ++ for Darcy, we take Curtin at #1.
You would take Curtin ahead of Duursma? Our backline is stacked and idk if he offers anything our midfield doesn't already have.
 
Losing Darcy to north would make me vomit. Don’t give a shit about pick 2.
They are just about the biggest laughing stock in AFL history yet they still are able to come over here and make weak little freo their bitch feeder club?
**** no.
 
No to Naughton. What is the main lesson we have learnt this finals series? Inaccurate teams get punished.

Young is a player I want but he can't play in the same backline as Pearce. Replacing Pearce with Young is a no brainer but not necessarily good for culture. Young's contract ends in 2025 which is when I would give Pearce the punt.
Young?? We already have him I’m confused
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

If we trade Darcy to North I'd want Bailey Scott and a high pick. Scott would be excellent on the wing, ready to go and upside.
 
My thoughts are similar to Carnthedockers and DragoDelph
Barrett is an absolute cum stain but he’s still the most senior journo in the business pretty much.
He doesn’t need to make s**t up at this stage of his career. Why would he? There is clearly some smoke behind it.
For me, we should simply not trade him unless there’s a godfather offer this off season. We are talking a monstrous trade price to consider it.
I personally value the extra season of footy we will get from Darcy next year if we hold him to contract. We will still get a top 10 pick next year as a FA, worst case scenario.
I’d literally want Aaron Naughton or Sam Taylor in the door instead of him if he leaves.
He's not making anything up, he's just saying he's keen to see what happens. If that means Darcy signing a 3 year deal by this afternoon then he still said the truth. Clicks are the key so he wants Freo fans to click on it.

Journos, Politicians and Big Footy posters are masters of not lying while stirring shit.
 
Darcy is close with Dogga, Wags, I think shoota


Come to think of it, quite a few of Darcy's mates have left

Shootas mates have left too fwiw
Yeah getting rid of Acres, Tucker, Griff, and Lobb in one season. All good mates with Shoota and Darcy too. Suddenly a much bigger lure to vic than there would have been previously.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top