Opinion 2023 Player X vs Y vs Z

[Northernsoul74]

Merrett vs Steele vs Neale vs Butters? (feel like Butters may be a bit over priced)

Merrett.

 

[pieman123]

Brayshaw and Dale or Steele and Siciliy?

 

[BOMBERBLITZ]

Brayshaw and Dale or Steele and Siciliy?

Steele and Siciliy

 

[duckey]

McKenna > Humphrey or Dale (roughie), or just save the trade because this round is cooked for me anyway

 

[SC fish]

McKenna > Humphrey or Dale (roughie), or just save the trade because this round is cooked for me anyway

Just seen this what did you end up doing?

 

[duckey]

Just seen this what did you end up doing?

Was going to hold but round and season is toast so went the bear last minute for some fun

 

[SC fish]

Was going to hold but round and season is toast so went the bear last minute for some fun

Going good so far

 

[evo]

I thought he looked pretty good this week. At least in the first half.

 

[stevebbb]

Next week:
Neale vs Brayshaw vs Warner

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Next week:
Neale vs Brayshaw vs Warner

I think a lot of us will have this choice, tbh I don't love any of them but currently thinking Neale.

 

[jdwood]

Next week:
Neale vs Brayshaw vs Warner

I have Brayshaw and will be getting Neale.

Brayshaw has been a good pick up (particularly when the alternative was Mills a few weeks ago) - seems fit again and clearly being helped by Freo's better run of form.

Toss of the coin between those two. Neale probably higher ceiling but Brayshaw less of a tag risk.

 

[evo]

I need one more mid who plays R15 and preferably R14 who is a genuine premo to end of season

Brayshaw v Serong v Anderson

Or any other suggestions under 590k (already have Laird, Zerret)

 

[PoopingHindi]

I need one more mid who plays R15 and preferably R14 who is a genuine premo to end of season

Brayshaw v Serong v Anderson

Or any other suggestions under 590k (already have Laird, Zerret)

already rules out Anderson.
maybe add in Neale and draw a name from a hat.

 

[evo]

already rules out Anderson.
maybe add in Neale and draw a name from a hat.

Should ve mentioned I have Neale. So guess its Serong v Brayshaw. Its quite hard to split. If i go Brayshaw i can get him next week, but for Serong i have to wait a week longer

 

[THECHIEFTON]

I need one more mid who plays R15 and preferably R14 who is a genuine premo to end of season

Brayshaw v Serong v Anderson

Or any other suggestions under 590k (already have Laird, Zerret)

Can't quite afford Rowell?

Wish I started the Kent this year. Started him last year.

 

[evo]

Can't quite afford Rowell?

Wish I started the Kent this year. Started him last year.

I could probably find a way to get him, but not super keen to be honest. I kinda like Anderson better for 40k or so less

 

[Wellsy35]

Unsure on Brayshaw or Serong next week.

Brayshaw’s cheaper, looks back and has a better history, but Serong has been unreal this year. 9/11 tons, with 4 of those 130+. If you take out DPP mids like Dawson, Dunks and the Butcher, Serong is currently 3rd in the comp for points scored and 5th for average.

 

[Northernsoul74]

Should ve mentioned I have Neale. So guess its Serong v Brayshaw. Its quite hard to split. If i go Brayshaw i can get him next week, but for Serong i have to wait a week longer

Serong for me.

 

[Wellsy35]

Serong for me.

Any reasoning?

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Should ve mentioned I have Neale. So guess its Serong v Brayshaw. Its quite hard to split. If i go Brayshaw i can get him next week, but for Serong i have to wait a week longer

Brayshaw evo ....he's ready to fly

 

[Northernsoul74]

Any reasoning?

Very consistent due to him having a well suited SuperCoach game. Signs were there last year. Doesn’t seem the type to attract a tag.
In saying that I noticed he dipped under 100 last week. Not sure there’s an obvious reason for that. Surely can’t be a Fyfe impact.

 

[evo]

Very consistent due to him having a well suited SuperCoach game. Signs were there last year. Doesn’t seem the type to attract a tag.
In saying that I noticed he dipped under 100 last week. Not sure there’s an obvious reason for that. Surely can’t be a Fyfe impact.

Maybe Hodor out may reduce his clearance ratethe next few weeks?

I m thinking Brayshaw may be a bit better given he doesnt rely so much on clearances for score.

 

[Wellsy35]

Maybe Hodor out may reduce his clearance ratethe next few weeks?

I m thinking Brayshaw may be a bit better given he doesnt rely so much on clearances for score.

 

[Wellsy35]

evo says Brayshaw, Northernsoul74 says Serong…

Quick, which one of you is higher ranked?

 

[rocker_oz33]

evo says Brayshaw, Northernsoul74 says Serong…

Quick, which one of you is higher ranked?

That's only a guide.

Ala serong going at 115.
You want him to keep that up in your team.

Bray could go 120 from here.

Go with ya guts...