Opinion 2023 Player X vs Y vs Z

[Corkintheocean]

I like all 4 of those picks but Doch and Green just

Agree.

 

[JDWCE]

Bont v Petracca v Kelly

I'm leaning Bont. Safest role, most durable. Doesn't have the ceiling of the other two however.

Yeah that’s the way I’d lean too. Kelly is risky for mine. I rate petracca as a pick thought. Take out that patch where he was sick last year and he goes 108 which is top 8 mid material. Talk of more forward time is a worry though

 

[amazingjoshy]

Cats fans...

If you had to keep one in a keeper league...Parfitt vs Holmes?

 

[tigs2010]

Cats fans...

If you had to keep one in a keeper league...Parfitt vs Holmes?

Not a cat fan but surely Holmes is the one the Cats will play every week

 

[JDWCE]

Cats fans...

If you had to keep one in a keeper league...Parfitt vs Holmes?

Holmes no contest

 

[Shadow89]

Cats fans...

If you had to keep one in a keeper league...Parfitt vs Holmes?

What the others have said - Holmes with an absolute bullet. Guy will play all 22 games this year, and is one of the motivating factors behind our push for back to back.

Parf on the other hand, has fallen back in the pecking order. Should play a lot of games, but won't have the same role certainty/scoring power that someone like Holmesy will have.

JS, role security, and higher scoring on Holmes' side. No contest at all.

 

[Decimation]

Cunnington (668k)



V

Sheed (591k)

 

[tigs2010]

Brayshaw, Bailey Smith

3

Bailey Smith

Age

25

Ht

185cm

Wt

86kg

Pos.

M/F

Career

Season

Last 5

D

18.3

5star

K

8.5

3star

HB

9.8

5star

M

2.3

2star

T

3.8

5star

CL

2.7

4star

D

19.8

5star

K

9.6

4star

HB

10.2

5star

M

1.8

2star

T

3.2

4star

CL

3.2

4star

D

14.8

4star

K

7.6

3star

HB

7.2

5star

M

2.0

3star

T

3.4

5star

CL

1.6

4star

, Sheed
Docherty, Steele, Worpel/Bruhn

The top end of the second one looks so much better but Worpel lol

 

[Mezzoculo]

Hot taek incoming...

From a fantasy perspective, Worpel's messy leather poisoning at sub $500k is more interesting to me than Sheed's perceived role at plus $500k. This isn't SuperCoach so weight of numbers beats impact every day of the week.

 

[tigs2010]

Hot taek incoming...

From a fantasy perspective, Worpel's messy leather poisoning at sub $500k is more interesting to me than Sheed's perceived role at plus $500k. This isn't SuperCoach so weight of numbers beats impact every day of the week.

Yes until lack of impact gets the campaigner dropped in round 3

 

[Zevon]

Hot taek incoming...

From a fantasy perspective, Worpel's messy leather poisoning at sub $500k is more interesting to me than Sheed's perceived role at plus $500k. This isn't SuperCoach so weight of numbers beats impact every day of the week.

I agree, my worry is just that his sloppyness sees Mitchell dump him either out of the side or in some graveyard position like HFF.

Edit - that sly campaigner tigs2010 beat me to it. Shut up tigs, I’m trying to sound intelligent here

 

[tigs2010]

I agree, my worry is just that his sloppyness sees Mitchell dump him either out of the side or in some graveyard position like HFF.

Edit - that sly campaigner tigs2010 beat me to it. Shut up tigs, I’m trying to sound intelligent here

You’ve copied what I’ve said. Obviously not trying that hard

 

[Mezzoculo]

tigs2010 Zevon Oh, I agree that Worps is a risk for that exact reason. But I'd argue that the risk difference between he and Sheed is not that great IF Worps keeps up his output and Sheed continues to 'build in' to the season.

Tonight will be an interesting watch.

 

[tigs2010]

tigs2010 Zevon Oh, I agree that Worps is a risk for that exact reason. But I'd argue that the risk difference between he and Sheed is not that great IF Worps keeps up his output and Sheed continues to 'build in' to the season.

Tonight will be an interesting watch.

Ultimately I can do a lot of good things with the cash which will probably be the decider.

 

[amazingjoshy]

What the others have said - Holmes with an absolute bullet. Guy will play all 22 games this year, and is one of the motivating factors behind our push for back to back.



