Juan Ide
Team Captain
- May 19, 2022
- 513
- 817
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
So Fin for Murphy? LOL
Prediction 2024 Best 23
- Thread starter Peter Sidorkiewicz
- Start date
- Tagged users None
sr36
Hall of Famer
Basically, the final 3 quarters of the GF, but with Finn as sub, Frampton replaced by one of the other marking talls and Schultz in for Ginni.
That's what I'd do if everyone remains fit and Murphy hasn't jumped enough hoops by round 1.
sadako1999
Debutant
- Oct 4, 2003
- 133
- 120
If Murphy doesn’t play - Frampton may be best suited for Hogan…
- Nov 16, 2014
- 5,791
- 10,170
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
After yesterday’s practice game… rd 1 team will likely be the GF team with
Out: Ginnivan, Murphy
In: Schulz, Lipinski
Frampton to move to defence. Or maybe Dean gets the nod instead
Noble not far off
But saw little chance of others getting selected
Despite some form Fin Macrae needs an injury to break into the midfield imo
And likewise no certainty for mine that Johnson or McInness are included inside 50
Out: Ginnivan, Murphy
In: Schulz, Lipinski
Frampton to move to defence. Or maybe Dean gets the nod instead
Noble not far off
But saw little chance of others getting selected
Despite some form Fin Macrae needs an injury to break into the midfield imo
And likewise no certainty for mine that Johnson or McInness are included inside 50
In: Dean, Schultz, McInnes, Macrae
Out: Murphy, Ginnivan, Frampton, WHE (sub)
Out: Murphy, Ginnivan, Frampton, WHE (sub)
ElliottsMaggies
Norm Smith Medallist
- Mar 28, 2023
- 7,867
- 15,497
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
You're leaving Lippa out? I'm not so sure with the pre-season he's been having.
He looks like he has no muscle on his frame. He looks like he just stepped out for a kick with his mates whereas his teammates all look cut, defined and hard.
- Jun 10, 2014
- 14,092
- 35,989
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
I think that is what Domey is doing when he assesses our boys as cut, defined and hard?
Spiral_Out
Team Captain
It's pretty simple, assuming everyone is fit.
Out: Ginni, Murphy
In: Schultz, McInnes
Frampton goes back to cover Murphy, Lipinski starts and McInnes sub.
Apart from that there's layers to think about that I'm sure the coaches are also pondering.
Macrae banging on the door and comes in for any mid/winger that gets injured. Sullivan looks pretty damn good though, so I'm letting them battle it out for the first few rounds in the VFL and perhaps we give the older mids a rest every 3-4 games so Macrae/Sullivan is basically always in the team, Pendlebury, Sidebottom, Mitchell and borderline Elliott.
Worked wonders for Geelong in 2022 and they dominated the entire year.
Dean next in line for any defender that gets injured and same for Johnson for the forwards.
Out: Ginni, Murphy
In: Schultz, McInnes
Frampton goes back to cover Murphy, Lipinski starts and McInnes sub.
Apart from that there's layers to think about that I'm sure the coaches are also pondering.
Macrae banging on the door and comes in for any mid/winger that gets injured. Sullivan looks pretty damn good though, so I'm letting them battle it out for the first few rounds in the VFL and perhaps we give the older mids a rest every 3-4 games so Macrae/Sullivan is basically always in the team, Pendlebury, Sidebottom, Mitchell and borderline Elliott.
Worked wonders for Geelong in 2022 and they dominated the entire year.
Dean next in line for any defender that gets injured and same for Johnson for the forwards.
How I think we line up for OR.
