List Mgmt. 2023 Trade Thread - Part III

[George]

The embedded resources below are kept up to date by the trade board mods (as much as possible – we are human after all). Enjoy!

Spoiler: 2023 Draft Order

Spoiler: 2024 Draft Order, aka Future Picks

Spoiler: Blue Tick Rumours

Courtesy of Lore

 

[austinnn]

Can confirm shiels shoe has healing properties and his feet are now fine,
Just hard to replace steele considering DS09 will be in town
View attachment 1816654

God I forgot about this. Drop our price

 

[pebblesofsand]

Even vegan pygmy floss can get the blues mate.

So can cowgirls

 

[Dr Spaceman]

Can confirm shiels shoe has healing properties and his feet are now fine,
Just hard to replace steele considering DS09 will be in town
View attachment 1816654

Nek minnit

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[MordySaint]

Adrian Dodoro ain't an Ameet Bains, he's not going to do a crappy deal on the way out the door.

Essendon will want full wack for Shiel and sell him to us like he is an 18 year old with a full career in front of him.

 

[Sully111]

Adrian Dodoro ain't an Ameet Bains, he's not going to do a crappy deal on the way out the door.

Essendon will want full wack for Shiel and sell him to us like he is an 18 year old with a full career in front of him.

He can want whatever he wants

We won't pay it

 

[_Maximus_12]

I fully expect the deal to fall through with Essendon and Hawthorn to swoop with a better offer for Gresham having missed McKay and needing to spend the money.

 

[Saintscomemarchingin]

My guess is that the eventual off list will be?

1. Adams
2. Allison- although contracted for 1 more year
3. Bytel
4. Campbell-dependant on a replacement?
5. Connolly
6. Gresham-has to be gone now, dragging on & annoying
7. Highmore
8. Howard- dependant on, if we can get good compo. for him & a risk of lacking KPD depth if we let him go.
9. McKenzie- not looking good for him, but hoping, like Jones, that they give him another season.
10. Peris

 

[nobhead]

I fully expect the deal to fall through with Essendon and Hawthorn to swoop with a better offer for Gresham having missed McKay and needing to spend the money.

Don't understand why everyone is complicating the hell out of this trade.easy fix gresham and pick 12 to them pick 8 and their 2nd to us and we will take on shiels contract .

 

[SaintsSeptember]

I fully expect the deal to fall through with Essendon and Hawthorn to swoop with a better offer for Gresham having missed McKay and needing to spend the money.

You can't tie a trade to a free agency move.
I expect its gone down like this.

Dodoro: Hi young Gresh, we can use you on our list , how much do you want.
Gresh : $750k, i'm hot property, i'm worth every penny.
Dodoro: phhhthh cough couhg, ( should have swallowed the coffee before hearing the amount ).
Dodoro: let me think a minute.
Dodoro: OK i have an idea ,we could trade that useless spud Shiel for the compensation pick, so then it would be worth paying you that much. I just need to get on the phone to SOS.
SOS: Beep Beep Beep.
Dodoro:hmmm maybe later, i'll run it by my mate Ralphy and see if he thinks it makes sense.

 

[MordySaint]

My guess is that the eventual off list will be?


6. Gresham-has to be gone now, dragging on & annoying

I find it interesting that his manager told the club not to put an offer on the table. Wait until other clubs had placed offers. i.e don't waste your time

 

[stavro#4]

I find it interesting that his manager told the club not to put an offer on the table. Wait until other clubs had placed offers. i.e don't waste your time

It would all be done verbally throughout the year.

 

[Veer Right]

He can want whatever he wants

We won't pay it

Your talking about St Kilda here and with our trading history, this club can certainly pay a stupid price. Long history of doing stupid shit.

What concerns me now that i have put more thought into it, is the Blues supporters taking shots at SOS for going after his old favourites who he has ties too.

Would we be going anywhere near an old cooked Shiel that is well past his used by date if SOS wasn't in charge?

I hope if this deal does go through and first round compo is awarded (AFL should block it but nothing surprises me really with them) we are the ones walking away with that pick. If it goes to Essendon like their supporters are hoping, i will quit supporting this club.

 

[kernelT]

Is this still the Asian Food Guide thread as well ? The thread title is confusing to me.

Should be:

2023 Trade and List Management & Asian Food Guide Thread - Part III

Home - Kites

Welcome to this website!

kitescafe.com.au

Sorry wrong thread bud, I’m stearing part 3 towards Tacos and Margs.

