Opinion 2023 Player X vs Y vs Z

[Mezzoculo]

Stuck on one last call for the timebeing

Josh Kelly and Sam Flanders (currently this)
or
Bailey Smith and Tanner Bruhn

Could you use the extra cash from a Jelly and Bruhn combo elsewhere?

 

[happy_eagle]

Could you use the extra cash from a Jelly and Bruhn combo elsewhere?

Could go Gulden up to Green, or wait and see what the rookie situation is like

 

[davosowl]

Could go Gulden up to Green, or wait and see what the rookie situation is like

I'm not sure that Gulden to Green is actually an upgrade, especially if you're thinking season-long.

If you were keen on Green, I'd be more inclined to bundle Day and Flanders (or McLean if you have money in the bank) into Green and a rookie.

 

[DynamiteDons]

Macrae, LDU and Daicos
Bont, Anderson and McGrath

 

[matty lloyd the champ]

Stuck on one last call for the timebeing

Josh Kelly and Sam Flanders (currently this)
or
Bailey Smith and Tanner Bruhn

I'd go Josh Kelly over Bailey Smith but I can't split Bruhn and Flanders.

If Kelly plays bulk of his time as a centre bounce mid, I reckon he gets his average up to 107+. With Taranto and Hopper gone, who else are they going to rotate into the mids?

Bailey Smith will be right up there provided his TOG is as high as it was for the first half of the season. Up until the Geelong headbutt game, his average TOG was in the mid 90's which was ridiculous for a midfielder. For some reason, it plummeted from there and he was getting low 80%'s for the rest of the season.

With Bruhn, I don't see Bruhn as a natural accumulator and worry about his job security and role in the team. He is easily one player that can be shifted to a flank for a whole game without much thought.

Flanders, I'm gonna be honest, I couldn't tell him apart from a bar of soap. I see he averaged sub 50 last season so I genuinely have no idea why people are picking him at his price.

 

[sante]

Macrae, LDU and Daicos
Bont, Anderson and McGrath

First one. I want Anderson so bad though but he was underwhelming in the pre season.

 

[RowellAnderson12]

First one. I want Anderson so bad though but he was underwhelming in the pre season.

He wasn't trying

 

[samFFC]

LDU v Cerra? I’ve had LDU locked in since day one but fighting to find an extra 30k somewhere.

Now I’m attached to LDU but looking at it purely numbers based, what do they both ave?

LDU easy

Cogs and Dawson v Andrew Brayshaw and Daicos ?

Bray and Daicos. Bray clearly over Cogs, and is C option.
Dawson and Daicos probably similar.

Stuck on one last call for the timebeing

Josh Kelly and Sam Flanders (currently this)
or
Bailey Smith and Tanner Bruhn

Not keen on Flanders or Bruhn. Probably former.

Macrae, LDU and Daicos
Bont, Anderson and McGrath

Very tough. Probably the 2nd but very similar both really.

 

[Chris99]

Last min scrambling

Dawson & LDU

vs

McGrath & Brayshaw

 

[BigVic]

Dawson + Merrett
Stewart + Andy Brayshaw

 

[happy_eagle]

Dawson + Merrett
Stewart + Andy Brayshaw

First one. Reckon the gap between Merett (110) and Brayshaw (115) will be smaller than the gap between Stewart (95) and Dawson (105)

 

[DesMan94]

Thoughts on Bruhn vs Flanders vs McClean? Why have people jumped off McClean?

 

[Shaunn]

So many changes urhhh.

Laird and Sheed
or
Bont and T Green|

I feel Laird and Sheed should have more points combined and Laird for the (c) makes it nice also.

 

[tigs2010]

So many changes urhhh.

Laird and Sheed
or
Bont and T Green|

I feel Laird and Sheed should have more points combined and Laird for the (c) makes it nice also.

Tough one. If you're going first one hopefully Sheed gets a boost with no Yeo.

 

[tigs2010]

Laird & Day v LDU & Cumming.

 

[Barnzy]

Laird & Day v LDU & Cumming.

This is very similar to my vs question so hard one.

Comes down to how much you trust Day. I don't trust him. His fantasy form line is poor and we're all hoping he breakouts off the back of a midfield role we haven't really seen in action. One preseason game with a score of 70ish.

I would go LDU and Cumming. I also think their best outcomes are higher overall. Cumming 100 and LDU 105+. Laird best outcome will be 120 again and don't see Day pushing past a 75-80

 

[tigs2010]

This is very similar to my vs question so hard one.

Comes down to how much you trust Day. I don't trust him. His fantasy form line is poor and we're all hoping he breakouts off the back of a midfield role we haven't really seen in action. One preseason game with a score of 70ish.

I would go LDU and Cumming. I also think their best outcomes are higher overall. Cumming 100 and LDU 105+. Laird best outcome will be 120 again and don't see Day pushing past a 75-80

That's the way I'm leaning. Both should make money too as opposed to Laird is going to lose it. I already have Oliver, Crae, Jelly in the mids but the backline is just ass.

 

[tigs2010]

My last vs question is Callaghan v McLean?

Callaghan means fielding Pou, McLean means I can field one of Phillips/Hollands.

 

[RowellAnderson12]

Laird & Day v LDU & Cumming.

i have the latter, do you have a solid captain option with option 2?

 

[RowellAnderson12]

My last vs question is Callaghan v McLean?

Callaghan means fielding Pou, McLean means I can field one of Phillips/Hollands.

Prob best to field Sheezel only.

 

[tigs2010]

i have the latter, do you have a solid captain option with option 2?

I’ll have Doc, Dunks, Oliver, Crae and Jelly which I think is more than enough. Last 2 a wait and see before I’d trust them.

 

[RowellAnderson12]

I’ll have Doc, Dunks, Oliver, Crae and Jelly which I think is more than enough. Last 2 a wait and see before I’d trust them.

Should be fine

 

[tigs2010]

Should be fine

Famous last words

 

[RowellAnderson12]

Famous last words

Well both our teams will sink

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Should be fine

Uh Huh ......