Trades 2023 Round 2 Trades

[RoughysMullet]

Thinking the following:

Jelly > Warner
Cunnington > JHF
Wilmot > McKenna

Thoughts?

Only trade Jelly if injured
Cunnington to JHF can probably wait another week - need more evidence
Give wilmont another week unless dropped - young player against a good side in Adelaide - will be better at home

 

[Scythe]

Thinking the following:

Jelly > Warner
Cunnington > JHF
Wilmot > McKenna

Thoughts?

Why Wilmot?

Yeah, I wouldn't trade up to a rookie that's not on the bubble. Wilmot was decent enough - will play this week with Coleman out for sure. Get another look next week and then re-evaluate. I'm also not sold on Warner being a top-10 mid, played a pretty rubbish GC outfit, and his DE% holds him back.

Feel like if you're gonna trade Jelly sideways, there's more value in bringing in Coniglio as a guaranteed forward keeper, or maybe Daicos as a value pick down back who looks like he should definitely be a keeper (generate some cash from that move too). Obviously you might have both of those players, but that's the line of thinking that I'd go with.

 

[Better Loosen Up]

Only trade Jelly if injured
Cunnington to JHF can probably wait another week
Give wilmont another week unless dropped - young player against a good side in Adelaide - will be better at home

How many trades do you think i'm doing next week?

I still need to deal with Jones and I'm looking at possibly bringing in Chandler if he backs it up next week.

 

[Scythe]

Stewart prob the only trade
Mighty tempting to rage trade Fyfe to JHF though

If it helps, I give you permission to make that Fyfe trade. He's beyond cooked, get him out of your side ASAP.

 

[Better Loosen Up]

Yeah, I wouldn't trade up to a rookie that's not on the bubble. Wilmot was decent enough - will play this week with Coleman out for sure. Get another look next week and then re-evaluate. I'm also not sold on Warner being a top-10 mid, played a pretty rubbish GC outfit, and his DE% holds him back.

Feel like if you're gonna trade Jelly sideways, there's more value in bringing in Coniglio as a guaranteed forward keeper, or maybe Daicos as a value pick down back who looks like he should definitely be a keeper (generate some cash from that move too). Obviously you might have both of those players, but that's the line of thinking that I'd go with.

I think you might be right... back to the drawing board

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

I don't see him holding his spot long term with players coming back where as I think McKenna is more likely to.

Who do they have coming back to take his spot? Surely trade Jones before Wilmot, his cash gen is dead. Wilmot will make money.

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Yeah, I wouldn't trade up to a rookie that's not on the bubble. Wilmot was decent enough - will play this week with Coleman out for sure. Get another look next week and then re-evaluate. I'm also not sold on Warner being a top-10 mid, played a pretty rubbish GC outfit, and his DE% holds him back.

Feel like if you're gonna trade Jelly sideways, there's more value in bringing in Coniglio as a guaranteed forward keeper, or maybe Daicos as a value pick down back who looks like he should definitely be a keeper (generate some cash from that move too). Obviously you might have both of those players, but that's the line of thinking that I'd go with.

Sydney have Hawthorn this week, big chance Warner gets the tag.

 

[Veer Right]

How many trades do you think i'm doing next week?

I still need to deal with Jones and I'm looking at possibly bringing in Chandler if he backs it up next week.

Trust your gut man. Your first two trades look great to me. I personally believe Warner will be the best player in the AFL in time. Jones to McKenna looks the better trade.

 

[kaiserchief13]

Early thoughts:

Whitfield -> Daicos
Laird -> LDU
F. Greene -> Callaghan

View attachment 1634546View attachment 1634545

That's a good looking team

 

[THECHIEFTON]

Do I give Jones 1 more week? Probably should. I might just field Constable and hope he can find a team mate or 2 this week.

 

[BFMC]

Best case: Hold Fire
Worst case:


Executed via Phillipou from mid bench to Fwd on field. Only leaves $3800 in bank for correction week, correction potentials are Chesser/Greene.