 

[SaintsSeptember]

Your talking about St Kilda here and with our trading history, this club can certainly pay a stupid price. Long history of doing stupid s**t.

What concerns me now that i have put more thought into it, is the Blues supporters taking shots at SOS for going after his old favourites who he has ties too.

Would we be going anywhere near an old cooked Shiel that is well past his used by date if SOS wasn't in charge?

I hope if this deal does go through and first round compo is awarded (AFL should block it but nothing surprises me really with them) we are the ones walking away with that pick. If it goes to Essendon like their supporters are hoping, i will quit supporting this club.

OK , surely the List Manager would run his idea's past the head coach, like in a meeting with recruiters, and head of footy also present.
Lyon has already commented on how many games Shiel played this year.

 

[kernelT]

My guess is that the eventual off list will be?

1. Adams
2. Allison- although contracted for 1 more year
3. Bytel
4. Campbell-dependant on a replacement?
5. Connolly
6. Gresham-has to be gone now, dragging on & annoying
7. Highmore
8. Howard- dependant on, if we can get good compo. for him & a risk of lacking KPD depth if we let him go.
9. McKenzie- not looking good for him, but hoping, like Jones, that they give him another season.
10. Peris

Can we find 10 players worthy of replacing all those though?
Dow, Henry, Lobb

Couple of draftees.

It would be nice to have space for the supp top-ups I guess.

 

[stavro#4]

OK , surely the List Manager would run his idea's past the head coach, like in a meeting with recruiters, and head of footy also present.
Lyon has already commented on how many games Shiel played this year.

We have met with Shiel.

Ross knows directly from him what injuries he had etc.

I’m 90-95% certain he ends up a saint

 

[stavro#4]

Your talking about St Kilda here and with our trading history, this club can certainly pay a stupid price. Long history of doing stupid s**t.

What concerns me now that i have put more thought into it, is the Blues supporters taking shots at SOS for going after his old favourites who he has ties too.

Would we be going anywhere near an old cooked Shiel that is well past his used by date if SOS wasn't in charge?

I hope if this deal does go through and first round compo is awarded (AFL should block it but nothing surprises me really with them) we are the ones walking away with that pick. If it goes to Essendon like their supporters are hoping, i will quit supporting this club.

The AFL have said that the compo pick can’t be traded back to Essendon according to the Ralph article.

So that means the only picks that can go Essendons way are 12,32,51

The deal makes even less sense if we start giving Essendon a pick infront of us!

 

[SaintsSeptember]

We have met with Shiel.

Ross knows directly from him what injuries he had etc.

I’m 90-95% certain he ends up a saint

Not for a first round pick.

 

[stavro#4]

Not for a first round pick.

I’d hope not. I believe it won’t be.

But who knows?

 

[MordySaint]

We have met with Shiel.

Ross knows directly from him what injuries he had etc.

I’m 90-95% certain he ends up a saint

To be fair to the supporters, that is what they said about Hannebery, Jones and every other old bloke we have thrown good money at for little return.

Come on Ross, please don't go down that well beaten path again.

 

[Sun Ra]

Can we find 10 players worthy of replacing all those though?
Dow, Henry, Lobb

Couple of draftees.

It would be nice to have space for the supp top-ups I guess.

Anyone but Lobb thanks. He moves clubs too often for me. Not a pressing need anyway.

 

[SaintsSeptember]

The fact that there's been no announcement by Gresham yet might mean that he's either got multiple offers to choose between or he's simply not happy with what he's been offered to date.

 

[stavro#4]

To be fair to the supporters, that is what they said about Hannebery, Jones and every other old bloke we have thrown good money at for little return.

Come on Ross, please don't go down that well beaten path again.

If you are worried.

Has SOS made a trade where he sent a top 15 pick to a club for a 31 year old injury prone player who’s on the decline before?

It isn’t in his M.O

He does however have a history of sending out later picks to see if he can find value in others junk.

 

[stavro#4]

The fact that there's been no announcement by Gresham yet might mean that he's either got multiple offers to choose between or he's simply not happy with what he's been offered to date.

BnF is Monday.

Probably wait until that’s done

 

[saintmike65]

Don't understand why everyone is complicating the hell out of this trade.easy fix gresham and pick 12 to them pick 8 and their 2nd to us and we will take on shiels contract .

That’s the only way us giving them our first pick makes any sense