Parf on the other hand, has fallen back in the pecking order. Should play a lot of games, but won't have the same role certainty/scoring power that someone like Holmesy will have.



JS, role security, and higher scoring on Holmes' side. No contest at all.

Just on this, was Holmes injured last night? Wasn't all that impressive the bit I saw, is it a case of good player in a good team but goes missing when the team struggles?

Also why does Parfitt get so little gametime? Can score when he's on.

It's one of those 2 or Naughton for my last keeper (very deep league) strongly swinging towards Naughton at this stage

 

[Shadow89]

Just on this, was Holmes injured last night? Wasn't all that impressive the bit I saw, is it a case of good player in a good team but goes missing when the team struggles?

Also why does Parfitt get so little gametime? Can score when he's on.

It's one of those 2 or Naughton for my last keeper (very deep league) strongly swinging towards Naughton at this stage

Nah, but played more on a wing at times to give others inside minutes.

We got demolished last night given all our outs - literally missing all of Hawkins, J. Cameron, Blicavs, Duncan, I. Smith, Menegola, J. Henry and Bowes - a 3rd of our side.

No player would perform overly well with over a third of the team missing, but I still think he went pretty well for most of the night - all things considering

 

[Zevon]

tigs2010 Zevon Oh, I agree that Worps is a risk for that exact reason. But I'd argue that the risk difference between he and Sheed is not that great IF Worps keeps up his output and Sheed continues to 'build in' to the season.

Tonight will be an interesting watch.

Ultimately I can do a lot of good things with the cash which will probably be the decider.

I’m tempted to go the other way and put some money on top of Sheed to get to Ward, but it’s going to be a big risk if every man and his dog owns Worpel and he does end up matching/exceeding Ward’s output for nearly 200 grand cheaper

 

[amazingjoshy]

tigs2010 Zevon Oh, I agree that Worps is a risk for that exact reason. But I'd argue that the risk difference between he and Sheed is not that great IF Worps keeps up his output and Sheed continues to 'build in' to the season.

Tonight will be an interesting watch.

Im strongly considering going with 2 in the 400-600k range tbh

Sheed
Worpel
Duursma
Bruhn
Callaghan

Enough options there to flick over to the best of them in the first round or 2 if one sucks, or absolute worst case it's one down, one up. Current team has Sheed and Duursma.

 

[tigs2010]

Im strongly considering going with 2 in the 400-600k range tbh

Sheed
Worpel
Duursma
Bruhn
Callaghan

Enough options there to flick over to the best of them in the first round or 2 if one sucks, or absolute worst case it's one down, one up. Current team has Sheed and Duursma.

Is Callaghan injured? Would love him to come out and dominate so I can get rid of that Worpel potato lol

 

[Corby_4]

Constable v McKenna v Hunt

They all feel yuck but which one will be the least yuck?
Finding 160k to get to Day is too hard.

 

[tigs2010]

Constable v McKenna v Hunt

They all feel yuck but which one will be the least yuck?
Finding 160k to get to Day is too hard.

I’d say not McKenna and a watch on Hunt tonight with Constable in front currently

 

[Tex Danger]

Callaghan v McLean

The ultimate “never on my radar before PS” vs “locked since day 1” battle

Can throw Worpel into that mix actually as I can have 2 of the 3 on current structure

 

[amazingjoshy]

Callaghan v McLean

The ultimate “never on my radar before PS” vs “locked since day 1” battle

Can throw Worpel into that mix actually as I can have 2 of the 3 on current structure

As someone also on McLean all PS....

Pros for Callaghan:
Junior fantasy chops
Not coming off injury
Great role
Selby a fan
Not coached by Bevo

 

[Tex Danger]

As someone also on McLean all PS....

Pros for Callaghan:
Junior fantasy chops
Not coming off injury
Great role
Selby a fan
Not coached by Bevo

Shelby guide not that hot on Finn. Not this year at least.

Will be interesting to see his take after the weekend

 

[amazingjoshy]

Shelby guide not that hot on Finn. Not this year at least.

Will be interesting to see his take after the weekend

Meant more in relation to McLean who he's said pretty much all PS on his pods that he's not a fan of him as a pico despite him being so popular