List Mgmt. 2023 Trade Thread - Part I

[George]

 

[Mowman]

He’s been mentioned a few times on here and people have scoffed at it as though he is a s**t kicker.

If he were on our list we’d be very excited about him. He’s a good player.

Mentioned him the other night
With Sinn injuries I would prefer Bergman

 

[bird_man]

Mentioned him the other night
With Sinn injuries I would prefer Bergman

Happy to wait and see how Sinn goes through the year. I think he will be a player with a bit of luck.

Bergman is underrated though. Also a local kid so suits our plan.

 

[gringo2011]

He’s been mentioned a few times on here and people have scoffed at it as though he is a s**t kicker.

If he were on our list we’d be very excited about him. He’s a good player.

It's the ceiling that you just can't judge without time. Nas is ideal for us because he's one of the few really clean kicking payers in the side. Bergs is that kind of hybrid forward/mid and probably like a bit of a Phillipou type. I didn't watch the Port game yesterday but his numbers at half time looked like he must be playing on the ball. He had about 15 possessions at that point.

There was talk that he wanted to get back to vic last year and Nas wanted home. I think we probably could have got some kind of deal done if we'd been brave enough to do a deal. After that performance it might be a straight swap instead of Bergs and a pick.

 

[gringo2011]

Happy to wait and see how Sinn goes through the year. I think he will be a player with a bit of luck.

Bergman is underrated though. Also a local kid so suits our plan.

The injuries are not looking good for Sinn, missed games in his draft year, lost last year and already had surgery this year and possibly carrying OP. As an explosive fast type that's not ideal. Jason Gram is the only player I can think of that spent years injured then became a resilient player.

 

[bird_man]

It's the ceiling that you just can't judge without time. Nas is ideal for us because he's one of the few really clean kicking payers in the side. Bergs is that kind of hybrid forward/mid and probably like a bit of a Phillipou type. I didn't watch the Port game yesterday but his numbers at half time looked like he must be playing on the ball. He had about 15 possessions at that point.

There was talk that he wanted to get back to vic last year and Nas wanted home. I think we probably could have got some kind of deal done if we'd been brave enough to do a deal. After that performance it might be a straight swap instead of Bergs and a pick.

Doubt we would have been able to ask for too much extra anyway.

Pretty sure Port rate him fairly highly. Taken around the same mark as Nas and has shown plenty at senior level

 

[SaintsSeptember]

The injuries are not looking good for Sinn, missed games in his draft year, lost last year and already had surgery this year and possibly carrying OP. As an explosive fast type that's not ideal. Jason Gram is the only player I can think of that spent years injured then became a resilient player.

When did Gram spend years injured?

 

[Sun Ra]

When did Gram spend years injured?

I think he meant Cripps.

 

[gringo2011]

When did Gram spend years injured?

Injured at Brissy and his first Saints seasons.

 

[XhazzafootyX]

Spewing Callaghan stayed. He looks unbelievable

 

[SaintsofSteel]

Mentioned him the other night
With Sinn injuries I would prefer Bergman

Absolutley, plus Bergman is more advanced and ready to plug and play. I also think Bergman is a bit more versatile in where he can play, Sinn is a very one sided player.

 

[XhazzafootyX]

Bergmans old man played saints reserves back in the day I believe

 

[sunny3193]

I’d be putting my money on: Tugg Speedman, Jeff Portnoy and Kirk Lazarus for our next premiership half forward line.
Thunder-ful!

 

[austinnn]

What do you think of Rachelle for Nas and a 2RDP?

 

[BrutThough]

What do you think of Rachelle for Nas and a 2RDP?

Adelaide wouldn't do that deal.

 

[Dr Spaceman]

What do you think of Rachelle for Nas and a 2RDP?

Adelaide wouldn't do that deal.

I think we’re getting a bit ahead of ourselves here and that’s not even taking into consideration whether or not Nas will formally request a trade back to SA.

Nas went pick 11 whilst Rachelle went 6 in the same draft. Both Nas & Rachelle have played one season of AFL. Nas played 14 games; Rachelle 13.

Both players have heaps of potential and surely it depends on how they progress in 2023.

If Nas has a breakout season off half back and Rachelle suffers a bit of second year blues it could/should be the Saints asking for the 2RDP to even out the deal.

 

[bird_man]

This lad would be worth looking at. Not contacted at years end and still on the rookie list.

 

[austinnn]

I think we’re getting a bit ahead of ourselves here and that’s not even taking into consideration whether or not Nas will formally request a trade back to SA.