B: B.Maynard - D.Moore - I.Quaynor
HB: O.Markov - J.Howe - J.Crisp
C: S.Sidebottom - S.Pendlebury - J.Daicos
HF: L.Schulz - B.Mihocek - B.McCreery
F: B.Hill - R.McInnes - J.Elliott
R: D.Cameron - J.DeGoey - N.Daicos
I: W.Hoskin-Elliott - M.Cox - T.Mitchell - F.Macrae - P.Lipinski
Best 23 Unavailable: D.McStay, N.Murphy
Next up: B.Frampton, J.Noble, A.Johnson
In the mix: L.Sullivan, H.Harrison, N.Kreuger, E.Allan, C.Dean
B: B.Maynard - D.Moore - I.Quaynor
HB: O.Markov - J.Howe - J.Crisp
C: S.Sidebottom - S.Pendlebury - J.Daicos
HF: L.Schulz - B.Mihocek - B.McCreery
F: B.Hill - R.McInnes - J.Elliott
R: D.Cameron - J.DeGoey - N.Daicos
I: W.Hoskin-Elliott - M.Cox - T.Mitchell - F.Macrae - P.Lipinski
Best 23 Unavailable: D.McStay, N.Murphy
Next up: B.Frampton, J.Noble, A.Johnson
In the mix: L.Sullivan, H.Harrison, N.Kreuger, E.Allan, C.Dean
Last edited:
This looks pretty close for me, I still have Murphy in the side but having a hard time who drops out when he gets up for opening round.
- May 7, 2011
- 54,372
- 13,156
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
- Other Teams
- Celtics, Tottenham, Oakland Raiders
He IS really quick...
Reckon the next practice game will give us a greater indication. At this stage clearly Murphy is unlikely.
If we are going off our Premiership side I would make 2 changes.
Clear one is Schultz for Ginnivan.
With Murphy unlikely, do we push Frampton back? I think he stays in the 23 for versatility especially with Murphy.
Just a guessing game but personal opinion I would have either McInnes or Macrae come in for Murphy and move some magnets around.
Line up:
B - Maynard Moore Quaynor
HB - Markov Howe Crisp
C - J.Daicos DeGoey Sidebottom
HF - McCreery Mihochek Schultz
F - Elliott Cox Hill
R - Cameron N.Daicos Pendlebury
INT - Mitchell Lipinski WHE
Then between the following 3 there is the last spot on the pine plus sub - Frampton/McInnes/Macrae
If we are going off our Premiership side I would make 2 changes.
Clear one is Schultz for Ginnivan.
With Murphy unlikely, do we push Frampton back? I think he stays in the 23 for versatility especially with Murphy.
Just a guessing game but personal opinion I would have either McInnes or Macrae come in for Murphy and move some magnets around.
Line up:
B - Maynard Moore Quaynor
HB - Markov Howe Crisp
C - J.Daicos DeGoey Sidebottom
HF - McCreery Mihochek Schultz
F - Elliott Cox Hill
R - Cameron N.Daicos Pendlebury
INT - Mitchell Lipinski WHE
Then between the following 3 there is the last spot on the pine plus sub - Frampton/McInnes/Macrae
I’m expecting he’s best 22 and would be in my best until something changes,
For Round 0 v GWS, starting with our GF line-up:
OUT - Ginni, Murphy
IN - Schultz, Johnson
Frampton moves to defence to replace Murph. AJ comes in to replace Frampton up forward. He has by far the most credits at AFL level amongst the key forward contenders.
Nobody else has done enough yet to force their way in to our Premiership side. No gifted games when trying to go back-to-back.
The likes of Macrae, McInnes and Noble will need to wait for the inevitable injuries to get their chances and will need to grab them strongly when they come.
Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com
OUT - Ginni, Murphy
IN - Schultz, Johnson
Frampton moves to defence to replace Murph. AJ comes in to replace Frampton up forward. He has by far the most credits at AFL level amongst the key forward contenders.
Nobody else has done enough yet to force their way in to our Premiership side. No gifted games when trying to go back-to-back.
The likes of Macrae, McInnes and Noble will need to wait for the inevitable injuries to get their chances and will need to grab them strongly when they come.
Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com
Last edited:
Gone Critical
Moderator
- Moderator
- #223
Pretty close to the mark
I agree re AJ. He is clearly the most proven at AFL level where he has looked dangerous frequently. Coming off clearly his best pre season and given he looked good in the NM practice match all he needs is to look good in the Richmond game and he is locked in.
Other one that is much closer than it looks is Markov Noble. There was little between them last year and Markov was the lucky one in the end. If JFN outperforms Markov in the Rich game he could get that spot. One of the few GF spots that isnt locked in
AJ will get first crack before Reef
- Sep 26, 2012
- 34,946
- 51,838
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
Murphy potential unavailability has thrown a real spanner in the works for me