I fall firmly into the Fyfe could pull it back with the next few fixtures being in his favour camp. I could replace Fyfe in the outs with Hopper and have $22.2k in the bank, field Callaghan and Phillipou stays at M9.

Last nights melts have tempered somewhat when it was a case of how can I eject all of the 3 outs above + Hopper with only 3 trades. Im also still not sold

 

[TDS7]

Flanders, Hopper, Laird, Jelly on watch. I'll hold everyone for now, being reactionary has cost me in the past.

Day scored really poorly, even when he was getting plenty of the footy. What I saw was enough for me to hold for now, more pressing concerns around the ground and he got plenty of stoppage possessions that should end up as points.

Nothing R2 unless I get spooked out of Jelly.

There is a world where I go Jelly > JHF, Day > Daicos next week.

 

[kenneje]

Have major problems all across the park.

Stewart has to go.
Jones might have to go as well if he's injured?
Laird, what the **** happened? Hard tag? Injured?
Marshall was underwhelming and you can't take 80-90 scores when Witts is going 120+
Fyfe looked miserable. Surely they have to get him involved in the game more?

Rage trade could look something like;

Stewart + Jones + Laird
Redman (looked brilliant)/Ryan + Daicos + Green/Coniglio/Davies-Uniacke

Sensible trade could look something like;

Stewart + Jones
Redman/Ryan/Daicos + Horne-Francis (via dpp)

Any help appreciated!

 

[JyeDye]

Do I give Jones 1 more week? Probably should. I might just field Constable and hope he can find a team mate or 2 this week.

Jones cash gen is dead and that's what you picked him for, get rid of him.

 

[Gene Simmons]

Should I trade Flanders to Callaghan?

 

[SC fish]

Jones is apparently still likely to play is it worth keeping him for 1 more weekend especially against StKilda

I'm planning on keeping him

 

[Jiska]

I just look at people like Jords who have Jelly in their team instead. LOL!

Who?

Actually, if he has Jelly in his team, don't really care who that is, but it's great for the rest of us. Hopefully he sucked in 100,000 coaches.

 

[Jiska]

Is it worth holding Fyfe considering the next two games are against North & West Coast, both at Optus? Surely its a good opportunity to kick a few and score well.

Yeah. 'cause St Kilda is sooooooooooooo much better than North and West Coast.

 

[Petrify]

Laird, what the * happened? Hard tag? Injured?

Unless it was a hidden injury, neither, just didn't look interested and went head to head with Tom Greene who absolutely demolished him

 

[A Bit Dusty]

Do I give Jones 1 more week? Probably should. I might just field Constable and hope he can find a team mate or 2 this week.

He was on 5 when he got injured in the 2nd quarter I'm trading him down to McKenna

 

[TheMcManusNose]

Stewart to Daicos gives me 180k total for the boost and rookie corrections next week.

H.Clark (low TOG) and Cunnington watch.

I don't have fyfe but if I did i would have traded him as soon as it opens. Our forward line is dysfunctional and even if he played mid he's 5th in line now (I don't think he will).

Actually **** might trade chesser too the useless campaigner. Just on the vibe.

 

[Jiska]

Why are you thinking of moving jelly on?

 

[kenneje]

Unless it was a hidden injury, neither, just didn't look interested and went head to head with Tom Greene who absolutely demolished him

Oh good. Love that. Only cost $700,000

 

[Jiska]

Did you watch the match? Flanders stayed on the entire 4th quarter and got 40 points of pure junk when Sydney gave up. He was unsighted in the first 3 quarters. I think the preseason match was a flash in the pan. I think he'll be lucky to average 70. Sheezel could go 90 like Daicos did. I pocket $55k, which can be used for corrections in round 3.

Agreed.

And even if Flanders does some how decide to learn how to play football, Sneeze will average the same, if not better, make more money and give an immediate 55k cash injection.

Can't lose TBH.

Also, when's Bollox jumping on Sneeze?

 

[Hack_Watts]

Jones-Richards
Stewart-Daicos
Bruhn-Phillipou

Gives me 13 premos.

Who is the better prospect of Phillipou and Pedlar WaynesWorld19 ?