Nas went pick 11 whilst Rachelle went 6 in the same draft. Both Nas & Rachelle have played one season of AFL. Nas played 14 games; Rachelle 13.

Both players have heaps of potential and surely it depends on how they progress in 2023.

If Nas has a breakout season off half back and Rachelle suffers a bit of second year blues it could/should be the Saints asking for the 2RDP to even out the deal.

My preference is to keep Nas, Doc. However we can't afford to be blindsided by a trade request if he doesn't sign an extension this year and lose a homesick pick 8 player for less than his worth.

I'm thinking of a way for him to get back to SA. Power don't have much to trade. I doubt they'll trade Rozee, and while Sinn is being talked about, he doesn't really excite me so I thought I'd look at alternatives.

Depending on Boston Everitt's progress this year, its possible we'll need loads of draft points, which could be the Steak Knives part of the puzzle, but no-one is talking about that so either I've got his draft year wrong or he's not going to be of much consequence to our draft plans.

 

[bird_man]

My preference is to keep Nas, Doc. However we can't afford to be blindsided by a trade request if he doesn't sign an extension this year and lose a homesick pick 8 player for less than his worth.

I'm thinking of a way for him to get back to SA. Power don't have much to trade. I doubt they'll trade Rozee, and while Sinn is being talked about, he doesn't really excite me so I thought I'd look at alternatives.

Depending on Boston Everitt's progress this year, its possible we'll need loads of draft points, which could be the Steak Knives part of the puzzle, but no-one is talking about that so either I've got his draft year wrong or he's not going to be of much consequence to our draft plans.

Port can trade their future first apparently (Not sure how)

I'd imagine both Sinn and Bergman would have interest from us being local lads

Both of those two for Nas and something else works for me

I don't think Everitt is looking at being at the pointy end of the draft at this stage but a long way to go

 

[Saintos The ITK]

If Naz keeps kicking directly to the opposition happy to let him go.

 

[Sarcoidevo]

If Naz keeps kicking directly to the opposition happy to let him go.

Must say as nice a kick as he is there were a few clangers v the Bummers

 

[Sarcoidevo]

Doubt we would have been able to ask for too much extra anyway.

Pretty sure Port rate him fairly highly. Taken around the same mark as Nas and has shown plenty at senior level

He has shown plenty at Senior Level?

He has played 1 game

I am sure Port would rate all their potential trade offings highly ...... yes yes we know he has only played one game in 2 years but sky's the limit with this one ..... we are certain of it .... trust us

 

[gringo2011]

He has shown plenty at Senior Level?

He has played 1 game

I am sure Port would rate all their potential trade offings highly ...... yes yes we know he has only played one game in 2 years but sky's the limit with this one ..... we are certain of it .... trust us

I think he's talking about Bergman, he's played more that Nas.

 

[bird_man]

He has shown plenty at Senior Level?

He has played 1 game

I am sure Port would rate all their potential trade offings highly ...... yes yes we know he has only played one game in 2 years but sky's the limit with this one ..... we are certain of it .... trust us

You've obviously followed his career really closely mate...

He has played 33 games

 

[Sarcoidevo]

You've obviously followed his career really closely mate...

He has played 33 games

My unreserved apologies .... Bergman looks like an ok player (doesnt really scream elite) and he has had surgery twice on his shoulder ..... I would want more than just him for Nas whose ceiling looks higher

 

[gringo2011]

Hard to know what his ceiling will be but he's a very good finisher around goal. Nas looks more like what we lack though. Played 23 games in his first year including QF and a PF. Had 2 finals games of 18 disposals. Probably more exposed form than Nas to be honest.





MILES BERGMAN

The sight of Miles Bergman in full flight on the wing pleased the Power after the 21-year-old underwent two shoulder operations and battled through illness last year to play 10 games. Bergman has shifted from half-back to the wing and looks a clear replacement for departed free agent Karl Amon

10

Karl Amon

Age

30

Ht

181cm

Wt

71kg

Pos.

Def

Career

Season

Last 5

D

16.6

4star

K

9.7

4star

HB

6.8

4star

M

3.4

3star

T

2.6

4star

MG

294.5

4star

D

21.0

5star

K

15.0

5star

HB

6.0

3star

M

6.0

5star

T

2.0

3star

D

10.4

3star

K

6.8

3star

HB

3.6

3star

M

2.6

3star

T

2.0

4star

MG

146.8

3star

. With a game-high 651m gained, his ability to cover ground offensively and defensively stood out, finishing with 25 disposals and a goal. – Nathan Schmook

Liked the look of: Who shone for your club in practice matches?

Check out the players who caught our eye during the pre-season practice matches

www.afl.com.au